meta-morality
A higher-level moral framework that enables different groups, each with their own values and interests, to live together and cooperate, analogous to how basic morality lets individuals cooperate within a group.
As defined in 176 | Joshua Greene on Morality, Psychology, and Trolley Problems
Where it comes up · 2
- Joshua Greene on Moral Tribes, Moral Dilemmas, and Utilitarianism4 claims
- 176 | Joshua Greene on Morality, Psychology, and Trolley Problems2 claims
Most important claims · 6 of 6Search all claims for “meta-morality” →
- Peter Singer's nonobvious insight—that saving a drowning child in front of you (ruining a $500 suit) is morally equivalent to donating that $500 to save a distant child's life—is basically right; our intuitions fire for the proximate child because we evolved biologically and culturally to cooperate within small groups, so the real puzzle is not why we ignore distant suffering but why we care about anyone, and a genuine global meta-morality requires valuing distant lives as much as near ones, at least in publicly justifiable policy if not in our hearts.Joshua Greene on Moral Tribes, Moral Dilemmas, and Utilitarianism
- Utilitarianism—better called 'deep pragmatism'—is the right meta-morality for adjudicating between tribes because resolving any value tradeoff requires a common currency, and utilitarianism supplies one by combining impartiality (everyone's interests count equally) with a shared measure of what matters: the quality of conscious experience, to which all values reduce when you keep asking 'why do you care about that?'Joshua Greene on Moral Tribes, Moral Dilemmas, and Utilitarianism
- Despite the impression from the news of worsening partisanship, Pinker's evidence is right that in almost every way that matters the world is getting better, because humanity is cobbling together a meta-morality—building systems that put 'us' ahead of 'me' and reconcile the competing moral visions of the world's different 'us-es' into a global system letting more people flourish—though a grand reversal via climate change or unfriendly AI cannot be ruled out.Joshua Greene on Moral Tribes, Moral Dilemmas, and Utilitarianism
- Basic morality solves the problem of me-versus-us (selfishness vs caring about others within a group), but the modern moral problem is us-versus-them—groups with their own interests and values trying to get along—which requires a higher-level 'meta-morality' to enable groups to cooperate.176 | Joshua Greene on Morality, Psychology, and Trolley Problems
- The modern moral problem is not turning a bunch of 'me-s' into an 'us' (the basic tragedy of the commons) but having many different 'us-es'—tribes each cooperative on their own different terms, with different leaders, values, and histories—all trying to coexist in the same space, which our basic in-group psychology is poorly equipped to handle.Joshua Greene on Moral Tribes, Moral Dilemmas, and Utilitarianism
- The nutshell of moral tribes: in everyday life and basic matters of right and wrong (me versus us), you should trust your gut intuitions and not overthink them; but on the moral issues that divide groups (us versus them), you must step back from intuitions and reason slowly, because it is precisely our conflicting moral intuitions that have us at each other's throats.176 | Joshua Greene on Morality, Psychology, and Trolley Problems