causal

Smoking Causes Cancer Yet Is Not Individually Predictive

One can firmly believe smoking causes cancer at the population scale—a smoking country shows far more lung cancer than a non-smoking country—while acknowledging that within a country where everyone smokes equally, smoking is not predictive of who gets cancer at all; causation and luck operate in tandem at different scales, so a phenomenon can be both determined and a matter of luck.

causalpending

Speaker

Michael Blastland

Evidence Quote

“you can have regular, clear knowledge at the probabilistic scale ... and you can have complete confusion at the individual level.”

Source

Michael Blastland on the Hidden Half— EconTalk
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:24:29 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...