first strike
A preemptive attack launched to gain decisive advantage before an opponent can act or before a power shift erodes one's relative strength.
As defined in Chris Blattman
Other definitions
An initial nuclear attack launched before the adversary can act.
465 - More From Sam Iran Jihadism Conspiracism Ai Disruption The Manosphere And More
Where it comes up · 13
- 210 - The Logic Of Doomsday2 claims
- 186 - The Bomb2 claims
- 330 - The Doomsday Machine2 claims
- Chris Blattman1 claim
- Fin Moorhouse - Longtermism, Space, & Entrepreneurship1 claim
- 442 - More From Sam Public Speaking Nuclear War Christian Nationalism1 claim
- 276 - Defending The Global Order1 claim
- Ep. 75 - Tired Of Being Should Upon1 claim
and 5 more
Most important claims · 10 of 16Search all claims for “first strike” →
- Mutually assured destruction rests on the psychologically questionable premise that a leader, upon learning his country has been annihilated, would in his last 30 minutes choose to become history's second-greatest mass murderer by killing 140 million people; the deterrent only holds because no adversary will gamble that the leader wouldn't retaliate, but unilaterally renouncing retaliation would be tantamount to disarming and could itself be provocative.276 - Defending The Global Order
- During the Cold War both superpowers recognized mutually assured destruction but continually tried to escape it through first-strike theories and other means; it held largely because neither side could technologically escape it, not because either side preferred being subject to it.Rise And Fall Of Nations How Superintelligence Will Transform Geopolitics Gregory Smith
- In 1983 a Soviet officer (Stanislav Petrov) received faulty radar data appearing to show a US first strike of about five ICBMs, but reasoned that a real first strike would launch a hundred missiles rather than five, and declined to pass the data up the chain, likely preventing a retaliatory nuclear response.330 - The Doomsday Machine
- Land-based ICBMs are by definition first-strike weapons because their known, fixed locations make them targetable; in a warning scenario the president must choose within five to ten minutes between launching them (risking starting an accidental war from a false alarm) or losing them, so deterrence forces should be shifted to submarines and aircraft and the ICBM force phased out before it precipitates an accidental war.210 - The Logic Of Doomsday
- Mutually assured destruction is morally senseless—launching upon being launched upon kills hundreds of millions for no purpose—yet it has plausibly prevented nuclear and conventional world wars precisely because all nuclear-armed parties don't want to die; this entire logic collapses once a party sincerely wants to die, as jihadists do.465 - More From Sam Iran Jihadism Conspiracism Ai Disruption The Manosphere And More
- The policy of launching a genocidal retaliatory strike in response to a perceived first strike—to get missiles out of silos before they are destroyed—accomplishes nothing strategically: it protects no one on one's own side while killing 100-200 million people on the other, yet US policy imagines a president would choose this in their final minutes.330 - The Doomsday Machine
- Space governance—the rules and institutions governing settlement, resource use, and conflict beyond Earth—is an underexplored area whose design now could have outsized and durable consequences, including risks of a space race dynamic and first-strike instability.Fin Moorhouse - Longtermism, Space, & Entrepreneurship
- Moving from a first-strike to a second-strike-only policy would be progress and remove one path to accidental war, but it would not remove the danger, because a president acting on false warning of an incoming attack could launch a 'retaliatory' strike that becomes the real first strike, triggering genuine retaliation and ending human history.210 - The Logic Of Doomsday
- Mutually assured destruction relies on the bluff that a country will retaliate, but once a first strike is inbound and your own annihilation is certain, retaliating only kills hundreds of millions of people for no purpose, so no sane person would actually do it; thus the deterrent threat is not genuinely credible.442 - More From Sam Public Speaking Nuclear War Christian Nationalism
- The Peloponnesian War illustrates the bargaining commitment problem: massive power shifts can lead to war because it becomes difficult for the temporarily powerful party to credibly be paid off not to exercise its advantage through a first strike to eliminate the rising rival.Chris Blattman