
The Politics of Consciousness | video lecture with Yuval Noah Harari
What this covers
This is a single-speaker lecture by Yuval Noah Harari, addressed to consciousness researchers, about why the science of mind cannot be separated from politics. He begins from the claim that moral status and political rights track the capacity to feel, which is why what scientists conclude about consciousness carries ethical weight. Stones, tables, and cars fall outside the moral domain. Beings that can feel fall inside it. He argues that even modern democratic authority rests on feeling rather than truth or intelligence: elections ask people what they feel, and votes are equal because the capacity to feel is treated as equal.
The middle of the talk turns to how theories land in the world. Harari cites the bogus racial theories of the 19th and early 20th centuries, and the labeling of homosexuality as sickness, as examples of flawed science with vast human cost. He then looks at animals through the 2012 Cambridge Declaration on Consciousness and New Zealand's 2015 legal recognition of animals as conscious beings. He also describes the unproven idea of human superiority over animals as possibly the cause of more suffering than any other single idea. Integrated Information Theory (IIT)) serves as a test case, since it claims to answer questions about fetuses and cows. Harari asks theorists to say what their models imply about fetuses at different stages, cows, and people with dementia, and doubts any theory that stays silent.
The sharpest turns come at the edges. A scale of suffering would almost inevitably become a hierarchy of consciousness, and Harari suggests a hierarchy among humans could be more dangerous than one between humans and animals. The last section separates intelligence from consciousness. He says the common assumption that AI will develop feelings is mistaken, comparing it to airplanes outflying birds without growing feathers. The risk he names is that societies end up privileging intelligent machines over conscious humans.
Consciousness should be defined fundamentally as the capacity to suffer rather than as neutral observation, and this distinction has profound ethical and political implications for how we treat animals, fetuses, humans, and artificial intelligence.
- Consciousness is the only phenomenon in the universe involving suffering, which is a rejection of present reality rather than neutral observation
- Defining consciousness by suffering capacity clarifies which entities deserve ethical and political consideration
- Conflating intelligence with consciousness in AI development poses existential risks to conscious beings
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
Flawed scientific theories about consciousness can cause dangerous political consequences, as demonstrated by how bogus racial theories of the 19th and early 20th centuries justifying European racial superiority and theories labeling homosexuality as sickness remained confined to laboratories but instead had terrible destructive impact on billions of people.
“flowed scientific theories can have dangerous political Fallout just think about the impact of erroneous theories regarding Grace and gender when a century ago scientists argued that Europeans constitute a superior race or that homosexuality is a sickness this bogus theories did not remain confined to Laboratories and seminar rooms they had a terrible destructive impact on the lives of billions of people outside the academic Ivory Tower”
Even completely wrong theories of consciousness can have huge ethical and political impact in the real world, as shown by how bogus racial theories of the 19th and 20th centuries reshaped the world, so we should be aware of ethical and political implications even as we're developing consciousness theories.
“the theory of Consciousness might be completely wrong and still have a huge ethical and political impact history is full of examples of wrong theories that reshape the world like the bogus racial theories of the 19th and early 20th century”
In 2015 New Zealand became the first country in the world to legally recognize animals as conscious beings and require proper attention to their welfare in animal husbandry contexts, partly motivated by the Cambridge Declaration on Consciousness.
“this declaration was one of the reasons why three years later in 2015 the New Zealand parliament passed the Animal Welfare Amendment act the act stipulates that it is obligatory to recognize animals as conscious and hence attend properly to their welfare in contexts like animal husbandry New Zealand thereby became the first country in the world to legally recognize animals as conscious beings”
The Cambridge Declaration on Consciousness (2012) states that non-human animals including all mammals and birds and many other creatures including octopuses possess the neurological substrates that generate consciousness and the capacity to exhibit intentional behaviors.
“in 2012 a group of prominent neuroscientists signed that Cambridge Declaration on consciousness which states that convergent evidence indicates that non-human animals have the neuroanatomical neurochemical and neurophysiological substrates of conscious States along with the capacity to exhibit intentional behaviors consequently the weight of evidence indicates that humans are not unique in possessing the neurological substrates that generate consciousness non-human animals including all mammals and birds and many other creatures including octopuses also possess these neurological substrates”
As computers and robots become more intelligent and potentially surpass human intelligence, ethical and political questions will arise about whether robots should have rights, whether AI should be authorized to make ethical decisions, and whether autonomous weapon systems should be created.
“questions arise about our ethical and political attitude to AI should robots have rights should AI be authorized to make ethical decisions should we for example produce autonomous weapon systems that can decide on their own initiative who to kill”
The Integrated Information Theory (IIT) claims it can potentially tell us new things about consciousness and give scientific answers to questions like whether fetuses have consciousness and whether cows can suffer like humans, if these claims are correct their ethical and political impact will be enormous.
“at present some theories of Consciousness such as the integrated information Theory do indeed claim that they can potentially tell us new things about such matters and give a scientific answer to questions like do fetuses have Consciousness and can cows suffer like humans if they are correct their potential ethical and political impact will be enormous”
The study of consciousness has deep political and ethical implications because consciousness determines who has moral standing and political rights, making what scientists discover about consciousness a matter of serious ethical responsibility.
“Consciousness is linked to suffering questions like what is consciousness and who has Consciousness have a deep impact on ethnic politics and the law as is apparent in debates about abortion animal rights and the legal status of AI”
Scientific studies often treat consciousness as a neutral observer of the world, but this is misleading because consciousness is the only thing in the universe that involves suffering, which is fundamentally a rejection of present reality rather than objective observation.
“while observation tries to capture the present reality as objectively as possible at the core of any experience of suffering is a rejection of present reality”
A hierarchy of consciousness within humanity that places some humans or some feelings above other humans could have even more dangerous consequences than hierarchies between humans and animals.
“now think of the potential impact of having a scale of Consciousness within Humanity itself which places some humans or some feelings above other humans and other feelings”
Consciousness is characterized by the capacity to suffer, which makes conscious entities ethical and political subjects entitled to moral consideration, whereas objects like stones, tables, and cars that cannot suffer are mere objects outside the ethical domain.
“Stones tables and cars don't have Consciousness they cannot suffer and are therefore not ethical or political subjects they are mere objects”
If consciousness researchers advocate a particular theory of consciousness, they should be willing to publicly testify what that theory implies about the consciousness and suffering capacity of fetuses at different stages of pregnancy, and if their theory cannot say anything relevant about this, it probably is not a real theory of consciousness.
“if you Advocate a particular Theory Of Consciousness can your theory tell us what is the stage of pregnancy when fetuses gain the capacity to suffer would you be willing to say so publicly to testifying code to testifying Congress and if your theory cannot say anything relevant on the consciousness of fetuses is it really a theory of consciousness”
Once we begin discussing scales of consciousness and suffering, the questions will inevitably extend beyond animals to differences in consciousness and suffering capacity among humans themselves, including questions about babies, people with dementia, and people with various diseases.
“once we get into such a debate about scales of Consciousness and scales of suffering it's unlikely to stop with animals the question will inevitably be raised about humans too perhaps within humankind itself there is a scale of Consciousness and significant differences in the capacity to suffer what about babies what about people with dementia what about all kinds of other diseases”
Many people both scholars and non-academics make the wrong assumption that artificial intelligence will inevitably develop consciousness, which is reflected in almost all science fiction movies about AI.
“too many people both Scholars and non-academics come to such debates with a wrong assumption then fortunately tend to confuse intelligence with Consciousness and assume that artificial intelligence will inevitably develop consciousness this for example is the Assumption in almost all science fiction movies that feature AI”
Just as airplanes fly faster than birds without developing feathers, computers may come to solve problems much better than humans without ever developing feelings like consciousness.
“just as airplanes fly faster than Birds without ever developing feathers so computers may come to solve problems much better than humans without ever developing feelings”
Modern political authority rests fundamentally on the capacity to feel and suffer, not on intelligence or truth, as evidenced by how democratic elections ask people what they feel rather than what is true, and give equal voting rights based on equal capacity to feel rather than equal intelligence.
“modern day rulers are not chosen by God they are elected by people according to their feelings and note that in Democratic elections people are asked not what is the truth but rather what do you feel”
Ethical and political conflicts in modern society increasingly pit one person's or group's feelings against another's, requiring that we develop ways to measure, compare, and weigh different feelings against each other to determine whose feelings should prevail.
“we need to weigh one feeling against another feeling some people will feel humiliated and even endangered if we ban the parade other people will feel hurt if we allow the parade which feelings count for more”
The abortion debate fundamentally revolves around the question of whether fetuses are conscious and capable of suffering, and once we know at what stage of pregnancy fetuses gain the capacity to suffer, we can determine their ethical and political status.
“consider abortion for many people the heated argument about abortion revolves around the questions are fetuses conscious in any way can a fetus feel something or not can a five-week-old fetus feel pain how about a 10 week old fetus can it suffer if not and this fetus is not an ethical subject the question of abortion should then focus on the feelings and potential suffering of the mother”
The key question about animal consciousness is whether animals can suffer in the same way or at the same level as humans, which is an empirical question that consciousness science should be able to answer if it is a genuine theory.
“someone might agree that cows do have Consciousness but it's nevertheless okay to slaughter and eat them because their capacity to suffer is somehow smaller than the human capacity to suffer now this is an empirical claim can the science of Consciousness prove or disprove this empirical claim the fate of billions of sentient beings may depend on this so again we counter the question of how we measure and scale Consciousness and how we measure and scale suffering can we measure cow Consciousness and compare it to human consciousness”
If someone advocates a scientific theory of consciousness, they should be willing and able to tell us what it implies about the consciousness and suffering capacity of fetuses, cows, humans with dementia, and other beings, and if their theory cannot answer such questions meaningfully, it has probably not solved the riddle of consciousness.
“Scholars constantly come up with claims that they have solved the mystery of consciousness if you have indeed solved the mystery of Consciousness what can you tell us about fetuses and abortion what can you tell us about cows and Animal Welfare what can you tell us about measuring and weighing human feelings one against the other if your theory cannot tell us anything meaningful about such things then I would doubt whether you have indeed solved the riddle of consciousness”
Scholars working on consciousness theories should be extremely careful about the claims they make and err on the side of caution, meaning on the side that is less likely to cause mass suffering, because consciousness science is likely to have explosive ethical and political impact.
“Scholars working on such theories should therefore be very careful about the claims they make they should remember that since Consciousness is the basis for modern ethics and politics a new Theory Of Consciousness is likely to have explosive ethical and political impact consequently if Scholars have doubts about a theory they should always err on the side of caution meaning on the side that is less likely to cause Mass suffering”
If we develop a scale of consciousness with strong measurement and scaling claims, this would almost inevitably translate into a hierarchy of consciousness, which could have the most explosive ethical and political consequences.
“a scaling of Consciousness would almost inevitably translate into a hierarchy of Consciousness we already have an unproven hierarchy of Consciousness between humans and other animals most people believe that humans have some kind of superior Consciousness which is what justifies the way we treat billions of other animals”
Consciousness researchers should be aware of and consider the ethical and political implications of consciousness theories from the very beginning of theory development, not waiting until theories are mature, because we should think about the fruit a theory could bear even as we're sowing the seeds.
“we are now in the initial stage of formulating theories of consciousness researchers are merely sowing the seeds of these theories but even as we saw a seed we should think of the fruit it could bear from the very beginning we should be aware of the ethical and political implications of such theories”
If we confuse intelligence with consciousness, then as computers become more intelligent than humans we might end up privileging intelligent computers over conscious humans, which would be a terrible mistake.
“if we confuse intelligence with Consciousness then as computers become more intelligent than humans we might end up privileging intelligent computers over conscious humans”
A true scientific theory of consciousness should be able to help measure and scale suffering and identify who deserves ethical and political consideration; if a theory cannot do this, it should be doubted as a genuine theory of consciousness.
“one question I would ask about any Theory Of Consciousness is can it help us measure suffering can it help us formulate a scale of suffering if it cannot I would doubt whether it is truly a theory of consciousness”
The unproven theory that human consciousness is superior to animal consciousness may have caused more suffering than any other single idea in the whole of history, through justifying the mistreatment of billions of animals.
“this unproven theory that human consciousness is superior to animal Consciousness may have caused more suffering than any other single idea in the whole of history”
Too often consciousness scholars treat consciousness as something neutral, like a camera that just observes the world, because when scientists study complicated phenomena they typically begin with the simplest parts, and the ability to see colors is simpler than the ability to feel love or hate.
“too often in the studies of Consciousness Scholars tend to treat Consciousness as something neutral as if Consciousness is mainly about perception observation calculation and so on as if Consciousness is like a camera that just observes the world without feeling anything this observational view of Consciousness is a byproduct of the fact that when scientists try to understand something very complicated we often start with the Least Complicated part of it accordingly when studying Consciousness we don't begin with the ability to feel love or hate which is very complicated but rather with far simpler things like the ability to see red”
In humans and animals, intelligence goes hand in hand with consciousness because they rely on their feelings to solve certain problems, but computers solve problems in a very different way and there is no reason to think they are developing consciousness.
“in humans and other animals intelligence goes hand in hand with consciousness humans chimps cows and chickens rely on their feelings in order to solve certain problems however computers solve problems in a very different way from animals and there is absolutely no reason to think that they are anywhere on the road to developing Consciousness”
In modern ethics and politics, prohibition against acts like murder and rape is no longer justified by divine commandment or laws of nature but by whether the acts cause people to suffer, representing a fundamental shift in the basis of moral authority.
“for forbidding things like murder or rape the reason is not that God said so or some ancient book said so we forbid these things because they make people suffer”
The case of homosexuality prohibition historically justified by divine commandment and laws of nature is increasingly challenged in modern times by questions about who actually suffers if two men love each other, showing how moral reasoning has shifted to focus on actual suffering rather than religious authority.
“Judaism Christianity in Islam famously banned homosexuality why because God said so because scriptures said so or because allegedly it was a crime against the laws of nature for thousands of years for one man to fall in love with another man was one of the worst crimes imaginable sometimes punished by Death in the modern world people began questioning this taboo they asked who suffers if two men love each other how does this harm anyone and if nobody suffers why should it be considered a crime”
The remarkable ability of consciousness to reject reality is what distinguishes it from all non-conscious entities like electrons, atoms, molecules, stars, black holes, and galaxies, which are all neutral and cannot suffer.
“what kind of thing can reject reality electrons atoms molecules Stars black holes and galaxies are all neutral entities they can't reject reality and they can't suffer they have no consciousness”
Even religious fundamentalists opposing homosexuality have shifted their public arguments away from divine commandment to claiming that allowing gay pride parades hurts their own feelings, demonstrating that the modern framework for ethical debate is now based on weighing competing feelings rather than divine authority.
“the religious zealots do not say these Sinners shouldn't hold a gay parade because God forbids homosexuality no the zealots explain to every available microphone television camera that seeing a gay pride parade passing through the holy city of Jerusalem hurts our feelings just as LGBT people want us to respect their feelings they should respect our feelings”
Modern voting rights are based on the assumption that all humans have equal capacity to feel rather than equal intelligence; if it turns out through consciousness science that not all humans have the same capacity to feel, this could undermine the basis for equal voting rights.
“remember for example the fact that voting rights today are based on the assumption that all humans have equal feelings rather than equal intelligence what might happen if it turns out that not all humans have the same capacity to feel what will that do to voting rights”
Suffering is not the same as pain; suffering is the mental reaction to a sensation, the rejection of present reality and preference for something else that does not exist, rather than the sensation itself.
“suffering is not the pain itself pain is just a sensation suffering is the mental reaction to that sensation it is a reaction of rejecting and hating the reality we encounter and preferring something else which is not there”
Recognizing that animals have consciousness and the capacity to suffer has far-reaching implications requiring serious discussion about how we treat animals in meat industries, dairy industries, and university laboratories, though it does not necessarily mean immediately banning all such practices.
“it means that these animals are ethical subjects it means that we should think very carefully about how we treat these animals in the meat industry in the dairy industry and in our University Laboratories”
Cameras do not suffer when it is dark and thermostats do not suffer when it is hot or experience depression or embarrassment from what they measure, which is why a thermostat has no moral status and throwing it in boiling water is not a crime.
“as for cameras and thermostats they can measure light and temperature but cameras do not suffer when it's very dark and thermostats don't suffer when it's very hot when we set an air conditioner to 25 degrees Celsius and its thermostat detects at the room temperature is now 28 degrees the thermostat activates the cooling units in order to lower the temperature but the thermostat doesn't generate any feelings of depression or embarrassment from what it measures it never rejects what it measures this is why throwing a thermostat into a boiling cauldron is not a crime”
Computers are revolutionizing the world while thermostats are not, which suggests that we should examine carefully what the difference is between computers and thermostats in terms of consciousness as AI develops.
“this is why throwing a thermostat into a boiling cauldron is not a crime the same goes for computers and this is a crucial point thermostats are not revolutionizing the world computers are we are now in the midst of an enormous revolution in artificial intelligence”
Understanding the link between consciousness and suffering is essential to dealing with difficult ethical and political questions raised by artificial intelligence as computers and robots become more intelligent and potentially surpass human intelligence.
“understanding the vital link between Consciousness and suffering will help us deal better with a whole host of difficult questions raised by artificial intelligence”
Unless we remind ourselves of the deep connection between consciousness and suffering, it will be very difficult to deal with the ethical and political implications of the rise of artificial intelligence.
“unless we remind ourselves of the deep connection between Consciousness and suffering it will be very difficult to deal with the ethical and political implications of the rise of artificial intelligence”
Defining consciousness as the capacity to suffer reminds us of the unique and crucial nature of consciousness and how it differs from all other known phenomena in the universe.
“on a deeper level this definition also reminds us of the unique nature of Consciousness and of how it differs from all the other known phenomena in the universe”
Starting with simple sensory abilities like seeing colors when studying consciousness may misleadingly suggest that cameras and thermostats that can distinguish colors or temperatures also have consciousness, which is false.
“unfortunately this may mislead us into having a sanitized and neutral attitude towards consciousness it might cause us to erroneously understand Consciousness as a neutral observational phenomenon as if Consciousness is mainly about observing things and as if seeing red is at the core of Consciousness well things like love and hate are peripheral add-ons if Consciousness is about seeing red and distinguishing red from Green maybe cameras that distinguish between red and green also have Consciousness maybe thermostats that measure temperature also have consciousness”
What makes consciousness unique and important is not perception or observation but that it is the least neutral phenomenon in the universe - the only thing that involves suffering and rejection of reality.
“in fact what makes Consciousness so unique and so important is that it is the least neutral phenomenon in the universe it is the only thing in the universe as far as we can tell that involves suffering”
Emotions beyond pain such as anger, greed, and depression all involve the same kind of rejection of present reality and craving for something else as suffering involves.
“this rejection of reality and the craving for something else can happen not only in reaction to pain anger greed depression and other kinds of misery also involve the same kind of reaction”
By 2050 computers may be far more intelligent than humans and still have zero consciousness, because there are several alternative roads leading to intelligence and only some of these roads involve gaining consciousness.
“by 2050 computers may be far more intelligent than humans and still have zero consciousness it seems that there are several alternative roads leading to intelligence and only some of these roads involve gaining consciousness”
It is an open empirical question whether consciousness always involves preferring one thing over another, and whether conscious entities can experience moments of pure observation without preference or rejection of reality.
“it is of course an open empirical question whether Consciousness always involves preferring one thing over another can conscious entities ever experience moments of pure observation when they don't prefer anything and they don't reject anything that is something we need to explore further”
Entities with zero capacity for suffering fall completely outside the ethical and political domain and deserve no moral consideration, such as statues which cannot feel pain or happiness.
“one very important part of any skill of suffering is the lowest end of the scale zero capacity for suffering zero capacity for suffering means that you fall completely outside the ethical and political domain for instance in their first debate about the Statue we take into account the feelings of people who abhor the statue and we take into account the feelings of people who admire the statue but we don't take into account the feelings of the statue itself because the statue has no feelings”
Even positive sensations can lead to suffering if they trigger craving for more of that sensation and disappointment when it is not available, as in a child crying while eating an apple because they wanted ice cream instead.
“even a sensation of pleasure might result in suffering if we react to the pleasing sensation by craving more of it and becoming disappointed when we don't get more a child might cry while eating a delicious apple because they wanted ice cream instead”
Intelligence and consciousness are very different things: intelligence is the ability to solve problems, while consciousness is the ability to feel things like pain, pleasure, love, and hate.
“intelligence is the ability to solve problems Consciousness is the ability to feel things like pain pleasure Love and Hate”
Over the past 50 years there has been immense advance in computer intelligence but exactly zero advance in computer consciousness, suggesting computers have not moved toward consciousness.
“over the past 50 years or so there has been an immense advance in computer intelligence but there has been exactly zero advance in computer consciousness as far as we know computers today are no more conscious than their prototypes were in the 1950s”