moral landscape
Harris's metaphor for a space of possible experiences with peaks (high wellbeing) and valleys (suffering), where moral progress means navigating toward peaks.
As defined in 92 - The Limits Of Persuasion
Where it comes up · 10
- Jordan Peterson & Sam Harris Try to Find Something They Agree On | EP 4087 claims
- Sam Harris & Jordan Peterson in Vancouver 2018 (with Bret Weinstein moderating) — Night One4 claims
- Sam Harris vs Jordan Peterson | God, Atheism, The Bible, Jesus - Part 1 - Presented by Pangburn4 claims
- 92 - The Limits Of Persuasion2 claims
- 150 - The Map Of Misunderstanding2 claims
- 115 - Sam Harris Lawrence Krauss And Matt Dillahunty 12 claims
- Ask Me Anything 122 claims
- 107 - Is Life Actually Worth Living1 claim
and 2 more
Most important claims · 10 of 26Search all claims for “moral landscape” →
- If what you are concerned about morally does not ultimately bear on the actual or potential wellbeing of conscious creatures somewhere at some time, then it is a pseudo-moral concern—a category error; even religious concerns about heaven and hell, when drilled down, reduce to the wellbeing of conscious (often fictional) creatures.92 - The Limits Of Persuasion
- Morality and value are best understood not through terms like duty but as a 'moral landscape' of peaks and valleys representing the well-being of all possible minds; there are many equivalent peaks and distinct valleys, and ethics reduces to a navigation problem of moving away from the worst possible suffering for everyone toward better states.107 - Is Life Actually Worth Living
- A consequentialist need not accept all reported suffering as morally weighty, because a person can be wired by culture to suffer over the wrong things—e.g. a lynch mob member's off-the-charts suffering at a rumored Quran burning reflects a disposition that forecloses most of what is good in human life, so we should want to migrate away from such low 'peaks' on the moral landscape.92 - The Limits Of Persuasion
- Objective morality does not mean absolute or single-answer morality; the moral landscape can have a functionally infinite number of equally valid peaks (right answers) while having an even larger set of wrong answers, and 'objective' merely means it is not subject to mere whim and that one can be wrong without knowing it.115 - Sam Harris Lawrence Krauss And Matt Dillahunty 1
- There are right answers to the question of how to navigate from the worst possible suffering for everyone to peaks on the moral landscape where there is beauty, creativity, and joy; these are fact-based discussions about genetics, psychology, neurobiology, sociology, economics, and sciences yet to be invented.Jordan Peterson & Sam Harris Try to Find Something They Agree On | EP 408
- The problem Harris's moral landscape faces is the necessity of an intermediary interpretive structure between facts and values, and Peterson maintains that this interpretive structure is itself not derivable from facts but rather consists of a priori intuitions that take the form of stories, personalities, or narratives.Sam Harris & Jordan Peterson in Vancouver 2018 (with Bret Weinstein moderating) — Night One
- Morality is a navigation problem between the worst possible misery and sublime well-being across the continuum of conscious experience; there are right and wrong answers about how properly constituted minds move along that continuum, and these answers draw on all legitimate human knowledge—biochemical, psychological, sociological, economic, and political—making objective (though not absolute) morality possible without divine command.115 - Sam Harris Lawrence Krauss And Matt Dillahunty 1
- You don't need free will for life to have a moral character; all morality requires is a real difference between abject misery and its opposite, creating a navigation problem in the space of conscious experience. We are not unmoved-mover agents authoring ourselves; we are causal structures buffeted in that space, and because we affect each other's states, real concern and norms and systems that make us much happier are warranted without any ultimate responsibility for being who we are.109 - Biology And Culture
- Our intuitions about aesthetic beauty converge enough that there is massive agreement about certain works—Shakespeare being a master of metaphor whose phrasings populate our language—implying a structural basis that a mature science of mind could in principle understand, analogous to finding logical structure.150 - The Map Of Misunderstanding
- Harris claims that his argument in The Moral Landscape uses two concrete stories (the 'hell' scenario of maximum suffering vs. the 'heaven' scenario of flourishing) to establish an axiom of morality, which Peterson interprets as relying on narrative/story rather than pure fact.Sam Harris vs Jordan Peterson | God, Atheism, The Bible, Jesus - Part 1 - Presented by Pangburn