normative

Singer's Drowning Child Moral Equivalence

Peter Singer's nonobvious insight—that saving a drowning child in front of you (ruining a $500 suit) is morally equivalent to donating that $500 to save a distant child's life—is basically right; our intuitions fire for the proximate child because we evolved biologically and culturally to cooperate within small groups, so the real puzzle is not why we ignore distant suffering but why we care about anyone, and a genuine global meta-morality requires valuing distant lives as much as near ones, at least in publicly justifiable policy if not in our hearts.

normativepending

Speaker

Joshua Greene

Evidence Quote

“it's going to require valuing the lives, valuing the wellbeing of distant people as much as we value the wellbeing of people who are nearby. Maybe not in our hearts, but at least in terms of the kinds of policies that we feel that we can publicly justify.”

Source

Joshua Greene on Moral Tribes, Moral Dilemmas, and Utilitarianism— EconTalk
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:29:56 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...