moral agency
The morally relevant capacity of a person to act and thereby cause outcomes; in this discussion, the idea that actively killing someone is categorically different from allowing them to die.
As defined in Michael Munger on How Adam Smith Solved the Trolley Problem
Where it comes up · 3
- Michael Munger on How Adam Smith Solved the Trolley Problem3 claims
- Kant's Moral Philosophy2 claims
- Do All Creatures, Great and Small, and Made From Silicon, Have Rights? (with Jeff Sebo)1 claim
Most important claims · 6 of 6Search all claims for “moral agency” →
- Moral agency and moral personhood adhere not just to individual persons but also to nations as collective rational agents, obligating all nations to eliminate the state of nature between them by creating international law, just as individuals must create civil law.Kant's Moral Philosophy
- In Kant's system, humans are elevated above the rest of nature and share something in common with God and the angels—the capacity for rational moral agency—rather than being mere mechanical automata.Kant's Moral Philosophy
- Moral agency (having duties to others) requires sophisticated higher-order states like complex beliefs, desires, and emotions such as regret, which is why a dog lacks duties to humans; but moral patienthood (others having duties to you) does not require such cognitive sophistication—a being can still have a life that matters to it and be capable of being benefited and harmed without adult-human-level cognition.Do All Creatures, Great and Small, and Made From Silicon, Have Rights? (with Jeff Sebo)
- Although from a utilitarian or consequentialist perspective diverting a trolley to kill one to save five is equivalent to allowing five to die, people feel a real moral difference rooted in moral agency: actively killing someone is categorically different from allowing them to die.Michael Munger on How Adam Smith Solved the Trolley Problem
- Adam Smith, writing in 1759, effectively anticipated the trolley problem by showing that people feel a fundamental moral difference between actively causing harm and merely allowing it; his resolution of the little-finger puzzle via the impartial spectator and moral agency is the same distinction Philippa Foot later drew between allowing a death and killing.Michael Munger on How Adam Smith Solved the Trolley Problem
- The decision to drop atomic bombs on Japan was a real-world trolley problem: dropping the bomb meant intentionally killing defenseless civilians (active killing) versus pursuing Operation Downfall, a conventional invasion whose resistance would, as an unavoidable side-consequence, cause roughly ten times as many casualties—up to a million U.S. soldiers and as many as 50 million Japanese by Japan's own estimate.Michael Munger on How Adam Smith Solved the Trolley Problem