pay-for-performance
Paying healthcare providers financial incentives tied to meeting quality or outcome targets.
As defined in Atul Gawande
Where it comes up · 4
- Jerry Muller on the Tyranny of Metrics4 claims
- Atul Gawande1 claim
- Evolution designed us to die fast; we can change that — Jacob Kimmel1 claim
- Arnold Kling on Hospitals and Health Care 06/30/20081 claim
Most important claims · 7 of 7Search all claims for “pay-for-performance” →
- Pay-for-performance schemes for hospitals are undermined by a reporting problem: when local providers do the reporting, they game the metrics—for example, a death may be listed as caused by cancer rather than a hospital-borne infection to avoid being penalized—because managing performance from a central distance invites manipulation.Arnold Kling on Hospitals and Health Care 06/30/2008
- Long-durability medicines whose benefits accrue years later face a reimbursement problem because Americans change insurers every 3-4 years, so no insurer is incentivized to cover a benefit realized in the out-years; a pay-for-performance model—paying a fraction of the cost each year contingent on demonstrated ongoing benefit—aligns incentives, treating the therapeutic's cost-lowering effect like a pre-existing condition that follows the patient between payers.Evolution designed us to die fast; we can change that — Jacob Kimmel
- An Ariadne experiment with South Carolina over five years got surgeons to voluntarily adopt the safe surgery checklist—without regulation (a red state unwilling to mandate) and without financial incentives (no money for pay-for-performance)—reaching 40 percent of the population and lowering the death rate 22 percent, but reaching the remaining 60 percent would require adding a mandate or other component.Atul Gawande
- Matthew Arnold, a school inspector, predicted that Robert Lowe's 1860s pay-for-performance scheme for British schools would penalize schools serving poor students and would narrow the focus of schooling to only the things tested by inspectors—anticipating the same dynamics that recurred in the late 20th century.Jerry Muller on the Tyranny of Metrics
- The tyranny of metrics is a pattern combining three individually plausible beliefs—that standardized numerical measurement should replace fallible human judgment, that people are best motivated by attaching rewards and penalties to measured performance, and that accountability is achieved by publishing those standardized measures—which in combination turn out to be counterproductive.Jerry Muller on the Tyranny of Metrics
- The right approach is not metrics versus judgment but metrics informed and modified by judgment; even pay-for-performance can be functional when what is measured and rewarded genuinely accords with the professional goals and intrinsic motivation of the people in the organization, such as rewarding a hospital and its physicians for improving patient safety.Jerry Muller on the Tyranny of Metrics
- No Child Left Behind's regime of testing, publicizing results, and rewarding/punishing schools had absolutely no effect on the achievement gap between white and black/Hispanic students, but it did narrow the range and depth of subjects taught as teaching was reoriented toward maximizing test scores.Jerry Muller on the Tyranny of Metrics