lexical copying
An alternative to movement in which different forms of a word (e.g., declarative vs interrogative auxiliaries) are learned as separate lexical entries rather than derived by moving one form.
As defined in Edward Gibson
Where it comes up · 1
- Edward Gibson2 claims
Most important claims · 2 of 2Search all claims for “lexical copying” →
- Chomsky's grammar combines phrase structure with movement (e.g., auxiliary verbs moving to the front to form questions), but in 1971 he showed this combination creates learnability problems—it becomes impossible for a child to figure out the underlying structure—which he resolved by positing innate universal grammar; Gibson argues that abandoning movement in favor of lexical copying makes language learnable from input.Edward Gibson
- The lexical copying account is favored over movement because auxiliary verbs don't all behave uniformly: some work only in interrogative form ('Aren't I invited?' but not 'I aren't invited'), which is naturally explained by learning word-specific usage but is hard for a general movement rule.Edward Gibson