macronutrient
The major dietary energy components—carbohydrate, protein, and fat—whose composition Taubes argues matters more than total calories.
As defined in Gary Taubes on Why We Get Fat
Where it comes up · 3
- Eating with Intelligence (with Julia Belluz)4 claims
- Weightlifting Is A Waste of Time & So Is Cardio - Dr John Jaquish2 claims
- Gary Taubes on Why We Get Fat1 claim
Most important claims · 7 of 7Search all claims for “macronutrient” →
- Weight loss is not a linear equation where cutting a fixed number of calories yields a fixed weight loss; instead the body reacts dynamically to any lifestyle change—reduced food, more exercise, less sleep—by adjusting metabolism and appetite, which undermines the assumption that, say, cutting out one soda daily will produce a predictable annual weight loss.Eating with Intelligence (with Julia Belluz)
- The effect sizes of food-environment interventions are massive compared to tweaking macronutrient composition: when Kevin Hall exposed people to ultra-processed versus whole-food environments and told them to eat as much or as little as they wanted, they spontaneously ate 500 to 1000 more calories per day in the ultra-processed environment, far outstripping any low-carb versus low-fat difference.Eating with Intelligence (with Julia Belluz)
- Feeding diet-study subjects a fixed low calorie level (e.g., 1700 calories) removes hunger from the equation and assumes the conclusion that you must eat less; a valid test must set calories high (e.g., 3000) to reveal differences between macronutrient compositions, but this introduces problems of satiety and intervention effects from weight-motivated subjects.Gary Taubes on Why We Get Fat
- Beyond fat loss, changing macronutrient composition creates different hormonal and immune responses in the body, which is why low-carb diets have long been used to treat conditions like epilepsy—endpoints Belluz finds far more interesting than the fat-loss question that has dominated the debate.Eating with Intelligence (with Julia Belluz)
- In Kevin Hall's repeated controlled studies, people lost about the same amount of body fat on low-carb versus low-fat diets when calories were held equal—with at most a negligible slight advantage to the lower-fat diet—contradicting Gary Taubes's claim that reducing carbohydrates creates a unique fat-burning metabolic advantage.Eating with Intelligence (with Julia Belluz)
- X3 users who gain minimal muscle (e.g., 1 lb over 6 months) are typically not eating sufficient protein rather than experiencing training failure; protein intake is the limiting factor for most users after training protocol is correctWeightlifting Is A Waste of Time & So Is Cardio - Dr John Jaquish
- Carbohydrates are not truly a macronutrient but rather exist in nature to get you fatter when it's advantageous (before winter) and are not essential for most bodily functions, which is why only fat and protein are real macronutrientsWeightlifting Is A Waste of Time & So Is Cardio - Dr John Jaquish