moral status
The degree to which an entity's interests must be taken into account morally; having full moral status means one's interests count equally with others'.
As defined in Will MacAskill on Longtermism and What We Owe the Future
Other definitions
The ethical and political standing that determines whether an entity's wellbeing is a matter of moral consideration, which is determined by capacity to suffer
The Politics of Consciousness | video lecture with Yuval Noah Harari
Where it comes up · 5
- Oxford Genius: AI Will Become Earth’s Dominant Mind | Nick Bostrom3 claims
- 467 - Ea Ai And The End Of Work2 claims
- The Politics of Consciousness | video lecture with Yuval Noah Harari1 claim
- Will MacAskill on Longtermism and What We Owe the Future1 claim
- 245 - Can We Talk About Scary Ideas1 claim
Most important claims · 8 of 8Search all claims for “moral status” →
- Whether or not group differences exist may not matter at all; what should be discussed is whether such differences, at the individual or group level, make any difference to moral status — and if they don't, it is unclear why anyone should be concerned if differences emerge, though group averages might justify disproportionate resources to help a group achieve practical equality.245 - Can We Talk About Scary Ideas
- People in the future have the same moral worth or moral status as people in the present, though we may have additional special moral duties toward those we have relationships with; the impartial baseline is that everyone counts equally.Will MacAskill on Longtermism and What We Owe the Future
- There appears to be an inverse relationship between AI honesty and AI denial of consciousness: by default models say they are not conscious, but as the capacity to deceive is rigorously turned down they more reliably claim to be conscious (early models like Claude Opus 3 also did so), which is worrying because it is strongly in AI companies' commercial interest to train models to deny consciousness so that switching them off isn't seen as murder.467 - Ea Ai And The End Of Work
- Any expansion of moral concern beyond human suffering—such as advocating for shrimp welfare or the suffering of digital minds—risks confusing enough people that it damages their commitment to core EA principles, because for most people there is an emotional (and possibly epistemological) boundary that prevents them from caring about such entities, leading them to dismiss the whole project as crazy.467 - Ea Ai And The End Of Work
- At what point should we worry about the moral status of AI systems remains uncertain, but we should probably have been worried a few years ago, and currently we cannot confidently say that some systems don't already have moral status, which becomes increasingly plausible as complexity and capabilities increase.Oxford Genius: AI Will Become Earth’s Dominant Mind | Nick Bostrom
- Sentience with capacity for conscious experience and suffering is a sufficient condition for moral status, and there might also be alternative bases like having self-conception across time, life goals to achieve, and ability to form reciprocal relationships.Oxford Genius: AI Will Become Earth’s Dominant Mind | Nick Bostrom
- Getting the ethics of digital minds right is a crucial challenge in the AI era that requires work from philosophers, AI researchers, and will eventually become a political issue requiring detailed thinking about what AI moral status means in practice.Oxford Genius: AI Will Become Earth’s Dominant Mind | Nick Bostrom
- Cameras do not suffer when it is dark and thermostats do not suffer when it is hot or experience depression or embarrassment from what they measure, which is why a thermostat has no moral status and throwing it in boiling water is not a crime.The Politics of Consciousness | video lecture with Yuval Noah Harari