manipulation
An influence that appeals to a person's System 1 and bypasses their deliberative capacities, as opposed to a legitimate appeal to reflection.
As defined in Cass Sunstein
Where it comes up · 2
- The Influence Expert: 7 Ways to Get People to Do What You Want (Even When They Don't Want To)5 claims
- Cass Sunstein1 claim
Most important claims · 6 of 6Search all claims for “manipulation” →
- Influence involves pointing to psychological principles where they naturally exist and informing people into assent by raising the profile of those principles in communication, whereas manipulation involves the fabrication or counterfeiting of these principles, such as lying with statistics or presenting non-experts as authorities.The Influence Expert: 7 Ways to Get People to Do What You Want (Even When They Don't Want To)
- To identify fake online reviews, look for reviews that use many personal stories (indicating lack of product knowledge), use verbs rather than nouns (focusing on personal actions rather than product features), and avoid the 4.2-4.7 star range which consumers recognize as suspicious; ratings below 4.2 suggest poor quality while ratings above 4.7 signal obvious manipulation.The Influence Expert: 7 Ways to Get People to Do What You Want (Even When They Don't Want To)
- The liking principle—that we prefer to say yes to people we like—can be leveraged by identifying and pointing to genuine commonalities that exist between you and the other person, such as shared interests, hometowns, or educational backgrounds, because similarity creates rapport and increases willingness to do business.The Influence Expert: 7 Ways to Get People to Do What You Want (Even When They Don't Want To)
- When companies are caught providing fake reviews or inflating ratings, people should publicly penalize them through online channels and refuse to do business with them, not just individually avoid them—visible penalties at the 'bottom line level' reduce manipulation because companies calculate costs of being caught against benefits of deception.The Influence Expert: 7 Ways to Get People to Do What You Want (Even When They Don't Want To)
- Defense against authority manipulation: ask two questions—(1) Is this person truly an expert on this topic? (2) Does this person have a reason (payment, product gifts, income) to recommend this that is independent of merit?—if the answer to either is no, unhook their perceived authority.The Influence Expert: 7 Ways to Get People to Do What You Want (Even When They Don't Want To)
- As a first approximation, manipulation is when an agent appeals to System 1 (intuitive, rapid processing) rather than to people's deliberative System 2 faculties; a System 2 nudge like a reminder or fuel economy label is by definition not manipulation, whereas appeals that wholly bypass deliberative capacities carry at least a risk of manipulation, even if they may be justified all things considered.Cass Sunstein