joint hypothesis problem
The principle that any test of market efficiency is simultaneously a test of an assumed risk-return model, so the two cannot be tested independently.
As defined in Eugene Fama on Finance
Where it comes up · 3
- The Market is Getting Less Efficient: Here is Why That is GREAT for Value Investors | Cliff Asness2 claims
- Eugene Fama on Finance1 claim
- This Paper Could Change How You Invest1 claim
Most important claims · 4 of 4Search all claims for “joint hypothesis problem” →
- Whenever you test market efficiency you are jointly testing it with some model of risk and return; the two are joined at the hip and cannot be separated, which means market efficiency is not testable on its own—but conversely a risk-return model is also untestable without assuming market efficiency.Eugene Fama on Finance
- The joint hypothesis problem states that we cannot determine whether markets are efficient without an asset pricing model to test efficiency, and we cannot prove whether an asset pricing model is correct without knowing whether markets are efficient, making it impossible to definitively resolve whether anomalies represent market inefficiency or incorrect modelsThis Paper Could Change How You Invest
- Testing market efficiency is historically extremely difficult because of the joint hypothesis problem: you cannot test whether markets are efficient without simultaneously testing a model of how prices should reflect information, and rejections of efficiency could mean either markets are inefficient or your model is wrong.The Market is Getting Less Efficient: Here is Why That is GREAT for Value Investors | Cliff Asness
- The core issue with testing market efficiency is the joint hypothesis problem: you cannot test whether markets are efficient without simultaneously assuming a model of how prices should reflect information (like the Capital Asset Pricing Model), so a rejection of the hypothesis could mean either markets are inefficient OR the model is wrong.The Market is Getting Less Efficient: Here is Why That is GREAT for Value Investors | Cliff Asness