market failures
Situations where unregulated markets are claimed to produce inefficient outcomes, used by interventionists to justify government correction.
As defined in Larry White on the Clash of Economic Ideas
Where it comes up · 3
- Michael Munger on Industrial Policy2 claims
- Larry White on the Clash of Economic Ideas1 claim
- Does Chinese Industrial Policy Work?: A Big Data China Event1 claim
Most important claims · 4 of 4Search all claims for “market failures” →
- Once market failures are accounted for, profit is neither necessary nor sufficient to establish that an activity is socially beneficial: a profitable firm may not be socially valuable, and a loss-making firm may not deserve to close, which is the core analytical opening that industrial-policy advocates exploit to justify government putting a thumb on the scale.Michael Munger on Industrial Policy
- India's central planning was implemented as the 'Permit Raj,' under which firms needed permits to exceed quotas, enter industries, or import equipment, and the resulting economy stagnated at a weak rate of growth (the 'Hindu rate of growth'), which led economists like Jagdish Bhagwati—initially trained as planners by left-Keynesians like Kaldor and Robinson—to abandon the planning approach after observing the actual results.Larry White on the Clash of Economic Ideas
- Standard market failures—asymmetric information, public goods, externalities—justify regulation, not industrial policy; industrial policy is distinctly about steering the flow of capital into or out of specific industries relative to what an omniscient benevolent dictator knows to be the socially optimal pattern of investment.Michael Munger on Industrial Policy
- Market failures like learning-by-doing (in semiconductors, EV batteries) and infant industries justify economic arguments for industrial policies, and these are legitimate considerations even if implementation is difficult.Does Chinese Industrial Policy Work?: A Big Data China Event