extractive institutions
Institutions designed to extract resources or labor from a population for the benefit of a narrow elite or colonial power, rather than to promote broad-based development
As defined in Melissa Dell
Where it comes up · 7
- Daron Acemoglu on Why Nations Fail5 claims
- Daron Acemoglu4 claims
- Conversations with Tyler - Jared Diamond1 claim
- Melissa Dell1 claim
- Peter Boettke on Living Economics1 claim
- 283 | Daron Acemoglu on Technology, Inequality, and Power1 claim
- 287 | Jean-Paul Faguet on Institutions and the Legacy of History1 claim
Most important claims · 10 of 14Search all claims for “extractive institutions” →
- The Jamestown colony's governors initially had the identical model of colonization as Cortez and Pizarro—subjugating local populations for food and gold—but could not because there were no dense populations to subjugate and no gold to grab; only after coercion and indentured servitude failed in the open frontier did they extend economic and then political incentives, launching the divergent path that became the United States.Daron Acemoglu on Why Nations Fail
- The Ignorance Hypothesis is wrong: leaders making the most consequential economic-development choices do not get them wrong by mistake but by design—like Mugabe's 100,000% inflation and land grabs—because they are clinging to power or enriching a narrow group at the expense of society, not pursuing national prosperity.Daron Acemoglu on Why Nations Fail
- About 120 countries' current institutions are heavily shaped by their colonial experience; settler colonies (US, Australia, Canada) developed good institutions because settlers fought for them, while densely populated tropical areas with high European mortality led to extractive institutions, and this difference explains most of the income gap between places like the US/Argentina/Chile and Peru/Bolivia/India/Pakistan.Daron Acemoglu
- The Soviet Union achieved extractive growth by using state power to forcibly relocate resources from highly unproductive agriculture into industry, generating rapid catch-up growth for about 40 years; China is doing the same kind of catch-up growth under extractive institutions, so unless China fundamentally changes its political institutions, its growth—like Soviet Russia's—will be short-lived.Daron Acemoglu on Why Nations Fail
- The correlation between distance from the equator and per capita income is largely accidental, not causal; geographic factors are not a good explanatory framework for understanding prosperity and poverty.Daron Acemoglu
- American good institutions (the Jamestown headright system, smallholder property, the general assembly, and ultimately the Declaration of Independence) arose not because Europeans imported ideas but in reaction to British power and against the wishes of colonial owners—success came from local conditions making European strategies of dominance unsuccessful.Daron Acemoglu
- China is unique among despotic, extractive states in systematically trying to lead in innovation (AI, telecom, digital tech) while maintaining despotic Communist Party control; Acemoglu predicts this will not be a complete failure nor a huge success because the most radical innovation requires the individualism and experimentation that despotic control suppresses.Daron Acemoglu
- The theory has three parts: (1) institutions and the incentives they create are central to prosperity; (2) bad extractive institutions exist not through stupidity or ignorance but through conflict of interest, as those controlling power impose their preferred policies even when harmful to society; and (3) institutions change over time, explaining why societies diverge.Daron Acemoglu on Why Nations Fail
- Argentina became rich despite extractive institutions because of resources, but this came back to bite it: when a country becomes wealthy from resources while its institutions are deeply extractive, conflict arises and people use the institutions to enrich themselves—producing Argentina's 20th-century pattern of coups, counter-coups, and repressive populist democracy.Daron Acemoglu on Why Nations Fail
- There is grounds for optimism that the profession is returning to institutional questions, as shown by elite economists like Shleifer (legal origins), Acemoglu and Robinson (inclusive vs extractive institutions in Why Nations Fail), and Besley (Pillars of Prosperity) bringing institutions to the forefront — reviving concepts from Olson, Buchanan, and ultimately Smith's inquiry into the nature and causes of the wealth of nations.Peter Boettke on Living Economics