legislation
In Hayek's distinction, the formal, deliberately designed rules created by authorities (the rule book), as opposed to spontaneously evolved 'law.'
As defined in Michael Munger on Sports, Norms, Rules, and the Code
Where it comes up · 4
- The Underrated Bruno Leoni (with Michael Munger)9 claims
- Boudreaux on Law and Legislation 12/11/20065 claims
- Moshe Koppel on Norms, Tradition, and Resilient Societies3 claims
- Michael Munger on Sports, Norms, Rules, and the Code1 claim
Most important claims · 10 of 18Search all claims for “legislation” →
- Leoni introduced Hayek to the concept of common law as an alternative to legislation, so that Hayek's famous distinction between law and legislation in part owes to Leoni, by Hayek's own acknowledgment.The Underrated Bruno Leoni (with Michael Munger)
- Leoni changed Hayek's mind by arguing that black-letter written law does not actually provide certainty, because a legislature can change it tomorrow and courts can reinterpret it; genuine predictability comes instead from something that emerges out of a tradition that is hard to change.The Underrated Bruno Leoni (with Michael Munger)
- Quoting Freedom and the Law, Leoni argued that no legislator could establish the rules governing everyone's actual behavior without continuous collaboration from all concerned—no polls or referenda suffice—just as planners cannot discover total supply and demand; therefore a legislation-centered legal system resembles a centralized economy run by a handful of directors with fatally limited knowledge, making it arbitrary and possibly a road to tyranny.The Underrated Bruno Leoni (with Michael Munger)
- Legislation is consciously designed rules enforced ultimately by the threat of state violence, whereas law is the emergent patterns of behavior incorporated into most people's expectations, which may or may not be enforced by force; much that looks like legislation (e.g. Hammurabi's Code) is actually a codification of pre-existing law.Boudreaux on Law and Legislation 12/11/2006
- Hayek's deepest insight in Law, Legislation and Liberty is that law itself can emerge from unplanned human actions in the same way that prices, product qualities and market arrangements evolve from individuals pursuing their self-interest, so good law can arise spontaneously rather than being designed.Boudreaux on Law and Legislation 12/11/2006
- Leoni's most radical and important idea is an explicit analogy: markets are to centrally planned economies as common law is to legislation; the core obstacle is not incentives but the knowledge problem—no one could possibly know enough to write a law encompassing all future circumstances, just as no planner could discover total demand and supply.The Underrated Bruno Leoni (with Michael Munger)
- Conservatism and libertarianism fit together coherently: the conservative side says communities should preserve their traditions because doing so confers real advantages, while the libertarian side says the state must not coerce those traditions—because the moment the state enforces a tradition, it ceases to adapt and evolve and thereby ceases to be a living tradition.Moshe Koppel on Norms, Tradition, and Resilient Societies
- What is written down in legislation is often not what is actually enforced—the speed limit may be 65 but the real understood 'law' is 67-72—and any complex legislation contains many such cases where, because not every case can be delineated and full enforcement is impossible, an emergent set of behaviors becomes the 'real law' in the Hayek-Leoni sense of expectations.The Underrated Bruno Leoni (with Michael Munger)
- Speed limits illustrate the law/legislation gap: although the black-letter legislation says 55, the actual law (the accepted expectation) is that driving about five miles over in good conditions is not really breaking the law, which is why a ticket for going 60 feels like a wrong while a ticket for going 95 does not.Boudreaux on Law and Legislation 12/11/2006
- Common law is powerful because no legislation can mandate, outline, or describe all possible cases that will arise; legislation necessarily uses vague phrases like 'good working order,' and the genius of common law is that it lets the case-by-case experience of disputants determine what expectations are at a given time and place, which can differ across cities, countries, and eras.The Underrated Bruno Leoni (with Michael Munger)