hidden half
Blastland's term for the large reservoir of irregular, chance, and unexplainable factors—beyond genetics and environment—that disrupt our ability to predict and explain outcomes.
As defined in Michael Blastland on the Hidden Half
Where it comes up · 1
Most important claims · 6 of 6Search all claims for “hidden half” →
- The marmorkrebs (a parthenogenetic, genetically identical clone crayfish) raised in deliberately standardized identical environments still develop with astonishing variation—weights differing by 20x, different shell markings, different behaviors, and lifespans varying by a factor of three—demonstrating a third cause of variation beyond genetics and environment.Michael Blastland on the Hidden Half
- In an ordinary (non-BRCA) case of breast cancer in one breast, the probability of cancer in the other breast is barely raised above the population norm, such that the other breast is more like the breast of a stranger than its own twin—showing irreducible difference emerges even within a single person where genetics, diet, and lifetime exposures are identical.Michael Blastland on the Hidden Half
- One can firmly believe smoking causes cancer at the population scale—a smoking country shows far more lung cancer than a non-smoking country—while acknowledging that within a country where everyone smokes equally, smoking is not predictive of who gets cancer at all; causation and luck operate in tandem at different scales, so a phenomenon can be both determined and a matter of luck.Michael Blastland on the Hidden Half
- Mike Tyson and his brother shared the same violent upbringing yet one became a violent criminal and the other a trauma nurse who patches up victims of violence, demonstrating that even the most extreme causal influence can take people in diametrically opposed directions, which destroys our ability to define causal pathways at the individual level.Michael Blastland on the Hidden Half
- Knowledge is fundamentally a kind of regularity: we learn something from one experience and predict it will work again, so knowledge is the way information about something travels to the next instance, and it does not travel as reliably as we hope because of a 'hidden half' of countervailing factors.Michael Blastland on the Hidden Half
- For people, roughly half of how things turn out is accounted for by factors that cannot be defined in normal terms—meaning this third 'hidden half' cause is the equal of genetics and environment put together, yet it receives almost no scientific recognition or argument.Michael Blastland on the Hidden Half