physics envy
The (pejorative) tendency in social sciences to imitate physics' methods and precision, despite social systems being far messier and harder to simplify.
As defined in 330 | Petter Törnberg on the Dynamics of (Mis)Information
Where it comes up · 5
- Johnathan Bi on Mimesis and René Girard1 claim
- Ernie Garcia - Disrupting the Auto Buying Experience - [Founder’s Field Guide, EP. 45]1 claim
- Tim Price: Rules for Understanding and Investing Through a New Bretton Woods Moment1 claim
- 296 | Brandon Ogbunu on Fitness Seascapes and the Course of Evolution1 claim
- 330 | Petter Törnberg on the Dynamics of (Mis)Information1 claim
Most important claims · 5 of 5Search all claims for “physics envy” →
- Economics wanted to run on the rails of mathematics out of physics envy, and the easiest way to do so was to model people as rational utility-maximizing creatures, because once you inject the social dimension you can no longer use quantity as the fundamental language--you must use quality, describing what is being traded and why.Johnathan Bi on Mimesis and René Girard
- Modern economics was born from physics envy: economists like Léon Walras became convinced that if differential calculus could describe planetary and atomic motion, it could also describe human economic behavior, but this category error is the core problem.Tim Price: Rules for Understanding and Investing Through a New Bretton Woods Moment
- Physics succeeds because its fundamental objects have few moving parts and can be described with few variables, but social science deals with messy, many-variable human systems; therefore trying to make social science too much like physics ('physics envy') is a mistake, even though physics-style concepts like equilibrium and emergence can still be usefully borrowed.330 | Petter Törnberg on the Dynamics of (Mis)Information
- Three main problems plague prediction in contemporary biology: physics envy (a learned-from-Gould desire for neat, clean physical-style laws), being incorrigible uncritical categorizers, and 'giddiness' (Doc Edge's term for the overconfident belief that we will solve all problems just by sequencing and collecting more and more data)—together producing overconfidence that we even know what we are doing with deeply complicated, environment-shaped traits.296 | Brandon Ogbunu on Fitness Seascapes and the Course of Evolution
- Investors exhibit 'physics envy' — a tendency to always try to cram business reality into clean formulas like the 'seven powers' framework for competitive advantage.Ernie Garcia - Disrupting the Auto Buying Experience - [Founder’s Field Guide, EP. 45]