high modernism
James Scott's term for the ideology of hierarchical, centralizing institutions of the 18th-19th centuries that sought to impose rational, legible order on society from the top down.
As defined in 148 | Henry Farrell on Democracy as a Problem-Solving Mechanism
Where it comes up · 2
- 148 | Henry Farrell on Democracy as a Problem-Solving Mechanism2 claims
- How neoliberalism broke economics | Dr Abby Innes2 claims
Most important claims · 4 of 4Search all claims for “high modernism” →
- Per James Scott's high modernism, hierarchical institutions of the 18th-19th centuries sought to make the world legible (e.g., Haussmann's redesign of Paris into grand boulevards) so populations could be organized, schooled, and policed; this legibility involves huge losses of tacit knowledge by re-segmenting the world to fit the state's own categories.148 | Henry Farrell on Democracy as a Problem-Solving Mechanism
- Hierarchy's principal virtue is that it can get big complex problems solved: it provides a way to take a decision, communicate it to the actors implementing the solution, and ensure they implement it coherently without undercutting each other; its weakness is inflexibility and top-down loss of information, but its benefits include essential services like sewage and disease control that require central organization.148 | Henry Farrell on Democracy as a Problem-Solving Mechanism
- Soviet totalitarianism and British liberal democracy are politically opposite, but both are 'misadventures in high modernism' — late-19th/early-20th-century projects seeking methodologies to transcend the uncertainties of the social world and obtain definitive answers, and Britain has imposed a totalizing economic science on itself without physical coercion or revolution.How neoliberalism broke economics | Dr Abby Innes
- Both Soviet and neoclassical systems are misadventures in high modernism—shared late-19th and early-20th-century aspirations to transcend the vicissitudes and uncertainties of the social world through scientific methodology.How neoliberalism broke economics | Dr Abby Innes