What this covers

This conversation pairs Shane Parrish with Adam Grant, an organizational psychologist, to work through the ideas in his book Think Again. It starts with why rethinking is hard: people tie their identities to their views, and changing them makes the world feel less predictable and threatens their standing as experts. Grant describes an overconfidence cycle in which pride in what you know feeds confirmation bias. He also gives the example of a physician whose professional identity rests on a single practice, such as lobotomy, and who therefore cannot revise it. From there the talk moves to what superforecasters do, such as pre-committing to the conditions that would change their minds, and to why "how" questions expose gaps in understanding better than "why" questions.

The middle section is about organizations. Grant argues that companies reward outcomes without judging process, when they should normalize good processes that end badly and stop rewarding luck. On hiring, he recommends setting criteria before interviews and using several independent assessors, each judging one dimension. The discussion of psychological safety is the most specific: asking for feedback is not enough, while a leader's open self-criticism raised safety in both natural and randomized settings, though Parrish raises the point that it backfires if it looks staged. Silent memo reading at Amazon comes up as a model of disciplined deliberation.

The last stretch turns to groups and persuasion. Grant covers why people join tribes, drawing on optimal distinctiveness and terror management, and why voters favor certain leaders over humble ones, with Roosevelt's New Deal as a counterexample. On changing minds, he says perspective-seeking beats perspective-taking, that one-sided persuasion can win the battle and lose the war, and that expert negotiators spend more time on common ground. He also argues that breaking binary bias into spectrums, as with ambiverts, reveals nuance. The episode closes with how to help children rethink.

Sharpest takeaway

Grant argues that people should adopt a 'scientist' mindset—treating their beliefs as testable hypotheses rather than fixed truths—to rethink more effectively, both individually and in organizations, by cultivating intellectual humility, seeking evidence, and creating psychological safety.

  • Preaching, prosecuting, and politicking lock beliefs in place; only scientist mode enables genuine rethinking
  • Psychological safety built through leader vulnerability and self-criticism, not just feedback requests, enables team rethinking
  • Process accountability and rigorous decision frameworks (like Amazon's memo-reading practice) outperform intuition-driven decisions

The claims · ranked59 claims · weighted by value

This asset isn't compiled yet

You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.

0.81

When leaders criticize themselves out loud (sharing specific areas for improvement from their own feedback), psychological safety increases in their teams both naturally and in randomized assignments, with effects lasting at least one year, because self-criticism demonstrates the leader can take it and creates mutuality through vulnerability.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 3/4durability 3/4· Adam Grant

“the one we we tried out that worked effectively was instead of just asking for feedback we actually had leaders criticize themselves out loud in some cases managers would bring in their performance review and they'd say to their team hey here's what you know what my boss told me i need to work on and i would love your input on whether i'm making progress in these areas and not only did ceos who did that naturally have higher psychological safety in their top management teams but when we randomly assign managers to kind of criticize themselves as opposed to asking for criticism just inviting them to do that once increased psychological safety in their teams for at least a year which is a staggering effect”

0.80

The effectiveness of a leader's vulnerability depends on whether it is perceived as authentic and consistent behavior rather than as a tactic or performance, because when it appears calculated it backfires and undermines trust.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Shane Parrish

“i think the key word in everything you just said is they did it naturally it wasn't a tactic it was a behavior as part of who they were and when it comes across as a tactic it actually has the opposite impact”

0.79

Organizations reward good outcomes regardless of process quality and punish bad outcomes regardless of process quality, but they should instead celebrate or normalize good processes with bad outcomes (because good processes with bad outcomes represent valuable experiments) and stop rewarding lucky outcomes (good outcomes from bad processes).

normativehigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Adam Grant

“in too many organizations people are basically counted as successful if they get a good result and failed if they get a bad result and the problem is it often takes years to find out what the results were it's very easy for people to persist with a failing project for a long time and convince themselves and everyone else around them that you know that they're on the right path and so what what a lot of the research on this suggests is that we want to shift to process accountability not just outcome accountability”

0.78

Professional identities built on specific practices (like a physician identifying as a lobotomist) are dangerous because they prevent necessary rethinking even when evidence shows the practice is harmful.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Adam Grant

“how how terrible would the world be if some professions had not rethought some of their convictions so imagine for example that you went to a doctor whose identity was to be a professional lobotomist right that would be extremely dangerous and yet there was a time when a lot of physicians define themselves by that method by that set of tools”

0.75

Super forecasters recognize that the only way to have a better shot at being right is to recognize all the places where they are wrong, using practices like pre-commitment to conditions that would change their mind.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Adam Grant

“they they will often come in to making a judgment and say okay the only way to have a better shot at getting right or excuse me the only way to have a better shot at being right is to recognize all the places where i'm wrong yeah and i i love this practice in particular that came from one of the super forecasters in the book jean-pierre begum who when he forms a tentative opinion will actually make a list of the conditions under which he would change his mind”

0.75

Most negative emotions (including regret) are teachable moments—the function of regret is to learn from what you did wrong so you can do it differently moving forward, not to deny or suppress the emotion.

definitionhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Adam Grant

“i think of most negative emotions as teachable moments yeah and the whole point of experiencing them is you're supposed to learn something from what you did wrong so you can make it right in the future and so much of regret is saying okay i did something that uh that led to an undesirable outcome or that violated one of my values and so how do i do this differently moving forward instead of trying to deny these emotions let's let's actually listen to them and figure out what the lesson is”

0.75

Attempting to take someone else's perspective (perspective-taking) often backfires: people invent stories that stray far from truth, especially when the other's perspective is very different. Perspective-seeking (asking questions, interviewing) is more effective than perspective-taking (imagining).

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Adam Grant

“the nick eppley experiments there there are 25 of them showing that on average just encouraging people to take someone else's perspective did not make them more likely to understand the other person and in some cases actually backfired and that's in part because the more the more different somebody else's perspective is from ours the more likely we are to just invent an explanation or a story that strays very far from the truth”

0.75

People are hesitant to rethink because it makes the world feel unpredictable (if views aren't fixed, who are they?) and threatens their sense of expert status and knowledge-based power.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Adam Grant

“i think there are probably multiple reasons for it but i think two of the reasons why people are really hesitant to rethink things are one it makes the world feel much more unpredictable you know if if my views aren't fixed then who am i and how do i navigate a really confusing and often turbulent world and two it makes me feel like i am not an expert right”

0.75

In hiring, the most basic mistake is not establishing criteria before interviewing candidates; experts use multiple independent assessors (3-4), each evaluating a single dimension against predefined criteria rather than making holistic candidate judgments, which reduces confirmation bias.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Adam Grant

“most basic mistake that people make in these kinds of decisions is they don't consider criteria before looking at candidates right so they they interview their three people and they start to compare them as opposed to saying no i should have an independent standard for the skills and values that i'm trying to select on and let's identify those really clearly”

0.75

Seeking feedback alone doesn't durably build psychological safety because managers often become defensive when hearing feedback they dislike, and employees stop speaking up when their feedback goes unaddressed or falls outside the manager's span of control.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Adam Grant

“we found that when we went and encouraged managers to go and ask for feedback it didn't have a lasting effect on psychological safety and it seems like a couple things broke down in our in our follow-up analyses the first one was sometimes leaders and managers would ask for feedback and then they didn't like what they heard and they got defensive which immediately says nope guess the door is closed the second problem was even when they were open to ideas sometimes the feedback was irrelevant or it addressed areas that were outside their span of control and so they said okay this is not a priority for me or i can't do anything about it and that led them to stop asking and it led their employees also to stop giving and to stop speaking up”

0.75

Even when a vision is wrong, there is something intoxicating about following someone who believes they've found the way, because it gives coherence and purpose, reducing uncertainty—we'd often rather be wrong with certainty than right with uncertainty.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Adam Grant

“but there's something very intoxicating about following someone who believes they've already found the way and i think it you know it gives us a sense of coherence it can give us a sense of purpose it's easy to put our trust in people who you know who who have a clear vision uh of course you know in the long run those are the people that i worry most about because they're the ones who are most likely to to get too attached to that vision and stick to it long past its time and i think it removes uncertainty too like it's sort of oh finally i don't have to think about something somebody else has got a clear path forward and therefore even if it's wrong we would almost rather be wrong and certain than uncertain and land in the correct spot”

0.75

'Why' questions invite confirmation bias by prompting people to generate compelling reasons for their existing views; 'how' questions (like 'how would you implement this?' or 'how would you explain that to an expert?') are more effective at revealing gaps in understanding and cultivating intellectual humility.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Adam Grant

“so let's uh let's talk for a second about how versus why questions so a lot of times when you discover that somebody has a different view from you you naturally will say well why do you think that and the problem is you're setting the other person up for confirmation bias you're you're giving them an invitation to make a list of compelling reasons that they themselves generated for why they're going to cling to their pre-existing convictions right so you're doing some of their work for them what works much better are sorry what tend to be more effective are how questions where instead of asking why do you believe this you ask how would you implement this or how would that idea work if we were to come to some agreement on it”

0.75

Breaking down binary categories into spectrums reveals nuance; for example, best leaders are not introverts or extroverts but ambiverts (mid-spectrum), most creative people are not procrastinators at both extremes but moderate procrastinators, and best outcomes usually favor spectrum positions over extremes.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Adam Grant

“if i can see the nuance there and i can start to get people to think about huh where where in this very nuanced spectrum do i fall then i see more shades of grey and less black and white in my beliefs and so what i've been doing a lot now is catching myself in binary bias right like i i'm so glad in retrospect that give and take had three categories rather than two because if there were only givers and takers i would have missed the matchers right the the people trading favors who actually are the most common at work and i think that there are so many this this is i mean this is relevant to any part of life but it's something that runs across almost every project i've done in psychology right um the the best leaders are not the introverts or the extroverts on average they're the ambiverts who fall somewhere in the middle of that spectrum and are comfortable flexing and talking and listening the most creative people are not the procrastinators like me who dive right in or the procrastinators who wait till the last minute they're the people who are quick to start but slow to finish somewhere in the middle of that spectrum”

0.75

Amazon practices silent reading of memos at senior leadership meetings (15-30 minutes) before discussion, ensuring everyone's thinking is carefully focused on options, alternatives, problem framing, and long-term impact, which is rare because most organizations are too busy with distractions.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Adam Grant

“if if you ever go to a senior leadership meeting at amazon you'll see this sort of awkward experience of people sitting silently reading a memo for 15 20 30 minutes and the reason they do that is they want everybody's thinking careful focused attention around what are the options for this big decisions excuse me what are the alternatives around this big decision we have to make and is it is the problem frame the right way what's the long-term impact of this decision and i think that it is so rare for a world of people who are like we all live in a world where we're too busy and we have too many distractions coming our way constantly how unusual is it to sit down with a group of thoughtful people and read and reflect on a common document and then say okay what assumptions should we be rethinking here”

0.75

Identification with a group identity is sufficient to produce the effects (belonging, terror management) even without active contribution or earning the identity—claiming the identity can be enough, though this sometimes creates a form of slacktivism.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Adam Grant

“it turns out identification is enough oh that's really interesting in fact sometimes sometimes the identity doesn't even have to be earned right it has to be claimed uh there's there's some peter goldwitz or work on um on how you know if people can it's a version of slacktivism where if people can claim to be a vegan only the people who they who they eat dinner with will actually know if they're living it or not and so there are situations in which going public with that identity actually prevents people from following through on it privately”

0.74

An overconfidence cycle occurs when pride in what you know leads to confirmation bias and desirability bias, causing you to see what you expect and want to see, which validates your views and makes you less open to rethinking.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Adam Grant

“an overconfident cycle is you know something we've all both committed and uh and witnessed probably too many times but the basic idea is we start by being proud of something that we think we know and that leads us then to feel a lot of conviction that kind of launches us into confirmation bias where we look for information that confirms our expectations as well as desirability bias where we look for information that that basically reinforces what we want to be true and then we see what we expected to see and what we wanted to see and we get validated and that only makes us prouder of what we know and less open to rethinking”

0.74

The theory of 'optimal distinctiveness' (Brewer) explains that people satisfy the conflicting desires to fit in and stand out by joining unique groups—they belong to something, gain identity from clear group boundaries, yet stand out from broader society through the group's differentiation.

definitionhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Adam Grant

“well i think the the idea that comes to mind right away here is the these twin desires that human beings are constantly grappling with we want to fit in we also want to stand out right we want belonging we also want status there's there's a theory that i love marilyn brewer calls it optimal distinctiveness and she says look there's a way to fit in and stand out at the same time it's by joining unique groups because then you are part of something and you're not only part of something you're part of something that has a clear identity because there are very few other groups like it but you also stand out because of the very way that that group has differentiated itself from from others”

0.74

Persuasion research shows that if a conversation is one-sided (one person changes views while the other stays fixed), you might win the battle but lose the war, because the person who changed feels resentful or defensive rather than genuinely converted.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Adam Grant

“if if this is a one-sided exchange and you're supposed to change your mind but i get to stand still we're probably not going to make a whole lot of progress here unless you are a very good prosecutor or the other person is very happy to be preached too which you know i think is all too rare when we get into persuasion challenges you might win the battle but you'll lose the war”

0.69

Expert negotiators spend far more time planning for and discussing common ground than average negotiators, and ask more questions motivated by genuine curiosity rather than leading questions.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Adam Grant

“the experts they spent far more time planning for and then talking about common ground okay that was the first takeaway so a lot of people when they go to have an argument or win a debate they think their their job is basically to find the differences quickly so that then they can they can fix them right that's not at all where i want to start i want to start by saying shane let's identify areas that we agree on which gets us in in synchrony right and also says hey you know what this is somebody who shares some of my values or maybe some of my views and that i think that that makes the conversation non-defensive and collaborative right from the start then a second difference that that jumped out pretty clearly is the experts asked a lot more questions than the average negotiators and they weren't leading questions they were questions motivated by genuine curiosity”

0.69

When claiming a public identity, people generally internalize it and live it more fully, not less—the public commitment increases likelihood of behavioral follow-through, opposite of the slacktivism effect.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Adam Grant

“that being said i think the the general effect in the literature is is the opposite right when when we're known for a particular identity we tend not to only internalize it we're then more likely to start to live it and want to contribute to that creep right because making choices that are a step towards who you who you are”

0.69

Hedging, showing humility, or admitting uncertainty is easily mistaken as ignorance by voters, even though it correlates with actual competence (as Dunning-Kruger shows—confident people are often the least knowledgeable).

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Adam Grant

“if if somebody hedges too much if somebody shows too much humility i think we mistake that as a sign of ignorance right and it's it's the basic trap that you've you've railed against for years shane which is we should stop confusing confidence for competence right just because somebody is is sure of an opinion does not mean they actually know what they're talking about and in fact anybody who's is familiar with the dunning-kruger effect will know that the the more assured people are of their opinions the more hesitant we should be to listen to them right”

0.68

Franklin Delano Roosevelt's New Deal was literally a campaign built on rethinking—trying trial-and-error experiments to learn what works—but it's hard for politicians with that approach to get elected because in times of crisis, voters are drawn to leaders who project certainty.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Adam Grant

“i think i think we have elected that person uh i don't i don't think it happens that often but i think that in the us uh franklin delano roosevelt that was literally his campaign with a new deal right it was it was uh it was a whole campaign to say you know what we're gonna we're gonna run a bunch of trial and error experiments and learn from what works i think it's hard for that person to get elected though because especially as as we face crises and we grapple with uncertainty we're drawn to people who we feel like are going to figure it out and get to fix it”

0.66

Group membership serves terror management function—research shows that belonging to a unique group helps manage threats to mortality and existential concerns by connecting you to something larger and more lasting than yourself.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Adam Grant

“and frankly the other function it serves is existential right one of the one of the most robust findings in psychology over the past three decades is that belonging to a unique group actually serves a terror management function that it helps you avoid threats to your own mortality uh or at least it makes you worry less about uh about what might happen to you in the future and you know whether you have a legacy it connects you to something larger and more lasting than yourself”

0.63

Trust and respect are the two foundations of psychological safety in any relationship (romantic, professional, or otherwise), where psychological safety means knowing that others will treat you with respect and won't punish you for challenging a deep-seated belief.

definitionhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Adam Grant

“the two foundations were really trust and respect and i think a lot of people as amy has pointed out get psychological safety wrong they think it's about being nice to everyone or being tolerant of everything or having no standards or not holding people accountable no it's none of those things psychological safety is knowing that other people are going to treat you with respect and trusting that if you go out on a limb and say something uncomfortable or challenge a deep-seated belief that you are not going to be punished for that”

0.59

People spend an inordinate amount of time thinking and talking like professions they have never held—preaching (proselytizing already-found truth), prosecuting (proving someone else wrong), and politicking (currying favor with a tribe)—rather than thinking like scientists.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Adam Grant

“we spend an inordinate amount of time thinking and talking like professions we have never held right like occupations we were never trained in so think about how much time you spend in your life preaching right you've already found the truth and your job is to proselytize it prosecuting you find somebody who you think is wrong and your job is to prove it and win your your case or come out ahead in the argument and politicking where you think okay i've got a base of people who i'm trying to curry favor with”

0.56

A rethinking cycle begins with intellectual humility (knowing what you don't know), which creates doubt about your convictions, leading to curiosity about gaps in knowledge, openness to discoveries, and recognition that each new learning is a tiny dot in a vast universe of things to learn.

definitionhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Adam Grant

“the rethinking cycle is is very much the opposite it starts for me with intellectual humility which is about knowing what you don't know so you you know no matter how much of an expert you are in a given field or a given topic you have a long list of things that you're clueless about and being aware of what of what your ignorance is leads you to doubt your convictions it makes you curious about what you don't know and that opens your mind to new discoveries and then every time you learn something new it's not this sign that oh now i'm an expert it's this sense that well there's so much more to learn right”

0.55

The reversibility/consequence framework is as relevant to personal decisions as to organizational decisions—having the opportunity to reverse a low-stakes decision requires the mindset that you'll actually use that opportunity.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Adam Grant

“i think this is as relevant to personal decisions as it is to running a company right to say okay before i go into a major decision if it is both irreversible and highly consequential then i want to spend a lot of time rethinking my own views up front whereas if it's pretty easy to reverse and undo or it doesn't really matter i'm going to go forward and make the decision knowing i'll have time later and the opportunity later to second guess it but it's not enough to just sort of convince yourself you have the opportunity you have to be of the mindset that that's sort of almost what you're looking to do”

0.55

When decision variables are not codified and made explicit, teams move the goal posts and explain away anomalies; codifying ranges and triggers in advance gives everyone power to object when evidence contradicts assumptions and enables earlier, less costly course correction.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Shane Parrish

“when we just when we actually when we talked about it and we didn't codify it in a way that everybody could sort of present or use as a reference we move the goal posts all the times it's just human nature right it's like oh well that's easy to explain away that's easy to explain away but when you actually codify it you give everybody in the team power to sort of like talk about it and bring it up and be like oh this doesn't make sense anymore like what's going on here because we never thought this would happen”

0.52

The danger of preaching and prosecuting is that you don't change your mind—you're right and everyone else is wrong—so even if you motivate others to rethink, your own views remain frozen.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Adam Grant

“the danger of preaching and prosecuting is that you don't change your mind right you you're right everyone else is wrong and so you might be very motivated to get other people to rethink but your views are frozen they're set in stone”

0.52

Scientist mode involves treating your views as hypotheses you can test through experiments in your life to determine if they're true or false, making you more mentally flexible and more likely to change your mind at the right times for the right reasons.

definitionhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Adam Grant

“i think we could all get better at thinking more like scientists to say you know what your views they're actually just theories right you could you could kind of make them into hypotheses and then you could run little experiments in your life to figure out whether they're true or false and that should leave you not only more mentally flexible but also more likely to change your mind at the right times for the right reasons”

0.52

Identity should be based on values (what you care about) rather than beliefs (what you think is true), because values remain stable while beliefs should flexibly update with evidence.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Adam Grant

“for me an identity is not about what you believe it's about what you value and so i want to have a set of principles for me my highest values are generosity excellence integrity and freedom and i am completely flexible on the best ways to live those values”

0.52

Jeff Bezos makes hard decisions using two criteria: (1) Is this decision reversible? (2) How consequential is it? He acts quickly on reversible or low-stakes decisions, but delays and procrastinates on irreversible, high-stakes decisions that require careful rethinking.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Adam Grant

“he said okay basically two questions one is is this decision reversible and the other is how consequential is it how high are the stakes and he's willing to act very quickly any time a decision is reversible because he can change his mind tomorrow or low stakes because it doesn't really matter the decisions he puts off until the last possible minute maybe even procrastinates on are the ones that are both irreversible and consequential because those are the ones that are not just gambles they are not just experiments those are real commitments”

0.52

Good advisory work involves introducing new questions rather than giving answers, holding up a mirror so the person can see their problems clearly, which positions them better to solve problems than the advisor could be.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Adam Grant

“what i want to do is i i really want to encourage people to you know to challenge their own thinking right and to consider possibilities they hadn't really thought through or given credence to before and so i feel like as an advisor what i often get to do is say look my job here is not to to tell you what the answer is my job is to introduce you to new questions right and what i want to do is i want to hold up a mirror so that you can see your own problems more clearly and once you do you're in a much better position to solve them than i am”

0.52

Most leaders never think about process accountability separately from outcome accountability, so asking how a decision's process quality could be evaluated independently of results is unusual and powerful for improving decision-making culture.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Adam Grant

“i would be thrilled to see more leaders adopt that practice i think it's brilliant because it doesn't assume people have read it before they come in it gives people time to read it and discuss it one of the things i i noticed when i was sort of running meetings like that is that people would come in and they would have read sort of like the first couple paragraphs because they didn't have time not really their fault in some ways and then they would signal that they've read the document by rephrasing some of those first and everybody would just do the same thing and i'm like you're all just saying the same thing like we can assume this is knowledge but then you can't actually assume that people have read it so i like the approach of sort of like distilling it down to something digestible giving people time to get on the same page allowing the time in the meeting most meetings don't need to be as long as they are anyway”

0.52

Grant's emotional reaction to learning Pluto is no longer a planet (feeling upset about a reclassification that doesn't materially affect reality) reveals how people attach identity to beliefs about stable categories; the object hasn't changed, only the name, yet it threatens their sense of a reliable, knowable world.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Adam Grant

“i like to have a set of beliefs about the world that i can count on and you know when it comes to my understanding of the solar system it's like i have a tower made out of jenga blocks and somebody just pulled out the wrong block and all of a sudden the whole tower's coming crashing down and i want a much more solid and sturdy foundation for the things i believe”

0.52

People signal they've read a document by rephrasing first paragraphs, missing deeper content; the Amazon practice forces actual reading and discussion from a common baseline rather than people faking familiarity.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Shane Parrish

“one of the things i i noticed when i was sort of running meetings like that is that people would come in and they would have read sort of like the first couple paragraphs because they didn't have time not really their fault in some ways and then they would signal that they've read the document by rephrasing some of those first and everybody would just do the same thing and i'm like you're all just saying the same thing like we can assume this is knowledge but then you can't actually assume that people have read it so i like the approach of sort of like distilling it down to something digestible giving people time to get on the same page allowing the time in the meeting most meetings don't need to be as long as they are anyway”

0.52

Grant decided that when someone claims to know something they don't or dismisses evidence, the scientific response is to get curious ('huh, I wonder what evidence would change your mind?') rather than to attack or prosecute, and this curiosity completely changes the tone of the conversation.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Adam Grant

“and so i wrote a little script for how i want to respond whenever somebody challenges my evidence or claims to know something that i think is false which is just to get really curious and say huh well i wonder what what evidence would change your mind and i don't always remember to ask the question i don't always get curious enough to really want to know but in the situations where i've pulled it off it has completely changed the tone of the conversation”

0.52

Disagreement is better framed as a dance (both parties moving, neither choreographed in advance, trying to get in sync) rather than a war (where your job is to win battles); good debate involves both parties stepping forward and backward, not one side winning.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Adam Grant

“one of the more interesting things that psychologists have done when when looking at you know disagreement and debate is to say you know what if we used a different metaphor what if we thought about it as a dance and i'm the worst person to use this metaphor because i cannot dance to save my life my wife actually signed us up for dancing lettings excuse me my wife signed us up for dancing lessons before our wedding and she quit after the second one it was so bad she she just decided it was hopeless”

0.52

When you realize your pitch isn't getting through to someone, mid-conversation interrupting yourself to ask 'If you were going to give this pitch to someone else, how would you approach it differently?' invites them to help you rethink your approach and positions you as learning rather than winning.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Adam Grant

“i've actually done this now a couple times in mid-conversation i've just interrupted myself and said you know what shane i can tell that the case i'm making right now is just not getting through to you you are not buying this even at all and i don't want to make this mistake again so if i go and give this pitch to somebody else how would you approach it differently and maybe that puts me in a better position to reason with you a different day or with a different person the hope is i learned something from that conversation and and now we're arguing to learn as opposed to arguing to win”

0.52

Grant and his family have 'myth-busting' dinner conversations where children share surprising facts that contradict what they previously learned, reinforcing the idea that discovering you were wrong is delightful because it means you've learned something.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Adam Grant

“a variation on that that we do occasionally at dinner is allison and i with our kids will have a myth busting discussion and i think originally it came about because our our kids had learned interesting things at school that surprised us like one day um one of our daughters came home and said uh we were we were just doing an egypt unit this was in elementary school and i found out that king tut probably did not die in a chariot accident i was like oh that's so cool that's not what i learned what else are you learning in school that is different from what we thought was true at the time and so it became sort of an occasional tradition for us to to say okay who's going to bring a myth or a fun surprising fact to the table and what i want to do in these whenever we have these conversations is i want our kids to to experience the joy of being wrong to say it is such a delight to discover that something you thought was true was actually false because now you know you've learned something”

0.52

Daniel Kahneman, after a talk Grant gave, said 'That was wonderful. I was wrong' and explained that being wrong is exhilarating because it's the only way he knows he's learned something—detaching your ideas from your identity enables genuine discovery.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Adam Grant

“he he said something like that was wonderful i was wrong and those two things don't normally go hand in hand right either a talk was wonderful because you were right or it was bad because you were wrong and i i just i couldn't let go of it my first reaction was to say holy cow danny kahneman liked something i said my second reaction was to say this is so strange that he thought it was wonderful to have been wrong what's behind this and so i ended up following up with him and i asked him you know why i could literally his face lit up when he talked about how exhilarating it was to be wrong and he said it's the only way i know i've learned something right if i find out i was wrong it means i am now less wrong than i was before”

0.52

Grant often sells his recommendations too early or hasn't tailored them enough to the person's context; he's learned to first understand why someone came (for advice, validation, or challenge) before offering recommendations.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Adam Grant

“even when i think i i have a pretty strong recommendation i often either sell it too early uh or i haven't tailored it enough to the world that the person is in and so uh what i've what i've tried to shift to over the years it's frankly the same thing that i've tried to do in office hours is to say all right shane tell me what you know why you're here why did you call me i'm happy to share with you whatever i know on this topic and then what i would love to hear from you is what do you want to do with that information”

0.52

A middle school teacher (Erin McCarthy) sends students to rewrite history textbook sections using primary sources and interviews, causing them to recognize how much information is missing from traditional narratives and learn to think critically when encountering new information.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Adam Grant

“what erin does with her students is she gives them a section of a history textbook and she sends them out to rewrite it and what they do is they you know they look at primary sources they interview people and they realize how much information is missing from the way that we've narrated past events and what that does is it allows them to think a little bit more when they encounter new information like fact checkers right whereas where instead of you know i read something in you know in the news or i heard it on tv it must be true to say well what are the sources of that information and how do we really know”

0.52

The main reason structured hiring is uncommon is the 'gospel of intuition'—managers fear that formalizing and delegating their judgment to an algorithmic process threatens their job and abandons the superior intuition they've built their career on.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Adam Grant

“i think it's less about the time and more about the gospel of intuition i think that too many too many hiring managers are afraid that if they essentially delegate i mean this is a more algorithmic it's a more algorithmic approach to decision making right if i if i delegate my knowledge and my experience uh to what feels more like a formula then maybe i'm out of a job and maybe also you know my my superior intuition my gut feeling about a candidate is going to get ignored”

0.52

In high-stakes, irreversible decisions, pre-meeting reading may be valuable, followed by post-meeting reflection time to allow second thoughts to surface, allowing people who think slower to contribute their deeper insights.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Shane Parrish

“there is a part of me that wonders whether especially again for a high-stakes irreversible decision do you want to send that out in advance encourage people to read it at least the first or second time and then really digest it again when you come together because i i'm not sure this goes back to that second thoughts post that you roast you wrote i'm not sure that our second thoughts are always our most insightful observations right they're usually the easiest ones to think of and i worry a little bit that in the moment sometimes people will will react based on their initial intuition as opposed to there's a i guess there's a a twist on danny kahneman's work here that that seems relevant which is i worry a lot that we spend too much time listening to people who think fast and shallow and not enough time hearing people who think slow and deep and i think we want to become the people who think slow and deep”

0.52

Sports organizations and special forces invest heavily in recruiting and assessment, yet outcomes remain highly variable ('hit or miss'), likely because they measure only 7-8 attributes when 200 might predict performance, measures are noisy for intangible factors like grit and generosity, and weighing attributes varies by individual context.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Adam Grant

“i think i think it's it's hit or miss for a few reasons one is that we we don't have all the criteria that we need so you know most i i've worked with a whole bunch of professional sports teams over the past few years on this exact problem and they're at best assessing on you know maybe seven or eight attributes when there might be 200 that are going to drive people's future performance right so i think that's that's the first problem the second problem is the measures are extremely noisy so it's one thing to say okay you know if i'm trying to hire a if i want to draft somebody to play for the toronto raptors right i can i can figure out how tall they are i can figure out how high they can jump but when it comes to you know quickness and diving for a loose ball i can't measure that as precisely as i would like and then i'm also trying to come up with a score for grit and generosity and humility good luck with that right they're they're very very intangible factors to measure”

0.52

Grant was called a 'logic bully' by a student (Jamie) when he overwhelmed her with rational arguments about why an MBA might be wasteful, depriving her of the opportunity to reason through the decision for herself despite his good intentions.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Adam Grant

“she came back and she said you're a logic bully i was like oh what and she said a logic bully and she went on to tell me that i had overwhelmed her with rational arguments and she didn't agree but she couldn't fight back and my first reaction shane was yes because i thought that was my job as a social scientist right i want to come with airtight logic and rigorous data and make the most compelling case i can to just it i guess at some level i was trying to destroy what i thought was shallow thinking but what i was depriving her of was the opportunity to own her own choice right”

0.52

A consulting relationship often involves clients deciding in advance what they want and hiring consultants to affirm that decision, while an advisory relationship involves genuine rethinking and challenging assumptions.

definitionhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Adam Grant

“companies don't rethink anything it's people there that rethink things and traditionally consulting hasn't been about rethinking it's about affirming something we already want to do and putting putting the the shoulder of that externally somehow yeah and this is why i'm a terrible consultant and why i hate consulting right i i i've discovered over the past couple years that i would much rather be an advisor than a consultant because i think as as a consultant to your point too often people have already decided on a decision or a plan or leaders want to convince their board of directors that you know that they brought in an outsider to you know to explore alternatives and then having done lip service to whatever the issue was they basically say all right we checked the box now our work here is done”

0.51

Politicking involves flexibility, but it causes you to change your mind at the wrong times and for the wrong reasons—to appease your tribe rather than to find the truth.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Adam Grant

“politicking is interesting because when we're being political we're actually more flexible right we might even flip-flop but we're doing it at the wrong times and we're doing it for the wrong reasons because we're just doing it to appease our tribe as opposed to doing it to find the truth”

0.48

Grant forms independent opinions based on evidence rather than adopting party affiliation, because identifying as a republican, democrat, liberal, or conservative means outsourcing your thinking to a group of people he doesn't believe are thinking scientifically.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Adam Grant

“when you know when people ask me what my politics are uh i think for myself i try to form independent opinions based on the information that i encounter and the idea of identifying myself as a republican or a democrat or a liberal or conservative that's ridiculous to me because it means i've outsourced my thinking to some group of people that i don't think are thinking very scientifically”

0.48

When someone says 'I'm entitled to my opinion,' the appropriate response is that while they are entitled to hold an opinion, if they voice it, they have a responsibility to be open to changing it in light of better logic or stronger data.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Adam Grant

“i think you are absolutely entitled excuse me yeah you're entitled to your own opinion if you keep your opinion to yourself if you decide to say it out loud then i think you have a responsibility to be open to changing your mind in the face of better logic or stronger data and so i think if you're willing to voice an opinion you should also be willing to change that opinion”

0.48

Farnum Street's mission is 'mastering the best of what other people have figured out,' which means there is no identity investment in original thinking, allowing continuous updating of views without ego threat.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Shane Parrish

“farnum street i mean we we sort of thought about this from the get-go and the tagline is mastering the best of what other people have figured out so then there's no sense of identity like we don't uh i don't come up with anything i just try to like talk to smart people like you all day and i'm like oh that makes sense like i think that'll work and the ultimate utility is sort of or the the ultimate test of whether a theory works is not only does it predict the past but it predicts the future right”

0.48

Rethinking is code for learning; the challenge is that we don't update our views very often on our own or others' views, and we need to shift from roughly 50/50 (sometimes open to updating) to 70% openness to updating our views.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — Adam Grant | Why You Should Rethink A Lot More Than You Do [ctkWiO6VcsE]

“rethinking is it's code for learning isn't it well it is but we don't update our views very often that's that's part of the issue our own and others right it's hard to see it when we don't do it it's really easy to see when others don't do it but we're maybe we're 50 50. right like how do we nudge that forward so it's like 70 of the time we're open to updating our”

0.48

Bezos said that people who don't change their minds are wrong, implying that changing your mind frequently is necessary for being right.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Shane Parrish

“bezos had something along these lines too right where he's like people who don't don't change their mind are wrong so if you want to be right you have to be somebody who changes your mind a lot”

0.48

Companies called Grant because they wanted help rethinking, but when he presented evidence contrary to their existing plans, they responded with 'That won't work here' or 'That's not how we've always done things,' making him realize they were closed to the evidence he brought.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Adam Grant

“i really started thinking deliberately about it when i just had experience after experience of going into a new organization and you know usually i'd either give a keynote speech or the ceo or founder would reach out for some advising and i'd start to walk through the evidence on whatever their question was and more often than not i'd get answers like well that won't work around here or that's not how we've always done things and at some point i just started saying hmm blackberry blockbuster kodak sears should i keep going”

0.48

Grant once presented 26 evidence-based recommendations to investment banking leaders for improving motivation and retention, but when a co-head dismissed his findings and suggested just paying people more (which had already failed), Grant responded by calling them 'a group of smart people acting so dumb,' which was ineffective persuasion and revealed him operating in prosecutor/playground bully mode rather than scientist mode.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Adam Grant

“i was presenting them i think it was actually my first ever video conference that i'd done this was at least seven maybe eight years ago um and i'm presenting to the co-heads of investment banking they're on multiple continents and i think i was on about recommendation five or six and one of the co-heads interrupts me and he says well why don't we just pay them more and if there is one recommendation that was not on my list of 26 it was to solve the problem with money because they had already thrown a lot of money at the problem these people were already well paid by which i mean overpaid and if money were going to attract them and retain them it already would have and i'm embarrassed to say that my response at the time was i've never seen a group of smart people act so dumb”

0.47

'Binary bias' describes the tendency to see complex issues (like policy disagreements) as having only two sides; in reality, most politically contentious issues have many positions on a spectrum, and most people disagree with their own party on multiple major issues.

definitionhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Adam Grant

“one of the things i just never thought about before was binary bias so i knew i wanted to write a chapter about having charged conversations and how people could talk about the most divisive issues that many of us have just been shying away from because it feels hopeless and i really came out rethinking my view that what we need to do is is better understand the other side which has been so much the political narrative i think actually that's part of the problem not the solution because there is no charged issue that's ever simple enough to have only two sides right and the research by peter coleman and his colleagues on this really opened my eyes to the fact that what we want to do is we want to complexify what seems like a spectrum sorry we want to complexify two categories into a spectrum right anytime there's a binary anytime there's a liberal versus conservative or um you know well let me yeah i'll just use that as an example anytime you run into a binary like you know liberals and conservatives you should picture a whole spectrum of beliefs there and say well you know they're relatively conservative and relatively liberal members of each of those groups and if you break down the multiple issues very few people agree with their party on all 16 or 17 of the major issues equally”

0.45

Challenging someone else's knowledge in public backfires through retaliation and defensiveness; these conversations are best done privately where the person doesn't feel humiliated.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Shane Parrish

“i think often those conversations where you're challenging other people's knowledge and you have a hint that it might not be there are usually best done in private and not in public for those people listening i think that'll backfire if you you sort of like oh i'm going to make this person look like an idiot in front of everybody else that just causes retaliation tit for tat you go nowhere it doesn't help people it just sort of cements them”

0.44

Young people (21 year-olds) and older people (61 year-olds) grapple with the same exact problem of resisting rethinking their views about career and life choices, suggesting there is something fundamentally important about this resistance to explore.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Adam Grant

“and i got the same resistance and any time i see a 21 year old and a 61 year old grapple with the same exact problem i think there's something really important and interesting to explore”