instrumentalism
The philosophical view that scientific theories are merely useful tools for predicting observations rather than literally true descriptions of reality.
As defined in Ask Me Anything | July 2024
Other definitions
The philosophy of science that views scientific theories not as true descriptions of reality but as useful instruments or tools for prediction, practical application, and further inquiry; science is pragmatic, not metaphysical.
A History of Philosophy | 65 John Dewey
Where it comes up · 8
- A History of Philosophy | 65 John Dewey2 claims
- David Deutsch2 claims
- Jim Manzi on Knowledge, Policy, and Uncontrolled2 claims
- A History of Philosophy | 73 19th Century Empiricism1 claim
- Paul Pfleiderer on the Misuse of Economic Models1 claim
- Lex Fridman Podcast #428 - Sean Carroll1 claim
- AMA | August 20241 claim
- Ask Me Anything | July 20241 claim
Most important claims · 10 of 11Search all claims for “instrumentalism” →
- Friedman's 'as if' argument—that assumptions need not be realistic so long as agents behave as if they were—should not be used to shield chameleon models from criticism of their assumptions when those assumptions have no intersection with the real world.Paul Pfleiderer on the Misuse of Economic Models
- Values are non-moral goods used as instruments for survival; survival itself is non-moral, yet it becomes loaded with value in certain problem situations; ethics concerns how to solve problems and achieve what we desire—it is an instrumentalist ethic.A History of Philosophy | 65 John Dewey
- Operationalism is akin to instrumentalism—the view that science doesn't tell us about the nature of reality but provides useful knowledge for further inquiry and developing practical applications; scientific theories are useful instruments, not accurate representations of reality.A History of Philosophy | 65 John Dewey
- Carroll claimed in a prior AMA that realism is generally more fruitful than instrumentalism, but a listener challenges whether there is significant evidence for this and questions the realist/instrumentalist dualism itself, citing Dennett's 'Real Patterns'.AMA | August 2024
- Most physicists reject the Everett interpretation not for scientific reasons but as a sociological phenomenon stemming from positivism and instrumentalism that contaminated physics around 1900; students were intimidated into believing questions like 'how did the electron get from here to here' are illegitimate, with only a prediction that it got there, which Einstein resisted for relativity but which took hold by the time quantum theory arrived.David Deutsch
- It is questionable whether physicists working on subatomic physics are mainly instrumentalists or realists, with the questioner finding instrumentalism hard to sustain for large objects but plausible for the subatomic realm.Ask Me Anything | July 2024
- The view that scientific theories are simply instruments for practical purposes rather than knowledge about reality in itself is known as 'instrumentalism' and represents the classic anti-realist view of science that develops in both Mill and Mach.A History of Philosophy | 73 19th Century Empiricism
- Francis Bacon laid the philosophical foundations of modern empirical science by shifting from the Aristotelian search for final or ultimate causes ('the why') to thinking of the world as particles plus rules of interaction ('the how'), with the ultimate purpose being not philosophical truth but improved engineering and practical progress.Jim Manzi on Knowledge, Policy, and Uncontrolled
- The purpose of science is not finding truth in the classical philosophical sense (correspondence of statement to reality) but building reliable, nonobvious predictive rules that let us master the physical environment; science treats theories instrumentally as predictive tools discarded when better ones come along, even though working scientists themselves are never instrumentalists.Jim Manzi on Knowledge, Policy, and Uncontrolled
- Understanding the function of the human mind can explain why people hold certain moral beliefs but will never justify those beliefs as right or wrong; science can help you implement and achieve your goals but cannot tell you which goals are right—if your goals are horrible, science is happy to help you achieve them.Lex Fridman Podcast #428 - Sean Carroll