marginal productivity
Economic theory that a worker's pay reflects the additional output their labor contributes; Piketty argues it is naive for explaining top executive pay.
As defined in Thomas Piketty on Inequality and Capital in the 21st Century
Where it comes up · 4
- Thomas Leonard on Race, Eugenics, and Illiberal Reformers3 claims
- 283 | Daron Acemoglu on Technology, Inequality, and Power3 claims
- Luigi Zingales on Incentives and the Potential Capture of Economists by Special Interests2 claims
- Thomas Piketty on Inequality and Capital in the 21st Century1 claim
Most important claims · 9 of 9Search all claims for “marginal productivity” →
- The anti-immigration argument rested on a low-standard-of-living theory of wages: if wages are determined by living standards rather than productivity, then the meat-eating Anglo-Saxon could not compete with the rice-eating Chinese worker, with race invoked to explain the low standards—as in Wilson's claim that white laborers could not 'live upon a handful of rice for a pittance' and Ely's call to exclude 'discordant elements like the Chinese.'Thomas Leonard on Race, Eugenics, and Illiberal Reformers
- The economics of the anti-Chinese argument was incoherent: just because a worker lives frugally or can subsist on little does not mean they will accept low wages—if there is any market competition they won't; frugality means saving money to bring family over or start a business, so the supposed link between subsistence living and substandard wages does not follow.Thomas Leonard on Race, Eugenics, and Illiberal Reformers
- At the time, labor economics (not yet called that) had not fully adopted marginal productivity as a theory of wage determination; it was a mishmash in which wages were thought partly determined by living standards, so if living standards could be made a function of race or gender, the racialized wage-competition argument could proceed.Thomas Leonard on Race, Eugenics, and Illiberal Reformers
- The theory of marginal productivity is naive for explaining top managerial compensation, because individual marginal productivities are very hard to observe in large corporations; managers have strong incentives to extract as much pay as they can, and lower marginal tax rates since the 1970s-80s radically changed those incentives.Thomas Piketty on Inequality and Capital in the 21st Century
- Using IGM survey data where economists' named opinions are public, Zingales found that economists who serve on corporate boards are significantly less likely to believe CEOs are paid above their marginal productivity than those who do not, consistent with either selection (negative views are not invited onto boards) or shaping (board service alters one's views).Luigi Zingales on Incentives and the Potential Capture of Economists by Special Interests
- The 'factory of the future' parable—a factory with only a man and a dog, where the man feeds the dog and the dog keeps the man from touching the equipment—illustrates that even if such a factory doubles its output, there is no reason to pay or hire more workers because their marginal productivity (contribution to output) is near zero, even though average productivity is huge; this is the danger if technology is used only to eliminate workers.283 | Daron Acemoglu on Technology, Inequality, and Power
- Even if technology raises a worker's contribution to output, workers may capture none of the gains when laws and institutions are stacked against them and employers are organized to repress them—as under the UK's Masters and Servants Acts, where a worker who tried to quit for a better job could be taken to court and jailed—so shared prosperity requires both productivity-enhancing technology and a balanced distribution of power embedded in institutions and social norms.283 | Daron Acemoglu on Technology, Inequality, and Power
- A large fraction of the economy involves social interaction, real-world action, wisdom, judgment, and creativity that are beyond current AI; but if AI is treated as an informational tool that provides context-dependent, reliable, real-time information rather than something that mimics humans, it can raise the marginal productivity of many workers—for example, helping an average electrician troubleshoot a complex problem as well as the very best electrician could.283 | Daron Acemoglu on Technology, Inequality, and Power
- If economists answer expert-opinion surveys strategically or politically rather than according to their economic analysis — as Zingales suspects happened with a tournament theorist who denies CEOs are overpaid despite his own models implying it — then the surveys lose their purpose of revealing how economists actually think about the world.Luigi Zingales on Incentives and the Potential Capture of Economists by Special Interests