placebo
An inert treatment (such as saline or a sugar pill) given to a control group so that the active treatment's effect can be isolated.
As defined in Adam Cifu on Ending Medical Reversal
Other definitions
An inactive treatment used as a control in clinical trials to separate drug effects from expectation or disease course.
Dinakar Singh - A Father’s Call To Action - [Invest Like the Best, EP.428]
Where it comes up · 10
- Adam Cifu on Ending Medical Reversal5 claims
- Unconventional But Effective Therapy for Alzheimer's Treatment: Dr. Mary T. Newport at TEDxUSF2 claims
- Jonathan Skinner on Health Care Costs, Technology, and Rising Mortality1 claim
- Anupam Bapu Jena on Random Acts of Medicine1 claim
- 272 - On Disappointing My Audience1 claim
- Dinakar Singh - A Father’s Call To Action - [Invest Like the Best, EP.428]1 claim
- The Disruptive Potential of GenAI for Emerging Markets | Rem Koning | Leading with AI1 claim
- 216 | John Allen Paulos on Numbers, Narratives, and Numeracy1 claim
and 2 more
Most important claims · 10 of 15Search all claims for “placebo” →
- Trials stopped early because an effect looks dramatic tend to overestimate the benefit of a treatment, because across many studies outcomes vary by chance and stopping at a favorable moment captures the high-variance positive result rather than the true effect.Adam Cifu on Ending Medical Reversal
- Statins offer a parallel to vaccines: roughly 4-5% of people get real side effects (and Harris is one), but a grown-up understands that any intervention harms some individuals for complex reasons while the aggregate risk can be assessed, so personal bad reactions do not justify movements claiming the drug is a crime of the century.272 - On Disappointing My Audience
- When a procedure can harm patients and turns out to be no better than sham, being randomized to the placebo group is actually beneficial—an insurance policy—and conducting the sham trial spares future patients from undergoing a useless or harmful procedure.Adam Cifu on Ending Medical Reversal
- A rigorous trial randomized spinal-compression-fracture patients to real vertebroplasty (injecting medical cement) or a sham procedure (full prep, opening cement so patients could smell it, but injecting only saline), and found no difference in pain, quality of life, or activity scores over the first month—showing the procedure's apparent benefit was a placebo effect.Adam Cifu on Ending Medical Reversal
- Atenolol (marketed as Tenormin) lowers blood pressure as well as most other antihypertensives, but pooled placebo-controlled studies show it does not improve mortality or heart attack risk and only slightly reduces stroke risk, illustrating that a drug can succeed on the surrogate endpoint yet fail on clinical endpoints.Adam Cifu on Ending Medical Reversal
- The FDA agreed to replace placebo-controlled trials with a natural history study, in which the team paid for patient care for several years to build a log of disease progression, and trial results were compared to that log, saving children who would otherwise have been on placebo.Dinakar Singh - A Father’s Call To Action - [Invest Like the Best, EP.428]
- The nocebo effect occurs when something that would have a positive effect loses that effect because the person believes it is harmful (as when Ipecac, designed to induce vomiting, stopped vomiting in people told it would); recognizing this means people are capable of giving themselves a placebo intentionally, potentially eliminating the need for the placebo itself.279 | Ellen Langer on Mindfulness and the Body
- In a randomized controlled trial, patients are randomly assigned to treatment or placebo so the groups are on average identical in all risk factors—both those you know and those you don't know yet—meaning any difference in outcome at the end is due to the intervention itself.Adam Cifu on Ending Medical Reversal
- For mild to moderate depression it is very difficult to find any advantage of antidepressants over placebos in populations, and even in severely depressed people antidepressants do only slightly better than placebos, with cure rates only in the 40-60% range.Gary Greenberg on Depression, Addiction, and the Brain 09/27/2010
- Just as high-tech job applicants are tested on relevant skills, candidates for Congress or president face no comparable numeracy or knowledge test, and perhaps they should — though such standards would need to avoid arbitrary requirements (like Heinlein's quadratic equation or solving algebra) and instead test feel for scaling, estimation, and basic scientific concepts like placebos and double-blind studies.216 | John Allen Paulos on Numbers, Narratives, and Numeracy