law of non-contradiction
The Greek logical principle that one cannot simultaneously hold mutually exclusive beliefs; Paine notes it is prioritized in the West but not necessarily in the East.
As defined in Sarah Paine — Why Japan lost WWII (lecture & interview)
Where it comes up · 7
- Sarah C.M. Paine: What Is China's Grand Strategy?2 claims
- A History of Philosophy | 21 Augustine's Christian Philosophy1 claim
- A History of Philosophy | 57 Hegel1 claim
- Sarah Paine — Why Japan lost WWII (lecture & interview)1 claim
- A History of Philosophy | 11 Aristotle's Metaphysics 21 claim
- How Superpowers Self-destruct Russian Chinese American Grand Strategy Sarah C.m. Paine1 claim
- 115 - Sam Harris Lawrence Krauss And Matt Dillahunty 11 claim
Most important claims · 8 of 8Search all claims for “law of non-contradiction” →
- Western civilization is built on three foundational pillars: Greek analytical thinking (laws of identity and non-contradiction), Roman law and institutions for enforcement, and Christian values emphasizing that the individual has a soul that precedes and supersedes government.Sarah C.M. Paine: What Is China's Grand Strategy?
- The laws of logic (identity, non-contradiction, excluded middle) do not define what something is; they merely provide the framework for categorizing things—like a Venn diagram circle that says everything is either inside or outside it without telling you what the circle contains—so quantum phenomena like superposition do not violate logic but simply require redefining the categories as we learn more about reality.115 - Sam Harris Lawrence Krauss And Matt Dillahunty 1
- In *Against the Academicians*, Augustine argues against skeptics that all humans possess truth, and this truth includes logical truths (truths with the logical form of the law of identity or non-contradiction), self-knowledge of existence (his 'si fallor, sum' - if I am mistaken I still must exist), and knowledge that even the skeptic denying knowledge must himself exist to make the denial.A History of Philosophy | 21 Augustine's Christian Philosophy
- Hegel regards the traditional laws of logic (identity, non-contradiction, excluded middle) as trivial when applied to static propositions about unchanging reality, because reality is process and nothing stays the same—therefore the law of identity (A=A) holds only at a single moment, while in actual becoming there is no 'same time' between past and future.A History of Philosophy | 57 Hegel
- The apparent contradiction between Japanese hierarchical loyalty and the insubordinate coups by junior officers dissolves once one recognizes that the Western law of non-contradiction is not prioritized in the East; instead, group loyalties to one's subgroup or unit take precedence, so behavior follows social values rather than logical consistency.Sarah Paine — Why Japan lost WWII (lecture & interview)
- Western civilization rests on three pillars: Greek analytical thinking (the law of identity and the law of non-contradiction), Roman law and the institutions to enforce it rather than personal rule, and Christian values centered on the individual having a soul that precedes government.How Superpowers Self-destruct Russian Chinese American Grand Strategy Sarah C.m. Paine
- The law of non-contradiction states that a being cannot both be and not be something at the same time and in the same respect; equivalently, one cannot both affirm and deny something at the same time and in the same respect, symbolized as 'A is not non-A'.A History of Philosophy | 11 Aristotle's Metaphysics 2
- Western civilization is built on three pillars: Greek analytical thinking (law of identity, law of non-contradiction), Roman law (institutions and rules enforced equally rather than through personal rule), and Christian values emphasizing that the individual has a soul and inherent worth that precedes government authority.Sarah C.M. Paine: What Is China's Grand Strategy?