false positive
A test result indicating disease when none is present, leading to unnecessary further procedures
As defined in et_361
Other definitions
A test result that signals disease when none is present, which can trigger unnecessary follow-up procedures and anxiety.
Alex Karnal - The Trillion-Dollar Health Revolution - [Invest Like the Best, EP.468]
Where it comes up · 20
- Is Most Published Research Wrong?9 claims
- Adam Cifu on the Case for Being a Medical Conservative4 claims
- Designing Better Decisions3 claims
- John Ioannidis on Statistical Significance, Economics, and Replication3 claims
- Novocure: Using Physics to Fight Cancer2 claims
- Investing in Healthcare2 claims
- Robert Aronowitz on Risky Medicine2 claims
- Gerd Gigerenzer on How to Stay Smart in a Smart World2 claims
and 12 more
Most important claims · 10 of 39Search all claims for “false positive” →
- Even without conscious fraud, researchers make many analysis decisions (which participants to exclude, which covariates to include) and are subtly influenced to choose those that make results look better; these unconstrained choices leverage chance to produce favorable results, which is why a constrained replication using the same fixed choices often fails to reproduce the original effect.Brian Nosek on Truth, Science, and Academic Incentives
- If 300 million Americans were screened with a liquid biopsy at 99% specificity, about one in every 100 healthy people would get a false positive, roughly 3 million people, who would then face unnecessary biopsies, CT scans, or surgery.Investing in Healthcare
- Each additional screening dimension carries a material false-positive rate, so the odds of a disruptive false alarm rise with every test, and imaging data is only valuable when placed in the right clinical context.Alex Karnal - The Trillion-Dollar Health Revolution - [Invest Like the Best, EP.468]
- Roughly 450 to 1000 studies in the 1990s and beyond confirmed a link between the gene SLC6A4 and depression, but a recent study found no medical basis for the connection, suggesting that a large body of studies that passed all standard tests was meaningless—a major wake-up call about scientific reliability.Adam Cifu on the Case for Being a Medical Conservative
- Researchers can make many decisions about data analysis that decrease p-values, including: analyzing data, finding it nearly significant, collecting more data points until p<0.05 is achieved, then stopping. Numerical simulations show this produces false positives where relationships cross the significance threshold through additional data even though larger samples would show no true relationship.Is Most Published Research Wrong?
- Because a single study of a new intervention cannot tell us whether a positive result is real or a false positive arising from a few patients in a large population responding differently, the conservative approach is to slow down and not accept any therapy until the result is replicated across multiple populations with subtly different study designs.Adam Cifu on the Case for Being a Medical Conservative
- In a realistic scenario with 1000 hypotheses being tested (10% true, 90% false), with 80% statistical power to detect true effects and using p<0.05 threshold, approximately 80 true positive results and 45 false positive results will be published, meaning nearly one-third (approximately 36%) of published results will be false even though the statistical system is working normally.Is Most Published Research Wrong?
- Operating in an underpowered environment creates two problems simultaneously: a very high chance of false negatives (missing real signals), and a high risk that any statistically significant result is a false positive or a grossly inflated effect size—the smaller the power, the greater the average inflation of detected effects.John Ioannidis on Statistical Significance, Economics, and Replication
- Whether a significant small-sample result is a complete false positive or merely an exaggerated true effect depends on the field's prior probability of real effects: in fields with strong theory and prior evidence you tend to get inflated-but-real effects, whereas in agnostic, high-noise fields searching in the dark, almost any significant result is a false positive.John Ioannidis on Statistical Significance, Economics, and Replication
- Empirical survey data show that people who lived for weeks or months falsely believing they had cancer, then learned they did not, generally become MORE pro-screening and pro-intervention rather than skeptical—apparently because the experience of brushing against death and gaining 'mastery' over it, even falsely, takes on a positive, life-enhancing meaning.Robert Aronowitz on Risky Medicine