causal

Zombie conceivability undermines introspective evidence

The zombie argument for non-physical consciousness is self-defeating because if zombies (physically identical beings without conscious experience) are truly conceivable, they would report being conscious and even write books defending consciousness—since reporting is a behavior obeying physics—which means introspection is entirely unreliable; thus any 'consciousness' that has no effect on behavior is not the consciousness we actually mean.

causalpending

Speaker

Sean Carroll

Evidence Quote

“if you can conceive of zombies, the zombies are reporting what they take to be their innermost experiences... the zombie thought experiment provides excellent evidence that if zombies are conceivable, then introspection is entirely unreliable... What kind of conscience is it that has no effect on my behaviour at all?”

Source

AMA | November 2021— Sean Carroll's Mindscape
Created: 6/13/2026, 3:36:38 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...