is-ought problem
Hume's point that one cannot logically derive a normative 'ought' statement from purely descriptive 'is' statements
As defined in ms_ama_december_2022
Where it comes up · 17
- 115 - Sam Harris Lawrence Krauss And Matt Dillahunty 13 claims
- 342 - Animal Minds Moral Truths2 claims
- 124 - In Search Of Reality2 claims
- Sam Harris and Richard Dawkins in Conversation2 claims
- 22 - Surviving The Cosmos1 claim
- 321 - Reckoning With Parfit1 claim
- Ask Me Anything 91 claim
- A History of Philosophy | 49 Reactions to David Hume1 claim
and 9 more
Most important claims · 10 of 22Search all claims for “is-ought problem” →
- Both morality and science require axioms to get off the ground, but the axioms needed for morality are not a subset of those needed for science: science's possible-worlds method lets us go look and discover what is, whereas the principle that we should avoid maximal suffering for conscious creatures cannot be learned that way—it is an extra value axiom one must choose, and the double standard is asking morality to be self-justifying in a way science never is.124 - In Search Of Reality
- The truth that agony is bad is a self-evident, objective truth analogous to '2+2=4'—a non-natural truth grasped directly—because agony and pleasure are experienced in inherently normative ways (agony presents itself as bad, pleasure as good), differing from a value-neutral fact like 'there is gold in these rocks.'342 - Animal Minds Moral Truths
- The Western assumption that objective moral truth must persuade people to act on it is mistaken; just as one can know how to lose weight yet fail to do so because one wants other things, moral truths are capable of moving rational beings to action and provide reasons for action without necessarily in fact persuading them, since humans are not fully rational beings.342 - Animal Minds Moral Truths
- Modern positivists with justice do not believe that a normative or ethical element can be derived from a purely naturalistic worldview; Comte himself evades the is-ought problem (Hume's famous distinction) by constructing a cult of reason.Comte and the Origins of Sociology
- Moral constructivism can be framed as: it is true that almost all humans have moral inclinations even if specific intuitions are not universal, so we ought to make our inclinations as coherent and consistent as possible; the questioner wonders whether this fully bridges the is-ought gap or whether a formal step is missing.AMA | November 2023
- Although you cannot derive 'ought' from 'is', if oughts exist at all they supervene on the physical state of the universe, and they may turn out like 'vitriol' and 'life' — concepts that were confusing in the 1800s but later acquired an objective handle and better ontology.AMA | September 2025
- Much philosophical confusion about moral objectivity is an inheritance from the Judeo-Christian framing in terms of obligation and 'ought'; if one drops terms like reason, should, and obligation and instead asks what would be true—what states are better or worse in the space of possible experience—objective moral claims become as unproblematic as objective claims in logic or mathematics, regardless of whether anyone is motivated to act on them.321 - Reckoning With Parfit
- Following Hume, you cannot derive an 'ought' from an 'is': by the rules of deductive logic, garbage in/garbage out, values in/values out, facts in/facts out—you cannot derive normative conclusions about what is morally right without including in your premises an assumption or axiom that relates to values; this is a straightforward computational/logical claim that everyone should accept, independent of the separate question of moral realism.124 - In Search Of Reality
- While one cannot logically derive an 'ought' from an 'is,' the question of where oughts come from is legitimate, and there may be near-universals about morality even if moral statements are not derivable from purely factual premises.AMA | July 2025
- Morality is a navigation problem between the worst possible misery and sublime well-being across the continuum of conscious experience; there are right and wrong answers about how properly constituted minds move along that continuum, and these answers draw on all legitimate human knowledge—biochemical, psychological, sociological, economic, and political—making objective (though not absolute) morality possible without divine command.115 - Sam Harris Lawrence Krauss And Matt Dillahunty 1