judgment
Informal measurement process where information is integrated using the mind as the measuring instrument; always involves some degree of intuition at the final stage but can be more or less deliberate
As defined in Daniel Kahneman | The Knowledge Project #68
Where it comes up · 3
- Daniel Kahneman | The Knowledge Project #6816 claims
- Fed up federal judge finally drops the HAMMER on Giuliani5 claims
- The Art of Failure: The Unexpected Path to Success (Audio)3 claims
Most important claims · 10 of 24Search all claims for “judgment” →
- In golf and markets, there is a paradox about opportunity: sometimes you have to let things happen naturally (wait for genuine opportunity), and sometimes you have to force a result; knowing which situation applies requires experience and judgment, and people often fail by forcing when they should wait or vice versa.The Art of Failure: The Unexpected Path to Success (Audio)
- Intuitive judgment is trustworthy only in stable environments with repeated attempts, rapid feedback, and opportunity to learn patterns (like chess or firefighting), but most decisions made in organizations do not fit this environment, yet organizations make these decisions on judgment and experience anyway.Daniel Kahneman | The Knowledge Project #68
- Organizations think more slowly and have procedures for thinking, so you can control the procedures and have more hope of improving organizational judgment than individual judgment; individual judgment is really hard to fix.Daniel Kahneman | The Knowledge Project #68
- When you want to improve decision-making, you should slow down, especially when you have an immediate strong conviction, and use procedures and algorithms; whenever you can replace judgment with rules and algorithms, algorithms will produce better decisions even though there are social costs to trusting algorithms.Daniel Kahneman | The Knowledge Project #68
- Noise is useless variability in judgment—when multiple underwriters at an insurance company assess the same case, they vary by about 50% in the premiums they assign, far more than expected by executives (who predict about 10%), and this variation produces no feedback or learning, just costly inconsistency.Daniel Kahneman | The Knowledge Project #68
- For judgment problems where you're evaluating a situation or considering options and trying to score them, Kahneman's advice derives from a system he designed as a 22-year-old psychologist in the Israeli army for interviewing recruits: identify separate traits or dimensions, evaluate each independently, score each, and only after collecting all dimension scores should you form a global intuitive judgment.Daniel Kahneman | The Knowledge Project #68
- Judge Lewis Liman characterized Rudy Giuliani's explanations for non-compliance as 'farcical' and warned him that he will be held in contempt of court if he doesn't deliver his assetsFed up federal judge finally drops the HAMMER on Giuliani
- Keeping meetings short is important for improving their quality, but more important is structuring meetings to discuss one topic at a time, having staff prepare briefing books where each chapter ends with a score on one dimension, and then structuring board discussion around these dimensional scores rather than global impressionsDaniel Kahneman | The Knowledge Project #68
- Scale training and shared frame of reference training, where people learn how to use an evaluation scale consistently with others, is an important component of noise reduction and is used in human resources performance evaluation (frame of reference training) and super forecaster training (probability scale learning)Daniel Kahneman | The Knowledge Project #68
- Slowing down evaluation is achieved by focusing systematically on separate dimensions or evidence points, delaying overall judgment until the full profile is reviewed, and where possible identifying deal-breakers early but otherwise resisting the urge to form a conclusionDaniel Kahneman | The Knowledge Project #68