motivated reasoning
Reasoning shaped by a desire to reach a particular conclusion (e.g. to preserve identity or feel good) rather than to reach an accurate one.
As defined in 333 | Gordon Pennycook on Unthinkingness, Conspiracies, and What to Do About Them
Where it comes up · 19
- 143 | Julia Galef on Openness, Bias, and Rationality5 claims
- Wanna Bet?4 claims
- Jonathan Haidt on the Righteous Mind4 claims
- David McRaney on How Minds Change4 claims
- 92 - The Limits Of Persuasion2 claims
- Ask Me Anything 12 claims
- 204 - A Conversation With Jonathan Haidt2 claims
- 333 | Gordon Pennycook on Unthinkingness, Conspiracies, and What to Do About Them2 claims
and 11 more
Most important claims · 10 of 38Search all claims for “motivated reasoning” →
- Identity-protective cognition means that on politically charged problems, greater skill or information does not improve accuracy but provides cognitive resources to convince oneself that what one's group believes is correct—so the gap in performance is largest among the most numerate or high-information people.81 | Ezra Klein on Politics, Polarization, and Identity
- Even after studying the math and writing a book on the topic, Duke still feels an emotional voice calling Pete Carroll an idiot, showing that knowledge of probabilities does not eliminate outcome-driven judgment.Wanna Bet?
- People seek information they agree with, avoid information they disagree with, and counter-argue disliked information in their heads; the more political information someone has, the better they are at counter-arguing, so the people paying most attention to politics are also the most biased in processing it—meaning corrective information cannot solve the problem because the most active and knowledgeable are the most resistant.Lilliana Mason on Uncivil Agreement
- More informed partisans are sometimes likelier than less informed ones to hold factually wrong beliefs (e.g., informed Republicans answering wrong about the Clinton-era deficit), because consuming partisan media gives them the tools and the selective information to arrange facts in ways that confirm what their side believes.81 | Ezra Klein on Politics, Polarization, and Identity
- There are two kinds of Independents—true Independents (uninformed) and leaning Independents (more informed)—while the strongest partisans are most informed yet also 'mal-informed' due to motivated reasoning: strong Democrats believe inflation didn't decline under Reagan, and strong Republicans believe WMD were found under Bush, both of which are false.Morris Fiorina on Polarization, Stability, and the State of the Electorate
- Motivated reasoning means our stated reasons follow our motivations rather than drive them: the same traits cited as reasons for liking someone (their music, opinions, the way they walk) become reasons against them once the motivation flips to breaking up, because reasons are generated to justify a conclusion the motivation already favors.David McRaney on How Minds Change
- When people reject a New York Times article on gun control, it is not because their trust in its factual reliability eroded but because of directional bias: they dig in and find counter-evidence for views they dislike while uncritically accepting congenial claims—this motivated reasoning is a longstanding feature of how people process information, not a recent decline.92 - The Limits Of Persuasion
- Motivated reasoning—wanting certain propositions to be true because of how they make one feel, as Francis Collins does by rebranding wishful thinking as faith—is the quintessence of an unscientific attitude and a way of failing to be in contact with reality, because, per Feynman, science is the art of not fooling yourself and you are the easiest person to fool.Ask Me Anything 1
- Witnessing someone relinquish a cherished opinion in real time under pressure from better arguments is about as rare as seeing a supernova explode overhead, which is a scandal of intellectual life given how universally the virtues of rational discourse are espoused; the perpetual stalemate in public debate is the product of motivated reasoning and self-deception.39 - Free Will Revisited
- Contrary to the popular and influential view that people fall for misinformation and conspiracies because of motivated reasoning (preserving identity, feeling good, group belonging), the primary driver is 'unmotivated reasoning' or unthinkingness—lazy failure to expend cognitive effort—evidenced by the fact that more reflective people better distinguish true from false headlines regardless of whether the content fits their ideology.333 | Gordon Pennycook on Unthinkingness, Conspiracies, and What to Do About Them