hard determinism
The view that determinism is true (or true enough) and therefore deprives us of free will, with no compatibilist reconciliation available.
As defined in 125 | David Haig on the Evolution of Meaning from Darwin to Derrida
Where it comes up · 3
- 125 | David Haig on the Evolution of Meaning from Darwin to Derrida2 claims
- AMA | April 20241 claim
- AMA | May 20211 claim
Most important claims · 4 of 4Search all claims for “hard determinism” →
- Whether you are a compatibilist or incompatibilist about free will has nothing to do with whether the laws of physics are deterministic; what matters is only that there are laws. Calling oneself a 'hard determinist' is a mistake because one would remain anti-free-will under indeterministic laws like spontaneous collapse theories; the real distinction is whether describing humans as choice-making agents is compatible with their being made of law-obeying particles.AMA | May 2021
- The institution of free will is a concept extremely useful for maintaining social control in areas of life crucial to civilization, cooperation, and personal safety—for example, it would be hard to keep people in jail without believing in free will—but its usefulness does not make it true.125 | David Haig on the Evolution of Meaning from Darwin to Derrida
- Free will does not exist; hard determinism is true or true enough to deprive us of it, and there is no way to reconcile determinism with a watered-down compatibilist conception of free will as Hume and others have tried; our subjective experience of free will merely deceives us.125 | David Haig on the Evolution of Meaning from Darwin to Derrida
- Compatibilism holds that even if the universe is fundamentally deterministic at the level of physics, the concept of free will remains meaningful and useful when describing human beings at the macroscopic, agent-level of description—free will is not an illusion to be discarded but a legitimate way of talking about systems that make choices, whereas hard determinism treats determinism as flatly incompatible with free will.AMA | April 2024