causal

Chomsky's Movement Theory Causes Learnability Problems

Chomsky's grammar combines phrase structure with movement (e.g., auxiliary verbs moving to the front to form questions), but in 1971 he showed this combination creates learnability problems—it becomes impossible for a child to figure out the underlying structure—which he resolved by positing innate universal grammar; Gibson argues that abandoning movement in favor of lexical copying makes language learnable from input.

causalpending

Speaker

Edward Gibson

Evidence Quote

“the movement story leads to learnability problems. It leads to problems for how language is learned.”

Source

Edward Gibson— Lex Fridman Podcast
Created: 6/13/2026, 3:34:36 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...