factual

Fixed-Calorie Diet Studies Are Invalid

Feeding diet-study subjects a fixed low calorie level (e.g., 1700 calories) removes hunger from the equation and assumes the conclusion that you must eat less; a valid test must set calories high (e.g., 3000) to reveal differences between macronutrient compositions, but this introduces problems of satiety and intervention effects from weight-motivated subjects.

factualpending

Speaker

Gary Taubes

Evidence Quote

“we're using obese subjects who want to lose weight; that's why they entered the study. So they might decide to eat less and be hungry all the time because they want to lose weight. So now we are not going to see the full physiological effect of the diet.”

Source

Gary Taubes on Why We Get Fat— EconTalk
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:17:14 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...