hormone replacement therapy
Treatment giving menopausal women hormones, promoted in the 1990s to prevent osteoporosis and heart disease.
As defined in Robert Aronowitz on Risky Medicine
Where it comes up · 2
- What Modern Medicine Gets Wrong (with Marty Makary)5 claims
- Robert Aronowitz on Risky Medicine1 claim
Most important claims · 6 of 6Search all claims for “hormone replacement therapy” →
- In the 1990s, advisory panels urged hormone replacement therapy for menopausal women (to prevent osteoporosis and heart disease, not for symptoms), based on observational trials flawed by a 'healthy-woman effect' and heavy marketing; the randomized Women's Health Initiative then showed incontrovertibly that, given as preventatives, these therapies did more harm than good—a rare case of a clear right answer emerging from a clinical trial.Robert Aronowitz on Risky Medicine
- Twenty-two years ago an NIH doctor held a press conference announcing hormone replacement therapy causes breast cancer, scaring tens of millions of women into stopping it, but the published data from this nearly billion-dollar study (the largest taxpayer-funded study in US history) showed no statistically significant increase in breast cancer versus placebo, meaning the data were misrepresented.What Modern Medicine Gets Wrong (with Marty Makary)
- Women who start estrogen or estrogen-plus-progesterone within 10 years of menopause live on average three and a half years longer, have half the rate of fatal heart attacks, 50-60% less cognitive decline, a 35% reduced risk of Alzheimer's, and are half as likely to break a bone in a fall—benefits Makary calls overwhelming and arguably second only to antibiotics among population health interventions.What Modern Medicine Gets Wrong (with Marty Makary)
- When medicine uses good scientific evidence and basic methodology it makes excellent public recommendations, but when it 'wings it' by issuing recommendations with absolutism in the absence of evidence, it has a terrible track record—as shown by being wrong on peanut allergies for 15 years, hormone replacement therapy for 22 years, opioid addictiveness for 30 years, and the low-fat diet for 60 years.What Modern Medicine Gets Wrong (with Marty Makary)
- An entire generation of women was denied HRT, and a second generation is now being denied because 80% to 90% of physicians still believe the dogma that it causes breast cancer—not because they are bad people but because, as one doctor told Makary, it was pounded into them in training.What Modern Medicine Gets Wrong (with Marty Makary)
- The cardiac risk people cite for HRT only appears when estrogen is started more than 10 years after menopause; because estrogen oxidizes and raises nitric oxide that keeps blood vessels dilated and soft, going years without estrogen lets vessels narrow and harden, so HRT cannot be safely started after that hardening sets in—which is why it should begin within 10 years of menopause onset.What Modern Medicine Gets Wrong (with Marty Makary)