definition

Compatibilism does not depend on determinism

Whether you are a compatibilist or incompatibilist about free will has nothing to do with whether the laws of physics are deterministic; what matters is only that there are laws. Calling oneself a 'hard determinist' is a mistake because one would remain anti-free-will under indeterministic laws like spontaneous collapse theories; the real distinction is whether describing humans as choice-making agents is compatible with their being made of law-obeying particles.

definitionpending

Speaker

Sean Carroll

Evidence Quote

“Whether those laws are deterministic or not makes zero difference to whether you're a compatibilist or an in compatibilist... so don't label yourself a hard determinist, that is not the point. You would still be anti-free will if you're an incompatibilist, even if... determinism is not there. It's the fact that there are laws that matters.”

Source

AMA | May 2021— Sean Carroll's Mindscape
Created: 6/13/2026, 3:36:54 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...