law (Hayekian sense)
Emergent patterns of behavior incorporated into most people's expectations, recognized as binding, which may be enforced by force but need not be—distinct from consciously designed legislation.
As defined in Boudreaux on Law and Legislation 12/11/2006
Where it comes up · 1
Most important claims · 10 of 12Search all claims for “law (Hayekian sense)” →
- The medieval law merchant (lex mercatoria) is the best-studied example of spontaneously emerged law: merchant courts not enforced by any sovereign produced nuanced, workable commercial rules that even losing defendants obeyed, because reputation and continued access to Mediterranean commerce—not state force—made compliance worthwhile, and this body of law survives today as the core of the Uniform Commercial Code.Boudreaux on Law and Legislation 12/11/2006
- The reasonable-person standard pervading Anglo-American tort, contract, and property law is a monument to the idea that law is built on people's expectations: what is 'reasonable' (e.g. expecting doorknobs to remain when taking possession of a house) depends on prevailing societal expectations, and can be overridden when a contract specifies otherwise.Boudreaux on Law and Legislation 12/11/2006
- Milton Friedman argued in 1974 that the sheer number of laws is so great that essentially anyone could be sent to prison if prosecutors were sufficiently determined, so business leaders comply with restrictions on freedom out of fear of antitrust suits, tax scrutiny, or other charges rather than moral agreement.Boudreaux on Law and Legislation 12/11/2006
- 'Judge-made law' is a conceptual mistake; in the common law the judge does not make law but discovers, finds, or articulates the pre-existing expectations of the parties—when a judge actually makes law he is acting as a legislator, which is the kernel of truth in conservative objections to judicial activism.Boudreaux on Law and Legislation 12/11/2006
- Reserving a cafeteria seat by placing books or a backpack on it is a clear example of true law: it is written nowhere in statute, constitution, or handbook, yet it is a widely recognized expectation whose violation feels like a genuine wrong even though it can be broken.Boudreaux on Law and Legislation 12/11/2006
- Legislation is consciously designed rules enforced ultimately by the threat of state violence, whereas law is the emergent patterns of behavior incorporated into most people's expectations, which may or may not be enforced by force; much that looks like legislation (e.g. Hammurabi's Code) is actually a codification of pre-existing law.Boudreaux on Law and Legislation 12/11/2006
- Hayek's deepest insight in Law, Legislation and Liberty is that law itself can emerge from unplanned human actions in the same way that prices, product qualities and market arrangements evolve from individuals pursuing their self-interest, so good law can arise spontaneously rather than being designed.Boudreaux on Law and Legislation 12/11/2006
- When a judge rules contrary to widely held expectations, more conflict and litigation result; through a spontaneous process the correct ruling—the one conforming to expectations—tends to be the one that produces less conflict and therefore endures and is understood as the law.Boudreaux on Law and Legislation 12/11/2006
- Speed limits illustrate the law/legislation gap: although the black-letter legislation says 55, the actual law (the accepted expectation) is that driving about five miles over in good conditions is not really breaking the law, which is why a ticket for going 60 feels like a wrong while a ticket for going 95 does not.Boudreaux on Law and Legislation 12/11/2006
- The spontaneously evolved expectations that underlie common law have genuine virtue—they are not merely arbitrary custom—because, as Bob Cooter argued, the common law is efficient precisely because courts adopt expectations and rules that emerged through a competitive discovery process in which ineffective practices are dropped and effective ones persist.Boudreaux on Law and Legislation 12/11/2006