overdiagnosis
Detecting disease (often via screening) that would never have caused symptoms or harm, leading to unnecessary treatment.
As defined in Robert Aronowitz on Risky Medicine
Where it comes up · 3
- Robert Aronowitz on Risky Medicine2 claims
- Ezekiel Emanuel1 claim
- 98 - Into The Dark Land1 claim
Most important claims · 4 of 4Search all claims for “overdiagnosis” →
- Early detection of cancer helps when the tumor burden is minimal and the cancer is genuinely detected, but overdetection is a real problem: most early thyroid cancers detected look malignant under the microscope but never become pathological, as illustrated by overdiagnosis in South Korea.98 - Into The Dark Land
- Screening mammography is in many ways the cause of the rapidly rising incidence of breast cancer diagnoses through the 1970s–1990s: it detected more cancers, more people were treated, prevalence rose, and as the disease seemed everywhere, people feared it more—yet getting screened is offered as the antidote to that fear, creating a self-fulfilling, self-feeding cycle.Robert Aronowitz on Risky Medicine
- Five-year survival statistics are misleading because we increasingly diagnose cancers that would never have harmed the patient; early diagnosis of small breast cancers gives the US the world's highest five-year survival, yet overall breast cancer mortality hasn't really changed, and aggressive prostate cancer treatment causes side effects like impotence and incontinence without much mortality benefit—so the right metric is overall population mortality controlled for disease stage.Ezekiel Emanuel
- A JAMA estimate suggests that out of 10,000 women getting annual mammograms (age 50-59), only about 10 deaths are averted while there are over 6,000 false positives and roughly 900 biopsies showing nothing, plus overdiagnosis leading to unnecessary mastectomies and radiation risk—a tragically imprecise tradeoff that the culture treats as a no-brainer.Robert Aronowitz on Risky Medicine