What this covers

Ben Felix walks through the 1993 Fama-French paper in the Journal of Financial Economics as a solo, structured explainer. He starts with the basics of risk, expected return and asset pricing, then covers CAPM), which won Bill Sharpe a Nobel Prize in 1990. He defines beta) and describes the anomalies that kept turning up, certain kinds of stocks earning more than their betas could account for. The middle of the video covers the paper's method: size and value factors built as long-short portfolios, and time series regressions that produce factor loadings and alpha. Felix then reports the results. Market beta explained roughly 60% of return differences across the test portfolios, and the three-factor model about 90%.

The video also covers territory beyond the paper itself. Felix explains the joint hypothesis problem, which means an anomaly cannot be cleanly classified as market inefficiency or a flawed model. He notes that Robert Merton and others had already raised the idea of multiple risks, and that the new contribution was identifying and measuring them. He traces the origin of alpha to a 1968 study of mutual fund managers. His practical claim is that many successful active funds may simply hold known factor exposures, which could be replicated more cheaply than their fees.

Later sections turn to what followed. The 2015 five-factor model added profitability and investment. A 2016 census by Hou, Lu, and Harvey counted 316 published factors, the "factor zoo" that John Cochrane named. Felix presents as contested the view that, once transaction costs are counted, the five-factor model is a strong base for building and judging portfolios. He closes with applications, discussing Dimensional Fund Advisors and Avantis Investors, and discloses his firm's long use of Dimensional products and that he was not paid for the mentions.

Sharpest takeaway

Fama and French's 1993 three-factor model revolutionized asset pricing by demonstrating that market beta alone explains only ~60% of return differences across diversified portfolios, but adding size and value factors increases explanatory power to ~90%, proving that multiple systematic risk factors—not market beta alone—drive expected returns.

  • CAPM's single market beta factor could only explain 60% of differences in returns between diversified portfolios, leaving significant anomalies unexplained
  • Fama and French's three-factor model (market, size, value) achieved R-squared values of 0.83-0.97 across 25 test portfolios, with minimal alphas indicating near-perfect explanatory power
  • The model's success demonstrated that size and value are systematic risk factors investors are compensated for, not market inefficiencies or anomalies

The claims · ranked23 claims · weighted by value

This asset isn't compiled yet

You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.

0.80

The joint hypothesis problem states that we cannot determine whether markets are efficient without an asset pricing model to test efficiency, and we cannot prove whether an asset pricing model is correct without knowing whether markets are efficient, making it impossible to definitively resolve whether anomalies represent market inefficiency or incorrect models

definitionhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Ben Felix

“An asset pricing anomaly could mean one of two things. If we believe the CAPM is a perfect model for explaining expected returns, anomalies must mean that markets are not efficient. Or, if we know that markets are efficient, the CAPM must be wrong. The asset pricing model must be wrong. This point turns out to be impossible to resolve. It's actually called the joint hypothesis problem. We can't say whether markets are efficient without having an asset pricing model to test market efficiency, and we can't prove whether an asset pricing model is right without knowing whether markets are efficient.”

0.74

The proliferation of factors from empirical asset pricing research became a problem or a joke, described as a 'factors zoo' by John Cochrane in his 2011 presidential address to the American Finance Association.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Ben Felix

“It became a bit of a problem or a joke. In 2011, John Cochrane in his presidential address to the American Finance Association described the proliferation of factors as a zoo, a factors zoo.”

0.74

Eugene Fama and Kenneth French's 1993 paper in the Journal of Financial Economics with nearly 15,000 citations demonstrated that three factors (market, size, and value) explain the vast majority of differences in returns across diversified portfolios, fundamentally changing financial economics and portfolio management

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Ben Felix

“A 1993 paper in the Journal of Financial Economics with nearly 15,000 citations today changed financial economics and portfolio management forever. Eugene Fama and Kenneth French found that a group of three factors explained the vast majority of differences in returns across diversified portfolios.”

0.74

Alpha was first used in 1968 academic research to describe excess risk-adjusted returns, in a paper that tested whether actively managed mutual fund managers generated returns in excess of what should be expected based on the amount of risk (measured by CAPM beta) they were taking, finding that active managers were not able to beat the market

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Ben Felix

“That last term, alpha, is really important. It was first used to describe excess risk-adjusted returns in a 1968 academic paper, another banger if you're into this kind of thing. That paper used the single factor capital asset pricing model to ask whether actively managed mutual fund managers were generating returns in excess of what should be expected based on the amount of risk they were taking. It's worth mentioning that active managers in the study were not able to beat the market, but that's another topic.”

0.74

In response to the proliferation of factors, Fama and French updated their 1993 research in 2015 by introducing a five-factor model that added two new factors: profitability (RMW or robust minus weak, capturing excess returns from highly profitable companies over weakly profitable ones) and investment (conservative minus aggressive, capturing excess returns from companies with slow asset growth over rapid asset growth)

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Ben Felix

“In the face of the slop proliferation, Fama and French went on to update their groundbreaking 1993 research in 2015, which introduced two new asset pricing factors, profitability and investment. Profitability is expressed as RMW or robust minus weak. That's the excess return expected from companies with high profitability over those with weak profitability. Investment is expressed as conservative minus aggressive. Companies that grow their assets slowly, conservative, tend to outperform those that pour cash into rapid asset growth, aggressive.”

0.74

The idea that investors might care about multiple types of risk was not new when the Fama-French paper came out, as Robert Merton and others had written about this idea before, but figuring out what those risks might be and how to measure them was new.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Ben Felix

“The idea that investors might care about multiple types of risk was not new when this paper came out. Robert Merton and others had written about this idea before, but figuring out what those risks might be and how to measure them was new.”

0.74

If an active fund has beaten the market, there is a really good chance it did so by maintaining exposure to some of the well-known factors (market, size, value), and since an active manager might be doing nothing more than this, you could probably replicate their factor exposure at a lower cost than the fee that most active managers charge.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Ben Felix

“Basically, if an active fund has beaten the market, there's a really good chance it did so by maintaining exposure to some of the well-known factors. This matters because if that is all an active manager is doing, you could probably replicate their factor exposure at a lower cost than the fee that most active managers charge.”

0.70

Stocks are riskier than bonds and therefore have higher expected returns, but what if some types of stocks have systematically higher expected returns than others based on exposure to undiversifiable risks that investors are sensitive to.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Ben Felix

“It's commonly known that stocks are riskier than bonds and therefore have higher expected returns. But, what if some types of stocks have systematically higher expected returns than others? In Fama and French's original framing, common undiversifiable risks that a lot of investors are sensitive to, how to explain why some stocks have higher returns than others.”

0.69

Dimensional Fund Advisors, founded with Eugene Fama as a founding director (who remains on the board), and with long-standing connections to Kenneth French, has implemented factor investing research in real investment products and has achieved a very good track record over decades using these strategies

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Ben Felix

“There are fund companies that using this research, this asset pricing research to build real investment portfolios, real investment products that you can invest in. They're kind of like low-cost index funds that deliver exposure to more than just market risk, but they're not actually index funds in most cases. Dimensional Fund Advisors has a long history of implementing factor investing research. Eugene Fama, one of this paper's authors, was a founding director and remains on the board today. Kenneth French, the other co-author, has long-standing connections to Dimensional. As I detailed in a previous video, their track record using these strategies has been very good over decades.”

0.66

Despite CAPM's dominance from the 1970s and 1980s, consistent research showed that certain types of stocks had higher returns than could be explained by their CAPM betas, leading these unexplained patterns to be called asset pricing anomalies

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Ben Felix

“Even though the CAPM defined and then dominated the study of asset pricing from its inception through the 70s and 80s, research had consistently come out showing that certain types of stocks had higher returns than what could be explained by their CAPM betas. Since these observations could not be explained by an asset pricing model, by the asset pricing model at the time, they were referred to as anomalies.”

0.66

Market beta alone could only explain around 60% of the differences in returns across Fama and French's test portfolios, whereas their three-factor model explained around 90%, representing an increase of approximately 30 percentage points in explanatory power

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Ben Felix

“In their tests, Fama and French found that market beta could only explain around 60% of the differences in returns across their test portfolios. Let that sink in for a minute. We went from being able to explain about 60% of the differences in returns between diversified portfolios with the CAPM to being able to explain around 90% with the Fama and French three-factor model.”

0.62

There is ongoing debate in academia and in practice about which asset pricing factors make sense and which model to use, but when transaction costs are accounted for, the Fama-French five-factor model provides a very strong foundation for portfolio construction and evaluating portfolio performance

normativehigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Ben Felix

“Don't get me wrong, there is still plenty of ongoing debate both in academia and in practice about which factors make sense and which asset pricing model we should be using. I'm pretty comfortable saying that when transaction costs are accounted for, Fama and French's five-factor model is a very strong foundation for thinking about portfolio construction and evaluating portfolio performance.”

0.61

A 2016 census by Hou, Lu, and Harvey found that 316 distinct factors had been published in academic journals by that time, with more published since then, contributing to what has been called 'factor slop'

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Ben Felix

“A 2016 census from Hou, Lu, and Harvey confirmed this concept finding that 316 distinct factors had been published in academic journals at that time and more since then. This created a whole new set of techniques for choosing factors and comparing asset pricing models.”

0.55

Determining which types of stocks to tilt toward and how to do so effectively and at low cost are complex questions that fund companies like Dimensional Fund Advisors and Avantis Investors attempt to solve by creating low-cost, broadly diversified investment portfolios specifically designed to apply academic factor investing theory to investor portfolios

normativehigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Ben Felix

“But which types of stocks and knowing how to do it effectively and at a low cost is a whole other question. Fortunately, there are fund companies like Dimensional Fund Advisors and Avantis Investors that do this, creating low-cost and broadly diversified investment portfolios specifically built to take academic theory and apply it to your portfolio.”

0.38

A beta of one means a stock tends to move up and down by similar amounts to the market; a higher beta means the stock will tend to be up more when the market is up and down more when the market is down; a beta less than one means the opposite.

definitionestablishednovelty 0/4durability 4/4· Ben Felix

“A beta of one means that a stock tends to move up and down by a similar amount to the market. A higher beta, more than one, means that the stock will tend to be up more when the market is up and down more when the market is down, and vice versa for a beta less than one.”

0.34

Bill Sharpe won the Nobel Memorial Prize in Economic Sciences in 1990 for his work developing the Capital Asset Pricing Model because it formalized the relationship between risk and expected return and performed well in explaining observed stock returns

factualestablishednovelty 0/4durability 4/4· Ben Felix

“According to this single factor model, where exposure to market risk is the only risk care about, stocks with higher betas should on average deliver higher returns. The CAPM was a big deal in finance. I mean, big enough to win Bill Sharpe the Nobel Memorial Prize in Economic Sciences in 1990 for his work on it, because it formalized a relationship between risk and expected return. And it did a pretty good job of explaining the observed returns of stocks.”

0.34

Expected return is the return an investor expects from investing in a stock or bond, and the study of expected returns is referred to as asset pricing because an asset's price is directly based on its expected return, which can be inferred from the asset's price

definitionestablishednovelty 0/4durability 4/4· Ben Felix

“An expected return, as it sounds, is the return you expect from investing in a stock or bond. The study of expected returns is often referred to as asset pricing because those two things are directly related. An asset's price is based on its expected return, and its expected return can be inferred from its price.”

0.34

Each of the size and value factors in the Fama-French model is constructed as a long-short portfolio (for example, SMB is long small cap stocks and short big stocks) to capture return variations related to company size and relative price characteristics that had been documented as return anomalies

factualestablishednovelty 0/4durability 4/4· Ben Felix

“Each of these factors is what's called a long short portfolio. SMB, for example, is long small cap stocks and short big stocks. The specific constructions of the factor portfolios have some details that are even too nerdy, I think, for this video, but the main idea is that they're capturing return variations related to company size and relative price, which had been well documented as return anomalies back when this paper was written.”

0.34

Time series regression is a statistical technique that looks at a portfolio's returns over time and quantifies how much of the variation in returns is explained by asset pricing factors, producing factor loadings (coefficients showing how the portfolio moves relative to each factor) and alpha (the portion of returns not explained by the asset pricing model)

definitionestablishednovelty 0/4durability 4/4· Ben Felix

“They used it time series regressions to test how well their asset pricing factors explain the returns of their test portfolios. A time series regression looks at the returns of a portfolio over time and asks how much of the variation in returns is explained by the asset pricing factors being used. Running a time series regression is pretty straightforward with the tools available to investors today. You can do it in Excel or using free online tools like Portfolio Visualizer. The output of a time series regression includes factor loadings or coefficients, which tell you how your portfolio moves relative to each factor, and an alpha, which is the portion of returns that is not explained by the asset pricing model.”

0.32

Dimensional Fund Advisors was historically only available through financial advisors but has recently become available as ETFs that can be purchased directly by investors in the United States, though not yet in Canada

factualestablishednovelty 0/4durability 2/4· Ben Felix

“One catch is that Dimensional used to be only available through financial advisors, though at least in the US, they're now available as ETFs that anybody can buy. Not in Canada, though, unfortunately.”

0.32

Ben Felix's firm, PWL Capital, uses Dimensional Fund Advisors funds extensively and has been using Dimensional products since helping bring them to Canada in 2003, and Felix was not paid by Dimensional or Avantis for mentioning them in the video

factualestablishednovelty 0/4durability 2/4· Ben Felix

“Full disclosure, real quick, my firm uses Dimensional Fund Advisors funds pretty extensively. We are not paid by Dimensional or Avantis, and I was not being paid to mention them in this video.”

0.24

Avantis Investors, a Dimensional competitor, recently launched similar factor investing products, and they have just launched ETFs in Canada through CIBC, with Ben Felix planning to do a deeper dive on these products in another video.

factualestablishednovelty 0/4durability 2/4· Ben Felix

“More recently, Avantis Investors, a Dimensional competitor, launched similar products and they have just launched ETFs in Canada through CIBC. If you want details on that, we did just release a podcast episode with the Avantis CIO. I'll do a deeper dive on these products in another video.”

0.24

The Fama-French 1993 paper forms the foundation for a big part of how Ben Felix thinks about investing, and is one reason the paper comes up frequently in his discussions.

factualspeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 4/4· Ben Felix

“Like I said at the beginning, this seminal paper forms the foundation for a big part of how I think about investing. It's also part of the reason that my firm, PWL Capital, has been using Dimensional Fund Advisors products since we helped bring them to Canada back in 2003.”