physicalist
Someone who holds that everything, including consciousness, is ultimately physical and describable in terms of physical processes.
As defined in 284 | Doris Tsao on How the Brain Turns Vision Into the World
Where it comes up · 5
- 284 | Doris Tsao on How the Brain Turns Vision Into the World2 claims
- Elijah Millgram1 claim
- 404 - What If Consciousness Is Fundamental1 claim
- 306 - Psychedelics Mortality1 claim
- 311 | Annaka Harris on Whether Consciousness is Fundamental1 claim
Most important claims · 6 of 6Search all claims for “physicalist” →
- Drawing on Tom Clark's physicalist essay, Sam argues that even if consciousness ceases when the brain dies, there can be no positive experience of oblivion—just as there was no abyss before birth—because consciousness is always present for itself and never experiences its own absence; what we take to be interruptions like sleep or anesthesia are merely lapses in memory, yielding a fairly mystical view of continuity consistent with physicalist assumptions about an impersonal consciousness.306 - Psychedelics Mortality
- Treating consciousness as fundamental is fully compatible with physicalism and leaves the behavior of physical stuff exactly as current physics describes it; any thought experiment that contradicts well-established physics should be ruled out, so the view defers to existing science rather than altering predictions.311 | Annaka Harris on Whether Consciousness is Fundamental
- We don't need to invent new laws of physics to describe consciousness, because we understand the laws of physics far better than we understand consciousness; it is cart-before-the-horse to think we should change the laws of physics to help understand consciousness, and Laplace's demon could in principle predict the body's behavior entirely in terms of atoms without ever using words like consciousness, entropy, or temperature.284 | Doris Tsao on How the Brain Turns Vision Into the World
- If a hypothetical zombie behaves exactly like a conscious creature—saying yes when asked if it is conscious, crying at sad stories—then a physicalist who regards consciousness as an emergent, higher-level way of describing things would simply call that being conscious; there is nothing more to consciousness than that physical behavior.284 | Doris Tsao on How the Brain Turns Vision Into the World
- Harris states she still considers herself a physicalist and has not landed on believing consciousness is fundamental; she only believes it is a legitimate question worth exploring, and that if consciousness is fundamental, existing physics and math likely already explain the structure of consciousness.404 - What If Consciousness Is Fundamental
- In teaching personal-identity puzzles, bright students never run out of trenchant objections to the arguments—Millgram has compiled over 30 pages of objections to a 25-page paper—so when asked his resolved view in a problem space where objections demonstrably never run out, he honestly has no settled view.Elijah Millgram