panpsychism
The view that consciousness or proto-conscious properties are fundamental and ubiquitous features of physical reality.
As defined in ms_ama_october_2024
Other definitions
A philosophical view proposing that consciousness or proto-consciousness is a fundamental property of all matter, not unique to brains; consciousness emerges from combining micro-consciousnesses in fundamental particles
Existential physics: answering life's biggest questions - with Sabine Hossenfelder
Where it comes up · 49
- 159 - Conscious7 claims
- 71 | Philip Goff on Consciousness Everywhere7 claims
- 262 | Eric Schwitzgebel on the Weirdness of the World6 claims
- 34 - The Light Of The Mind3 claims
- 149 | Lee Smolin on Time, Philosophy, and the Nature of Reality3 claims
- Micheal Pollan On The Mystery Of Consciousness.2 claims
- Existential physics: answering life's biggest questions - with Sabine Hossenfelder2 claims
- 404 - What If Consciousness Is Fundamental2 claims
and 41 more
Most important claims · 10 of 74Search all claims for “panpsychism” →
- When confronting a far-out idea like panpsychist consciousness as a fundamental force, the proper scientific method is to test all the possibilities within existing constructs first rather than jumping to the most exotic explanation; to accept the exotic theory you must either find evidence for it or show the phenomenon is impossible without it, and we are very far from that.Lisa Randall
- Bizarreness can dissipate not by being refuted but because our intuitions and sense of common sense change over time—just as a heliocentric Earth orbiting the Sun was bizarre when Copernicus proposed it but is no longer felt to violate common sense—so it is possible that some day people will find it commonsensical that the United States is conscious or that the universe is conscious (panpsychism); common sense is not a fixed point.262 | Eric Schwitzgebel on the Weirdness of the World
- Many Worlds and panpsychism share a structural appeal: Many Worlds avoids hidden variables and observers (just Schrödinger), while panpsychism's 'consciousness all the way down' avoids dualism and arbitrary brain-complexity justifications (just experience), suggesting fundamental consciousness might be the cost of explaining the hard problem just as branching universes is the cost of Many Worlds.AMA | May 2025
- The distinction between what matter does and what matter is makes no sense; matter is the physical universe, which is sui generis with nothing to explain it in terms of, so all of science describes what matter does, and the desire to say matter is something else is a leftover from pre-scientific thinking. Carroll's best current description is a vector in Hilbert space.AMA | March 2022
- If consciousness is distinct from its physical correlates and the physical world is a causally closed network where every physical event has a physical cause, then consciousness is almost forced to be an epiphenomenon; to avoid this, one must either place consciousness inside the physical network at the fundamental level (panpsychism) or deny causal closure (e.g., a role in quantum wave-function collapse).34 - The Light Of The Mind
- The zombie argument for non-physical consciousness is self-defeating because if zombies (physically identical beings without conscious experience) are truly conceivable, they would report being conscious and even write books defending consciousness—since reporting is a behavior obeying physics—which means introspection is entirely unreliable; thus any 'consciousness' that has no effect on behavior is not the consciousness we actually mean.AMA | November 2021
- All versions of panpsychism encountered to date face not only philosophical problems but also scientific problems: panpsychism itself is not testable and does not lead to testable predictions; only if specific panpsychist theories come up with mathematical principles specifying under what conditions consciousness arises could they become scientifically testable.What Creates Consciousness? | World Science Festival
- If consciousness emerged through evolution it should have been metabolically costly and selected for because it conferred differential survival or reproductive advantage; but if consciousness is not actually doing anything causal, its evolutionary emergence is mysterious, which leads some—including Annika—to consider that consciousness might instead be a fundamental feature of all matter present in minimal forms.159 - Conscious
- Consciousness is neither an on-off switch nor a single-valued spectrum; there are degrees of sentience (humans more than cats, cats more than earthworms, etc.), but consciousness comprises different aspects acquired along the evolutionary tree, such as the ability to imagine the future, which some organisms have and others lack entirely rather than possessing partially.AMA | May 2021
- Panpsychism is the right kind of idea but fails on two counts: it is too restrictive because it traps little units of consciousness inside interface objects like electrons and lets them combine into the consciousness of atoms, which over-constrains the solution set using interface concepts; and it has never been turned into a mathematically precise scientific theory.178 - The Reality Illusion