negative mimesis
The inverse of mimetic desire: wanting to be distant from objects and values associated with low-status models, driven by resentment rather than admiration.
As defined in Johnathan Bi on Mimesis and René Girard
Where it comes up · 1
Most important claims · 3 of 3Search all claims for “negative mimesis” →
- The lie of Romanticism is that it confuses difference for autonomy and distance for authenticity: the modern narrative that being different from the group means being authentic is false, since rebellion can be just as rigidly conformist--exemplified by Marlon Brando's biker who, asked what he is rebelling against, answers 'What do you got?', rebelling against whatever is presented without standing for anything.Johnathan Bi on Mimesis and René Girard
- Metaphysical desire works in reverse too: just as we want objects associated with models of heightened being, we want to be distant from objects associated with models that have a deficiency of being--avoiding the brands and places of social outcasts. This negative mode is Nietzsche's resentment, illustrated by a friend whose progressive economics was really a localized hatred of the rich who made him feel small, and who later became an investment banker because he never disliked money, he wanted it.Johnathan Bi on Mimesis and René Girard
- The tech founder who shows up to a fancy dinner party of $500 suits in a $5 T-shirt is not authentic but engaged in negative imitation--playing the same status game by accelerated means, because treating the group's core value of expensive dress as nothing is a bigger power move than out-spending them with a $5,000 suit, signaling superiority by dismissing their value entirely.Johnathan Bi on Mimesis and René Girard