in vitro fertilization
A reproductive technology in which eggs are fertilized outside the body; cited as a past technology feared then normalized.
As defined in cwt_atul-gawande
Where it comes up · 6
- 8 | Carl Zimmer on Heredity, DNA, and Editing Genes2 claims
- Scott Atlas on American Health Care1 claim
- 187 - A Conversation With Paul Bloom1 claim
- 14 | Alta Charo on Bioethics and the Law1 claim
- 353 | Alvin Roth on the Economics of Morally Contested Markets1 claim
- 47 | Adam Rutherford on Humans, Animals, and Life in General1 claim
Most important claims · 7 of 7Search all claims for “in vitro fertilization” →
- The idea that an experience can alter how our genes work and pass that alteration to future generations has good evidence in plants and tiny worms and tantalizing mouse experiments (such as odor-shock conditioning seemingly affecting pups via sperm), but the molecular mechanism for transgenerational epigenetic inheritance in mammals is unknown and many scientists doubt it makes sense.8 | Carl Zimmer on Heredity, DNA, and Editing Genes
- CRISPR by itself cannot deliver a science-fiction future of designer babies because it would require everyone to undergo in vitro fertilization, currently a difficult drawn-out process with possibly inherent limits, plus many other advances in reproductive technology and stem cell research before widespread embryo editing could even be possible.8 | Carl Zimmer on Heredity, DNA, and Editing Genes
- In vitro fertilization, recognized with a 2010 Nobel Prize after producing millions of children, is morally contested because multiple embryos are created and not all used; those who regard the embryo as a living person view IVF as a massacre, while others view it as life-giving, so a transaction occurring millions of times draws both intense praise and condemnation.353 | Alvin Roth on the Economics of Morally Contested Markets
- US medical culture applies a full court press to save the weakest infants and is aggressive about in vitro fertilization, which raises multiple-gestation pregnancies (twins, triplets) that carry higher risk of premature birth and infant death, all of which raise measured infant mortality even though they reflect more, not worse, medical effort.Scott Atlas on American Health Care
- Fetal-personhood amendments granting an embryo full legal status from fertilization have failed at the ballot even in highly conservative states with anti-abortion majorities, because such a law would effectively criminalize in vitro fertilization—and there are too many would-be grandmothers whose grandchildren exist only because IVF was available.14 | Alta Charo on Bioethics and the Law
- For deaf parents using IVF to deliberately implant an embryo guaranteed to produce a deaf child when a hearing option is available, the choice seems selfish and less ethical even granting fuller integration into deaf culture—though Bloom is unsure this intuition is strong enough to justify legally forbidding the practice, and notes the case is complicated by genuine disagreement over what counts as flourishing and by empirical questions about cochlear implants.187 - A Conversation With Paul Bloom
- The main drivers of evolution are how many children you have and how young they die; infant mortality has dropped worldwide at roughly the same rate over ~150 years but its geographic distribution is unchanged (still highest in West Africa, lowest in Scandinavia), so selection may operate in high-mortality regions but is not universal, and technologies like IVF (~5 million babies, under a thousandth of the global population) are too small and unevenly distributed to significantly shift human evolution.47 | Adam Rutherford on Humans, Animals, and Life in General