monopoly on violence
The condition where a government is the sole legitimate authority able to use force within its territory; about 60 states lack this.
As defined in Ben Sasse
Where it comes up · 7
- Barry Weingast on the Violence Trap2 claims
- Ask Me Anything 52 claims
- Ben Sasse1 claim
- Melissa Dell1 claim
- 207 - Can We Pull Back From The Brink1 claim
- 134 - Beyond The Politics Of Race1 claim
- 42 - Racism And Violence In America1 claim
Most important claims · 9 of 9Search all claims for “monopoly on violence” →
- A monopoly on violence held by the state—including a police force that deters and solves crime and delivers violent criminals to a functioning justice system—is one of humanity's greatest achievements and the necessary precondition for almost everything else we value, so abolishing the police is insane even though serious reform is needed.207 - Can We Pull Back From The Brink
- Because eugenics-era progressive attitudes led whites to effectively let black communities police themselves as a form of population control, a culture of honor and retributive violence was allowed to survive in black communities while white communities received reliable policing, perpetuating cycles of retaliatory violence.134 - Beyond The Politics Of Race
- Government and its legal machinery should be used sparingly because every law must be backed by the threat of violence; criminalizing drug use, for example, means being willing to send armed police to break down a neighbor's door over something as innocuous as smoking pot, which is unethical, dangerous, and an insane use of resources.Ask Me Anything 5
- The US lacks a national security strategy for the post-1989 age of cyber and jihad: about 60 of the world's countries lack a monopoly on violence within their borders, and in these ungoverned spaces non-state actors with global reach emerge (Al-Qaeda was possible only because the Taliban didn't control its territory), yet we still think of security primarily in terms of nation-state actors and traditional war-making while future cyber targets will be civil society, not governments.Ben Sasse
- While the justice system over-applies law and order to petty and drug crimes, murders in black communities largely go unsolved because witnesses refuse to testify—both out of fear and out of distrust of police rooted in historical bad policing—creating a self-reinforcing state of nature where the state's monopoly on violence does not exist and people take the law into their own hands.42 - Racism And Violence In America
- Anarchists who attack 'worship of the religion of the state' should spend time in countries with weak states where people take the law into their own hands; a strong state with a monopoly on violence is necessary so people don't feel they must be violent to protect their interests, but state power must be reserved for safeguarding human wellbeing in ways that make sense.Ask Me Anything 5
- State capacity is largely a prerequisite for economic development—places with chronically weak states are very poor—but a strong state can be good or bad depending on what it does; the Prussian-state-and-Nazi-extermination evidence shows strong capacity amplifies whatever goals the state pursues, so capacity is necessary but not sufficient for good outcomes.Melissa Dell
- The aid community's strategy of doing everything at once—building democracy, rule of law, good governance, and a market economy by transplanting them to failed states like Somalia, Congo, Iraq, or Afghanistan—almost never works, because these projects do not address the underlying problem of violence; if leaders gain a monopoly on violence without controls on it, they predate on everyone, as Saddam Hussein's Iraq exemplified.Barry Weingast on the Violence Trap
- Because violence is so prevalent, countries must organize themselves to reduce its probability; developing countries characteristically have dispersed sources of violence, meaning multiple actors have access to violence and no state holds the monopoly on violence that characterizes the developed world—as in Mexico, where besides the government, PEMEX (a bloated private army), teachers' unions, drug lords, and the Chiapas insurgency all constitute alternative sources of violence.Barry Weingast on the Violence Trap