metaphysical desire
In Girard's theory, the desire for identity and being—what an object says about us—as opposed to its practical usefulness; a craving for persistence, power, and social recognition routed through admired models.
As defined in Johnathan Bi on Mimesis and René Girard
Where it comes up · 1
Most important claims · 5 of 5Search all claims for “metaphysical desire” →
- Human desire splits into two kinds: physical desire, which is for utility (what objects provide in themselves), and metaphysical desire, which is for identity (what objects say about us); this split runs across the whole spectrum of human wants, as when a Michelin restaurant commands 10-30x the price of good ramen not for proportionally better food but for the self-conception it bolsters.Johnathan Bi on Mimesis and René Girard
- Girard is forced to concede that physical desire is real and that not all desire is metaphysical desire; his actual claim is that every act of desiring probably has a social/metaphysical component, but saying all desire HAS metaphysical desire is not the same as saying all desire IS metaphysical desire--a crucial distinction that preserves the possibility of authentic physical desire.Johnathan Bi on Mimesis and René Girard
- One solution to the split between physical and metaphysical desire, favored by Girard and Buddhism, holds that metaphysical desire (desire for being) is always perverse: for Girard it is essentially a desire to be God--to have persistence, power, and reality, the metaphysical qualities of the Judeo-Christian God--making it the satanic original sin; for Buddhists those qualities are impossible because emptiness permeates the world; so good health means getting rid of metaphysical desire and being concerned only with physical desire.Johnathan Bi on Mimesis and René Girard
- Because the ideals we crave (persistence, power, recognition, fame) are too abstract to pursue directly, we fulfill them by making associations with objects through choosing models whom we already think possess this heightened 'being'; our fundamental desires and moral paradigms are thus anchored by these models and the values associated with them, whether distant literary models or proximate well-regarded coworkers.Johnathan Bi on Mimesis and René Girard
- Even when thrown in with a group whose values differ from yours, you can still access your authentic physical desire by calming your metaphysical frenzy; moreover, you can reason about direction even without absolute amounts--Bi's friend who is a superstar in industry getting all the social recognition yet loathes it while loving recognition-less philosophy proves that since the social weighting already inflates industry and deflates philosophy, his true preference for philosophy must be even stronger than it appears.Johnathan Bi on Mimesis and René Girard