Conversations with Tyler - Jared Diamond
What this covers
Tyler Cowen interviews Jared Diamond, and the conversation moves between his long-run explanations of history and a narrower question: when does one person change what happens? Diamond restates the argument of Guns, Germs, and Steel. The domestication candidates of the Fertile Crescent, set against the New World's single big domestic animal, explain why European diseases devastated Native Americans. The Continental Axis Hypothesis explains why crops and inventions spread faster across Eurasia. He credits James Robinson with teaching him the natural experiment, and admits his own comparisons of New Guinea bird populations were cruder than those of Acemoglu and Robinson.
The middle of the conversation is a tour of leaders who did matter. Hitler appears as a charismatic manipulator and gambler whose bets sometimes paid off and sometimes failed. Kennedy is credited chiefly with handling the Cuban Missile Crisis. Diamond argues that Genghis Khan's rise coincided with the wettest steppe period in 2,000 years. He sets out three roles a new religion needs: founder, organizer, and general. Rachel Carson is said to have advanced environmentalism by about a decade. Business examples include Lynda Resnick's $150 million, 18-year bet that created the American pomegranate juice industry. On sports, he explains why business schools study coaching, and describes how John Wooden ran practices.
The contentious turns come late. Diamond attributes England's early industrialization to its island position and credits Botswana's success partly to diamond wealth being shared among about three million people. He also claims New Guineans are on average smarter than Westerners, a claim the material marks as fringe. He ends more optimistic than he was 20 years ago, pointing to Walmart, Unilever, and Chevron, whose interest in sustainability is driven by lawsuit and contract risk.
Diamond argues that individual leaders matter far less than geography, plants and animals, and long-run contingency over large timescales, but matter decisively in specific cases where a leader's personal skill or timing changes outcomes.
- Over long periods, leaders are replaceable and outcomes are driven by environmental and geographic factors such as domesticable species and continental axes.
- Leaders matter most in identifiable cases such as Hitler, Churchill, Kennedy, Bezos, and Wooden, where personal traits or timing made a measurable difference.
- Face-to-face social skill and direct communication are underrated, and their decline shapes which leaders succeed.
Geography, more than institutions or biology, explains divergent historical outcomes across civilizations.
- Europeans brought infectious diseases that killed more Native Americans than swords or horses because the Fertile Crescent had five big domesticable animals, while the New World had only the llama, and the epidemic diseases of the modern world originated from domestic animals, so Native Americans had no diseases to give back to Europeans.
“What killed the most Native Americans was not European swords and horses; it was European infectious diseases.”
- Eurasia's east-west axis let domesticated plants, animals, people, and inventions spread quickly across lands at the same latitude and day length, while the New World's north-south axis slowed diffusion across climate zones.
“It also depended upon the axes of the continents, Eurasia being east-west, the New World being north-south.”
- It is impossible to demonstrate that Europeans became smarter in the 25,000 years since the Lascaux art period, so claims of recent cognitive selection are untestable.
“Oh, how on earth would we demonstrate that Europeans are smarter now than they were 25,000 years ago? There's no way that you could demonstrate that.”
- Europeans did not develop metal tools earlier than New Guineans because of superior intelligence; they lacked metal tools in New Guinea because their agricultural productivity was much lower, which limited surplus for specialization.
“Well, they didn't have metal tools because their agriculture was much less productive.”
- Distance from the equator has not been a major factor in world history because agriculture and state formation originated in Mediterranean-latitude Fertile Crescent, and the most advanced New World societies, the Maya and Incas, were near the equator rather than at high latitudes.
“Most advanced societies were the Maya of the Yucatán and the Incas close to the equator. Distance from the equator, no; it's not been a major factor in world history.”
- England industrialized first because being an island meant it did not need a standing army, avoided invasion since 1066, developed democracy gradually, and sat on the Atlantic coast, which together with Atlantic navigation favored its rise over Spain and Portugal.
“England being an island allowed England not to need an army, gradually to develop democracy.”
- Democracy is productive because it allows ideas to be suggested without a dictator silencing them, and the absence of a standing army in England allowed parliament to become powerful after the 1600s, a shift Diamond links to the Enlightenment and Netherlands' early democracy.
“With democracy, you can suggest an idea, and there's not a dictator who will tell you to shut up.”
- There is no evidence that Europeans have higher IQs than other peoples, and the century-long attempts by European scientists and eugenicists to show this have failed.
“There's no evidence whatsoever for it. There are lots of people who try.”
- Muhammad is harder to evaluate than Christ because we lack information on Arabian weather at his time, and rainfall affects plant growth, feeding babies and armies, so without climate data we cannot tell whether his era was especially propitious for founding a religion.
“We just don't have information on the weather in Arabia at that time. Weather makes a big difference.”
- Because humans cannot be manipulated experimentally, historical and social questions must be answered through natural experiments, comparing cases that differ in one factor, as Diamond did by comparing New Guinea mountains with and without a bird species, and as Acemoglu and Robinson do with institutions.
“It was Jim who taught me the power of natural experiments... On people, we can't do manipulative experiments.”
- Acemoglu and Robinson give less credit to geography and more to institutions than Diamond does, and Diamond sees both as important but believes geography carries more weight for long-run outcomes.
“I think that they give less credit to geography and more credit to institutions than I do.”
- Guns, Germs, and Steel argues that global inequalities reflect the distribution of domesticable plants and animals and the east-west axis of Eurasia versus the north-south axis of the Americas, not superior ability.
“My argument and the argument of others is that it depended upon the distribution of domesticable plants and animals around the world. It also depended upon the axes of the continents, Eurasia being east-west, the New World being north-south.”
Structural forces rather than individual leaders determine long-run societal outcomes.
- In the long run no individual leader has made a lasting difference because over long periods outcomes wash out; even Jesus, whom Diamond names as the strongest candidate, could have been replaced by one of several other prophets of the Roman era had he died in childbirth.
“There has been no unreplaceable leader in human history because over a long time, things wash out.”
- Why whole societies diverged over 10,000 years is explained by the availability of plants and animals for domestication in the Fertile Crescent versus the New World, not by individual leaders; individual leaders matter for shorter-term questions such as why Amazon became the largest everything store.
“The explanation is not individual leaders, but it has to do with plants and animals available for domestication in the Fertile Crescent versus in the New World.”
- Individual leaders have mattered little in Papua New Guinea because the country was not unified until the Australian colonial era, has about 700 languages, and its leaders remain loyal to their tribe, clan, or tribal group rather than to a national identity.
“PNG was not unified until the Australian colonial era, and even today, PNG has something like 700 different languages.”
- Botswana became independent in 1966 as the poorest country in Africa and has been among the richest or second richest for most of the 60 years since, partly because its diamond wealth is divided among about three million people rather than the roughly 100 million in Nigeria.
“The value of the diamonds is divided among only three million people instead of divided among the 100 million people, as in the case of Nigeria.”
- The great leap forward around 80,000 years ago, with finer stone tools, sewn clothing, and later art, may have been caused by changes in the human voice box that enabled complex spoken language, which chimpanzees' vocal anatomy cannot produce.
“My guess is that it might have been changes in the voice box 80,000 years ago that resulted in the great leap forward”
- On average New Guineans are more curious and smarter than Westerners because natural selection in New Guinea favored those who survived a harsh environment and constant warfare, whereas selection in Europe over the last 10,000 years favored survival against infectious diseases rather than intelligence.
“In New Guinea, the main causes of death are dealing with this very difficult environment and dealing with other New Guineans because warfare is constant there.”
Leaders matter most as destroyers, founders, and preventers of catastrophe.
- Hitler was the destructive leader with the largest 20th-century impact because he was ultra-charismatic, a skilled manipulator who deceived Chamberlain, German generals, and his own Nazis, and a risk-taker who gambled everything, with some gambles paying off (France, the Rhineland) and others failing (Stalingrad, the Battle of the Bulge).
“He was a big risk-taker. He was not willing to wait. He was convinced that he would die early, and so he took big risks.”
- A new religion needs three functions: a charismatic founder, an organizer, and often a general to fight opposition; these roles are sometimes played by one person, as with the Mahdi of Sudan and Muhammad.
“a religion needs three things: It needs a charismatic founder, it needs an organizer, and often it needs a general because new religions often face opposition.”
- Among leaders who made a difference in the 20th century, the list of constructive leaders is slightly longer than the list of destructive leaders, so destructive leaders do not dominate merely because destruction is easier.
“the list of constructive leaders is, if anything, slightly longer than the list of destructive leaders.”
- Most celebrated leaders are doers rather than preventers, yet preventers can be enormously consequential; Churchill is a case of a leader who prevented Hitler's conquest of England and then helped defeat Hitler with Roosevelt.
“One can say that Winston Churchill prevented events. He prevented the conquest of England by Hitler.”
- The most important thing John Kennedy did was handle the Cuban Missile Crisis to prevent nuclear war; after the crisis, the US and Soviets learned how close they came, including a Soviet submarine captain who wanted to launch a nuclear missile until other officers stopped him.
“It was the other officers on the crew who prevented the captain, so it was a close call.”
- Conversations among the nine nuclear-armed countries are the main way to limit nuclear war risk, as Russia and the United States established ongoing dialogue after the Cuban Missile Crisis showed how close they had come.
“In short, my answer to your question, what do we need to avoid a nuclear war? Conversations among the nine countries that have nuclear weapons.”
Specific choices and contingent circumstances shape outcomes more than general forces.
- Jeff Bezos created a distinctive customer-focused online everything store, though eBay already existed as an everything store, so the specific form of Amazon depended on one person's choices even as the general category existed.
“There already was an everything store, namely eBay. Jeff Bezos developed a distinctive sort of everything store, an online store that prioritized the customer.”
- Continued use of the Dvorak keyboard reflects sunk investment in learning and existing usage rather than inertia, since young people learn Dvorak and other priorities take precedence over switching to a more efficient layout.
“I would just say we've got too much investment in the Dvorak keyboard.”
- When Chevron brought international lawyers to negotiate with New Guinea villagers, the villagers were more skilled at negotiation, and the next morning they repudiated the previous day's apparent agreement by saying the negotiators who made it did not count and sending new ones.
“The next morning, the New Guineans said, "Oh, no, that agreement, we are forgetting that agreement. The people who made that agreement, they don't count."”
- James Robinson taught Diamond the power of natural experiments, and Diamond adapted this approach from his bird studies in New Guinea, comparing mountains with and without a particular bird species, though his own natural experiments were cruder than those of Acemoglu and Robinson.
“It was Jim who taught me the power of natural experiments. My career was as a laboratory scientist, as a gallbladder scientist”
- Genghis Khan's rise to build the largest land empire was likely contingent on timing and place, because the wettest period on the steppes in 2,000 years coincided with his birth, producing plant growth for feeding armies, while the lack of weather records for Arabia makes Muhammad's contingency harder to assess.
“We've learned recently that the wettest time on the steppes in the last 2,000 years was around the time of Genghis's birth.”
Patient, resourced individuals create what institutions and reproducible systems will not.
- Business school professors study leadership largely through sports coaching because sports are reproducible: teams play weekly under the same rules, with many teams in one league, whereas business outcomes are far harder to replicate and compare.
“In sports, there's a game every week. All the teams play by the same rules. There may be 24 teams in the same league. It's reproducible. Business is not so reproducible.”
- John Wooden's coaching advantage came from planning practices for two and a half to three hours, drilling plays faster and faster until players executed them almost subconsciously, and changing practice groups from five to seven so every reserve had trained with the starting group.
“He trained his players in groups of seven rather than five.”
- The American pomegranate juice industry did not exist until 2002, when about 22 US growers, mostly small farmers, were the only producers; Lynda Resnick's roughly $150 million investment and 18 years before profit made the industry possible, something small farmers or big food companies would not have done.
“It took her 18 years to start making money on pomegranate juice. None of those 22 other farmers had the $150 million to pour in or would have waited 18 years.”
- Wooden's players described him as a life mentor rather than a basketball coach, with Bill Walton saying Wooden made more difference in his life than anyone except his parents, illustrating that basketball functioned as a metaphor for life.
“John Wooden made more difference in my life than anyone other than my mother and father.”
- Large corporations such as Coca-Cola and Nestlé would never have allowed a branch of their business to spend $150 million with no profit for 18 years, so only an individual with deep pockets and patience could create a new industry of this kind.
“The big companies like Coca-Cola and Nestlé, they never would have permitted a branch of their industry to sink $150 million and not make a profit for 18 years.”
Leaders can be tested across domains but judged only in hindsight, apart from fame.
- Diamond will not judge leaders still in office, such as Angela Merkel and Donald Trump, because their historical significance cannot be assessed until long after their time.
“I won't pass judgment on leaders who are still active today because premature.”
- Because communication through telephones, radio, computers, and the internet is indirect, students at UCLA have shown a shocking deterioration in writing and speaking skills in recent decades, since they are not developing social skills.
“Because I teach at UCLA, I've seen the shocking deterioration of writing skills and speaking skills in UCLA students in the last several decades. Why? Because the internet communication is indirect now.”
- Politicians who are well known through social media are not necessarily politically or socially skilled, because their communication is indirect, so fame and effectiveness come apart.
“Well known, yes. Politically skilled and socially skilled, no.”
- PNG's founding president did not make a big mess but was not as spectacularly successful as Seretse Khama, the founding president of Botswana.
“He didn't make a big mess. On the other hand, he wasn't as spectacularly successful as Seretse Khama, the founding president of Botswana.”
- John Wooden won national championships both with and without his star recruits Walton and Alcindor, so recruiting was the least of his talents.
“He won national championships with Walton and with Alcindor, but he also won national championships without them.”
- Profits, Prophets, Coaches, and Kings is not an error term for Guns, Germs, and Steel but a different book asking a different question on a different timescale.
“No, I would just say it's a different book about a different question on a different timescale.”
- Diamond's new book shows that leadership methods used in business and sports can be tested under common rules and repeated games, and this reproducibility is what allows leader effects to be assessed across domains.
“It turns out that there are common questions and common methods used for studying leaders in these different spheres.”
Cautious optimism about the environment rests on corporate interest and young people's engagement.
- Diamond is more optimistic than 20 years ago because big businesses such as Walmart, Unilever, and Chevron have become increasingly interested in environmental sustainability, partly because environmental failures risk lawsuits and loss of contracts.
“Chevron is and was ultra-cautious in the oil fields because they knew that if they made a mess, New Guineans would sue them.”
- Cowen's proposed view that Australia could solve water problems through desalination and solar power at a cost of about 2 percent of GDP, roughly one year's growth, is not yet demonstrated, and Diamond says the outcome remains to be seen.
“We shall see. It has not happened yet.”
- Wind and solar account for about 10 to 15 percent of US energy production, while nuclear power supplies roughly 85 to 90 percent of France's energy, and tidal and geothermal energy are being developed as additional sources.
“About 85 percent or 90 percent of the energy in France comes from nuclear energy.”
- Asking for the single most important thing is misguided because the world is complicated; the most important issues to get right are climate change, inequality, and nuclear risk, just as a happy marriage depends on getting many things right.
“My answer is always the single most important thing is not to look for the single most important thing, because the world is complicated.”
- Young people have become much more interested in the environment than they were 25 years ago, which makes Diamond cautiously optimistic about the future, as illustrated by his own sons marching for rainforest protection as children.
“Twenty-five years ago, young people were not much interested in the environment. Now they've got a lot interested in the environment.”
Carson's public advocacy produced policy effects and changed how scientists communicate.
- When Carson wrote, professional scientists believed that writing for the public meant you were washed up as a scientist, and so the first scientists to succeed at public writing, Paul Ehrlich and Carl Sagan, only did so about 20 years after Carson.
“the belief among scientists, professional scientists, was that if you write for the public, it's because you're washed up as a scientist.”
- Rachel Carson's Silent Spring moved the environmental movement forward by roughly a decade, and the day after publication Senator Ribicoff announced a government investigation into toxic chemicals, showing a direct policy effect.
“At minimum, Rachel Carson jumped out of the environmental movement about a decade before it would have been jumpstarted.”
- Carson succeeded partly because she was not a university professor, so she could not be accused of prostituting herself, she wrote beautifully, read her texts aloud, and remained calm on television while a chemical company spokesman appeared to lose composure.
“She was a mild-mannered person, not a vigorous arguer like Carl Sagan.”
- Diamond estimates the chance of a good environmental outcome at 51 percent and a bad outcome at 49 percent, a cautiously optimistic forecast.
“I would say the chances are 51 percent that we will have a good outcome and only 49 percent that we will have a bad outcome.”
Production difficulty, durable demand, and reputation shape business and consumer behavior.
- Pomegranate juice is much harder to make than orange juice because the value sits in the hard rind and tiny seeds, so industrial production requires a tower that squeezes the whole fruit including the rind.
“The way that pomegranate juice is now made on a large scale consists of a three-story tower that squeezes the entire pomegranate, including the rind.”
- Natural diamonds remain popular despite artificial alternatives having existed for a while, as shown by Diamond's son buying a natural diamond for his fiancee, which suggests demand for natural diamonds is durable.
“We've had artificial diamonds for quite a while now. Despite that, natural diamonds are still very popular.”
- Chevron was ultra-cautious in its New Guinea oil fields because New Guineans would sue for environmental damage, and a poor environmental record would cost it contracts for Norwegian oil fields.
“Chevron is and was ultra-cautious in the oil fields because they knew that if they made a mess, New Guineans would sue them.”
Diamond's upbringing, routines, and bird fieldwork shaped his interests and calm temperament.
- New Guinea has the most beautiful birds in the world, the birds of paradise, and bowerbirds, which build the most complex structures of any animal besides humans, with males decorating bowers with hundreds of blue fruits, red flowers, and mushrooms.
“New Guinea has bowerbirds, the animals that build the most complex structures other than us humans.”
- Diamond plans to synthesize his fieldwork across New Guinea's ten outlying mountain ranges to explain why some bird species colonized every one of them while others colonized none, because birds are the easiest animals to observe for questions about colonization.
“why some New Guinea birds have colonized every one of those outlying New Guinea mountains while other New Guinea birds have colonized none of them.”
- Diamond has recorded 189 bird species on his Los Angeles street, Stone Canyon Road, which he birdwatches every weekend.
“My list of species for my street is 189 species.”
- Diamond's father, a hematologist and pediatrician, pushed him toward medical science, while his mother, a linguist and concert pianist, taught him to read at three and drilled him in Latin grammar, which gave him his love of languages and music.
“Dad shaped my career in that direction. My mother was a linguist and a teacher. Mom taught me to read when I was three years old.”
- Listening to Bach cantatas each evening, at a pace of one per week, relaxes Diamond and reduces anxiety, and helps him get good sleep, a routine he adopted to replace evening work on his book.
“It means that in the evening, I'm relaxed and I'm not fretting. I'm not wasting my time getting anxious. I get good sleep.”
- Diamond's first Latin lessons failed because he memorized vocabulary without grammar, and only after his mother drilled him through grammar each night for a year did he develop his lasting interest in languages.
“I just memorized vocabulary. After a month, I was way out of shape with Latin because I hadn't learned the grammar.”
Diamond's career shift and advice favor big-picture, face-to-face thinking.
- Diamond shifted from gallbladder physiology to big-picture history and geography after his twin sons were born in 1987, realizing their future would depend on those fields, and receiving a MacArthur Fellowship made him feel that he had not delivered enough.
“The combination of the birth of my sons, and the MacArthur Fellowship caused me to switch from medical physiology into writing books on big subjects”
- Several later books by Diamond grew out of chapters of The Third Chimpanzee: one chapter became Guns, Germs, and Steel, another became Collapse, and another became Why Is Sex Fun?
“One chapter of my book, The Third Chimpanzee, my book from 1991, got expanded into Guns, Germs, and Steel.”
- The main lesson for an ambitious 25-year-old seeking consequence is to learn to talk face-to-face and set aside indirect communication, because social skills have deteriorated across generations as most communication has moved to indirect channels.
“The main lesson is learn to talk to people face-to-face and put away your indirect means of communication.”