infinite ethics
The branch of ethics dealing with how to value and compare outcomes involving infinite amounts of value, which breaks standard expected-value reasoning.
As defined in William MacAskill
Where it comes up · 3
- Joseph Carlsmith - Utopia, AI, & Infinite Ethics2 claims
- William MacAskill1 claim
- Sam Bankman-Fried - Crypto, Altruism, and Leadership1 claim
Most important claims · 4 of 4Search all claims for “infinite ethics” →
- Infinite ethics is practically relevant, not just theoretical, because we should have non-zero credence that we live in an infinite universe; many common ethical theories break when applied to infinite worlds, and for an expected-value reasoner even a tiny credence in being able to do an infinite thing dominates or breaks the entire expected-value calculation, undermining standard arguments for long-termism.Joseph Carlsmith - Utopia, AI, & Infinite Ethics
- Moral philosophy is a 'train to crazy town': starting from commonsense intuitions, careful theorizing builds simpler, more explanatorily powerful theories that move us away from those intuitions, raising the methodological question of how far we are willing to go; MacAskill gets off the train before accepting Pascalian wagers about infinite value from a possible God.William MacAskill
- A convergent strategy for many unresolved philosophical and empirical problems (including infinite ethics) is to survive long enough for civilization to become much wiser and more empowered, keep your options open, and then act from that position — a framing similar to long-termism but focused on reaching wisdom rather than on directly maximizing the welfare of future people.Joseph Carlsmith - Utopia, AI, & Infinite Ethics
- Because many chains of altruistic reasoning are contingent on our current and possibly mistaken understanding of the universe, EA's tendency to fixate on one specific model is risky; one should weight moderately more toward theories of impact that behave robustly when underlying assumptions are jostled, while still avoiding the hand-wavy 'diffuse good' reasoning that usually masks unrigorous thinking.Sam Bankman-Fried - Crypto, Altruism, and Leadership