illusion of explanatory depth
The cognitive bias of believing you understand how something works in far more detail than you actually do.
As defined in 255 | Michael Muthukrishna on Developing a Theory of Everyone
Other definitions
Psychological phenomenon where people believe they understand things much better than they actually do, revealed when asked to explain the mechanisms in detail
Adam Grant | Why You Should Rethink A Lot More Than You Do
Where it comes up · 3
- Dan Ariely — Why People Believe Irrational Things | Prof G Conversations3 claims
- 255 | Michael Muthukrishna on Developing a Theory of Everyone2 claims
- Adam Mastroianni on the Brain, the Ears, and How We Learn1 claim
Most important claims · 6 of 6Search all claims for “illusion of explanatory depth” →
- The illusion of explanatory depth means it's easy to feel you know something because you lack any signal that you don't; one trigger is simply knowing a name for something—experiments show people claim to understand an arbitrarily named star better than an unnamed one—so having a word becomes a flawed heuristic that we understand the idea.Adam Mastroianni on the Brain, the Ears, and How We Learn
- Because of our cognitive limitations, humans deferred computation and innovation to the population level by selectively copying successful or prestigious others without fully understanding why—so we hold heads full of recipes we have never checked; we are 'smart because we're dumb,' surpassing other apes precisely because we defer to accumulated cultural information rather than figuring everything out from first principles.255 | Michael Muthukrishna on Developing a Theory of Everyone
- The illusion of explanatory depth is the gap between what people think they understand and what they actually understand; people believe they understand how things work (e.g., a flush toilet) but when asked to explain in detail, they realize they have only superficial understanding.Dan Ariely — Why People Believe Irrational Things | Prof G Conversations
- Asking people detailed questions about their understanding of complex issues (through the illusion of explanatory depth mechanism) is a more effective persuasion strategy than asserting counter-arguments or presenting evidence, because it activates their own recognition of knowledge gaps.Dan Ariely — Why People Believe Irrational Things | Prof G Conversations
- People hold beliefs they cannot actually justify (why brush teeth twice daily, why finish antibiotics) under an 'illusion of explanatory depth' that stops them from probing further—for example, the intuition that finishing antibiotics prevents superbugs is undermined by the observation that incomplete courses would leave the most resistant bacteria—demonstrating that we acquire interfaces to interact with the world rather than true causal models.255 | Michael Muthukrishna on Developing a Theory of Everyone
- Effective dialogue requires moving away from head-to-head argument and instead coming from the other person's side, exploring their perspective while maintaining empathy, and focusing on understanding rather than winning the debate.Dan Ariely — Why People Believe Irrational Things | Prof G Conversations