multiple equilibria
A situation in which a system can settle into more than one stable state, so similar conditions can lead to very different persistent outcomes depending on history.
As defined in Chris Blattman
Where it comes up · 8
- Michael Munger on Obedience to the Unenforceable2 claims
- The Three Body Portfolio1 claim
- Bryan Caplan1 claim
- Chris Blattman1 claim
- Patrick Collison1 claim
- Robin Hanson1 claim
- Guillermo Calvo on the Crisis, Money, and Macro1 claim
- Michael Munger on Industrial Policy1 claim
Most important claims · 9 of 9Search all claims for “multiple equilibria” →
- In game-theory terms there are multiple social equilibria: one where everyone does the right thing even when unobserved, and one where no one does the right thing even when observed; humans can live in either, so which equilibrium prevails is socially constructed, not fixed by human nature—and a single defector can corrode others' commitment.Michael Munger on Obedience to the Unenforceable
- Game theory cannot predict which of several equilibria a market will reach, but it is valuable for understanding the dynamics and human interactions of a system, which helps investors adapt as events unfold.The Three Body Portfolio
- Unlike Keynesian investment contractions, which require a large change in investment to produce big output effects, liquidity is so non-fundamental that it can be destroyed by only a little 'animal spirits'—a small coordination shift—because there are multiple equilibria, whereas destroying real capital, productivity, or technology requires far more.Guillermo Calvo on the Crisis, Money, and Macro
- The Idea Trap is a model with three variables — growth, policy, ideas — where good ideas cause good policy, good policy causes good growth, and (per public-opinion evidence) good growth feeds good ideas while bad growth feeds bad ideas (populism); this feedback produces multiple equilibria, one where good ideas/policy/growth mutually reinforce and one where bad ideas/policy/growth do, rather than universal convergence.Bryan Caplan
- Tax compliance is a multiple-equilibrium phenomenon—Chile sits at 98% compliance with social stigma for cheating while Argentina sits near 50%—and you cannot move from the low-compliance to the high-compliance equilibrium by education or exhortation unless everybody moves at the same time, as shown when Argentina's compliance ad campaign collapsed because the celebrity endorsers hadn't paid their own taxes.Michael Munger on Industrial Policy
- Predatory urban violence spreads via a multiple-equilibria mechanism: once a small group proves that a violent criminal vocation can be done and made profitable in a city (as in Nairobi versus Kampala), others copy and professionalize it until it becomes entrenched as a thing people do.Chris Blattman
- Arguments that small justified rule-breaking leads to larger corruption are not mere slippery-slope dismissals but describe equilibrium behavior: once you justify why it's okay to break the rules in this instance, you start to fool yourself (and you are the easiest person to fool), and it takes surprisingly few unexpected bad actions before others conclude they need not obey the rules either.Michael Munger on Obedience to the Unenforceable
- Like cost accounting, prediction markets and futarchy face a multiple-equilibria problem: in a world where nobody uses them, proposing to do so sends a bad signal ('people are bullshitting here, we need to find who'), while in a world where everybody uses them, refusing to do so sends an equally bad signal—so adoption depends on which equilibrium prevails, and accurate-forecasting organizations could eventually outcompete more emotionally indulgent ones.Robin Hanson
- Economics has advanced in retrodiction—we can now trace where bad mortgages were made and which banks held them in the Great Recession with detail unavailable for the 1979-82 recession—but it has made no progress in controlling or predicting business cycles, crashes, or recessions, and the best theories imply such events are intrinsically difficult to predict.Patrick Collison