natural state
A society (the most prevalent historical form) that limits access to organizations, restricting political and economic competition, distributing privileges, and dispersing violence potential, resulting in chronic disputes and slow growth.
As defined in Barry Weingast on Law
Where it comes up · 3
- Barry Weingast on Violence, Power and a Theory of Nearly Everything 8/13/20075 claims
- Barry Weingast on Law4 claims
- A History of Philosophy | 30 Thomas Hobbes1 claim
Most important claims · 10 of 10Search all claims for “natural state” →
- Hobbes distinguishes between the natural state (a condition of conflict and power struggle with no natural right other than the desire to survive, and no natural law in the Aquinas sense) and natural law (which he redefines as the dictates of right reason—consequentialist thinking about the effects of actions).A History of Philosophy | 30 Thomas Hobbes
- In natural states no one holds a monopoly on violence; instead violence is distributed among many specialists, so the key to peace is ensuring these specialists in violence don't fight by creating rents that give them a stake in peace.Barry Weingast on Violence, Power and a Theory of Nearly Everything 8/13/2007
- There are three types of societies ('orders'): the primitive order (small hunter-gatherer bands of 25-200 with little specialization or wealth accumulation), the limited access order or 'natural state' which solves violence through limited access, and the open access order.Barry Weingast on Violence, Power and a Theory of Nearly Everything 8/13/2007
- Natural states are best understood not as a single dictator controlling access but as a dominant coalition of many specialists in violence and economic activity who respect one another's privileges and thereby prevent violence.Barry Weingast on Violence, Power and a Theory of Nearly Everything 8/13/2007
- A key advantage of open access societies is the ability to provide benefits impersonally—by virtue of being a citizen or being in a certain condition (unemployment insurance, poverty relief, health benefits)—whereas natural states distribute benefits through who you know and what patronage system or organization you belong to.Barry Weingast on Violence, Power and a Theory of Nearly Everything 8/13/2007
- Natural states progress through stages distinguished by their organizations: fragile (only the state organization, prone to collapse—Chad, Somalia, Rwanda, Afghanistan), basic (differentiated organizations but all part of the state), and mature (private but elite-based organizations with privilege); effective development helps a country move along this progression rather than leap to open access.Barry Weingast on Violence, Power and a Theory of Nearly Everything 8/13/2007
- Most societies throughout history have been 'natural states' that limit access to organizations, restricting competition in politics and economics, distributing a set of privileges, and dispersing violence potential, producing chronic disputes and violence; these are by far the most prevalent and long-lived form of government in human civilization.Barry Weingast on Law
- Societies like ancient Greece emerged from the natural state because they were trading states; facilitating trade and getting rich beyond a self-sufficient landlord's level required a different set of rules, leading them to create law with legal attributes and stewards and a much wider body of citizens.Barry Weingast on Law
- Aid organizations (World Bank, IMF, USAID) design legal systems based on a flawed conception of law as sovereign commands, leading them to transplant developed-world institutions (legislatures, constitutions, separation of powers) into natural states where dispersed violence potential makes such institutions fail, because they lack the necessary legal attributes and steward function and ignore that law is separate from enforcement.Barry Weingast on Law
- Developed societies that support property rights, contracts, stable political systems, and economic growth are relatively rare—no more than about two dozen on the planet, roughly 10-15% of all countries—while the rest remain natural states.Barry Weingast on Law