phenomenal consciousness
The 'what it's like' aspect of mind—subjective experience that feels like something, as opposed to unconscious neural processing.
As defined in Do All Creatures, Great and Small, and Made From Silicon, Have Rights? (with Jeff Sebo)
Where it comes up · 7
- 339 | Ned Block on Whether Consciousness Requires Biology4 claims
- Do All Creatures, Great and Small, and Made From Silicon, Have Rights? (with Jeff Sebo)3 claims
- 354 | Christian List on Free Will and Levels of Reality3 claims
- 264 - Consciousness And Self Rebroadcast1 claim
- 292 | Jonathan Birch on Animal Sentience1 claim
- AMA | July 20251 claim
- Mindscape Ask Me Anything, Sean Carroll | August 20261 claim
Most important claims · 10 of 14Search all claims for “phenomenal consciousness” →
- Phenomenal consciousness, following Nagel's 'What Is It Like to Be a Bat?', refers to subjective experience—the fact that it feels like something to perceive red, hear a trumpet, or feel pain—as distinct from unconscious processing like regulating heartbeat or digestion, and the open question is which kinds of beings can have such experiences and how far this extends in and beyond the tree of life.Do All Creatures, Great and Small, and Made From Silicon, Have Rights? (with Jeff Sebo)
- The term consciousness conflates at least three distinct things: phenomenal consciousness (the 'what it's like' of experience), access consciousness (global availability of perceptual information to cognitive mechanisms), and transitive consciousness or 'consciousness of' (a state being conscious in virtue of another state being directed at it).339 | Ned Block on Whether Consciousness Requires Biology
- Given how much is currently unknown about the nature of phenomenal consciousness, it would be premature to be highly confident either that it will or will not feel like something to be near-future AI systems; we should presume such systems will exist and remain fairly uncertain whether and at what point it will feel like anything to be them—which defines our predicament when deciding whether to scale this technology.Do All Creatures, Great and Small, and Made From Silicon, Have Rights? (with Jeff Sebo)
- Whether a sufficiently advanced silicon-based being (like a Westworld robot) can genuinely feel pleasure and pain is subject to real uncertainty on two axes: the ethics axis (what capacity—sentience, consciousness, or agency—is the basis for moral standing) and the science axis (whether silicon chips can actually realize those capacities), making it genuinely confusing how to treat such a being.Do All Creatures, Great and Small, and Made From Silicon, Have Rights? (with Jeff Sebo)
- Phenomenal consciousness—the 'what it's like' of experience—cannot be defined; one can only point to it, which is why it generates persistent misunderstanding where some people deny knowing what is even being referred to.339 | Ned Block on Whether Consciousness Requires Biology
- Consciousness is the presence of any kind of subjective experience whatsoever, and we should resist demanding a fixed technical definition because scientific definitions co-evolve with understanding rather than being transcribed into knowledge unidirectionally.264 - Consciousness And Self Rebroadcast
- While external colors are the most obviously objective thing, the phenomenology of color experience is also objective—it's just that we currently don't know how to measure it.339 | Ned Block on Whether Consciousness Requires Biology
- A recent Anthropic paper suggests LLMs may develop a form of access consciousness through a 'J-Space' of internal neural patterns that play a special role, letting the model think about concepts without writing them down.Mindscape Ask Me Anything, Sean Carroll | August 2026
- Phenomenal consciousness can occur without access consciousness: experiences may exist in an isolated part of cortex completely cut off from access, and Freudian repression—being repression in the access sense—illustrates how a vivid phenomenal experience could persist with its phenomenal qualities intact while being inaccessible.339 | Ned Block on Whether Consciousness Requires Biology
- Sentience, defined as the capacity for valenced experience (experiences that feel good or bad, like pain and pleasure), captures the most basic, evolutionarily ancient layer of consciousness, and it is this capacity that makes a system's interests matter morally, requiring us to act.292 | Jonathan Birch on Animal Sentience