excess deaths
The number of deaths above the normally expected baseline over a period, used to capture the total mortality impact of an event including indirect effects.
As defined in Don Boudreaux on the Pandemic
Where it comes up · 7
- 270 - What Have We Learned From The Pandemic3 claims
- Tyler Cowen on the Pandemic, Revisited2 claims
- 222 - A Pandemic Of Incompetence2 claims
- Don Boudreaux on the Pandemic1 claim
- Casey Mulligan on Vaccines, the Pandemic, and the FDA1 claim
- 311 - Did Sars-cov-2 Escape From A Lab1 claim
- AMA | February 20221 claim
Most important claims · 10 of 11Search all claims for “excess deaths” →
- The excess-death metric is objective because it counts all-cause deaths during the epidemic against expected baseline, automatically netting out both indirect costs (such as increased suicides) and indirect benefits (fewer motor-vehicle deaths, less iatrogenic harm to patients who stayed home), and reassigning miscoded deaths would not change it; if COPD, asthma, and pneumonia deaths were being mislabeled as COVID, we would see those categories fall.222 - A Pandemic Of Incompetence
- The excess-deaths method (invented by William Farr in 19th-century England) compares actual deaths to expected baseline deaths and captures both direct viral deaths and indirect effects—deaths from untreated cancer, domestic violence—offset by lives saved (fewer car accidents, improved air quality in India and China)—and global estimates put COVID excess deaths around 17 million versus the ~5 million officially counted.270 - What Have We Learned From The Pandemic
- The claim that COVID deaths are overreported due to incentives makes no sense; multiple lines of evidence including cross-national consistency, closed populations like the Diamond Princess and isolated villages, and the excess-death method dating to William Farr show that confirmed US deaths (around 230,000) are actually an underestimate, with probably about 300,000 already dead.222 - A Pandemic Of Incompetence
- Naive cross-country and cross-state COVID comparisons are uninformative because they fail to control for confounders like age, population density, and obesity, and because lockdown is not a 0-1 variable (except perhaps in China) given widespread voluntary self-quarantining—so the data are genuinely messy and resist simple causal inference.Tyler Cowen on the Pandemic, Revisited
- Much of the scientific community is conflicted on origins because risky pathogen and gain-of-function research was endorsed not just by funding agencies and research institutes but by publishers and journal editors who published glowing things about it, making it hard for them to U-turn and confront that this work might have caused a million American and some 20 million excess global deaths.311 - Did Sars-cov-2 Escape From A Lab
- Lockdowns do work for respiratory viruses if people actually stop co-mingling, as demonstrated by Australia and New Zealand's minimal excess mortality; the US 'failure' was due to non-compliance, and the claim that 'lockdowns don't work' usually conflates the finding that stay-at-home orders add little once schools and businesses are already closed—which is itself a functional lockdown.270 - What Have We Learned From The Pandemic
- Because COVID killed mainly its most vulnerable victims who would likely have died shortly thereafter, excess fatalities over the next year or two will likely run lower than average, making excess deaths over several years the best metric for measuring COVID's true impact.Don Boudreaux on the Pandemic
- COVID will ultimately kill about a million Americans (with excess deaths reaching that figure), disable roughly five million more with lasting organ and neurological damage, and impose roughly $16 trillion in losses ($8T economic, $8T from death/disability), making it a once-in-a-century catastrophe exceeding the Great Depression in economic impact.270 - What Have We Learned From The Pandemic
- The US (and some other countries) lost more life-years from trying to avoid COVID than COVID itself took, because lockdowns drove a large increase in non-COVID deaths (alcohol, drugs, traffic, homicide, diabetes, heart, stroke) concentrated in younger people; COVID deaths have basically stopped while these excess deaths continue, suggesting the disruption of beneficial human cooperation was the root cause.Casey Mulligan on Vaccines, the Pandemic, and the FDA
- Carroll's leading candidates for global catastrophic risks over the next 50 years are nuclear war (operational weapons remain and proliferation only increases) and bioterrorism/pandemics (COVID already caused over 20 million excess deaths, within an order of magnitude of 100 million, and a more lethal pathogen that is infectious before symptomatic would be devastating), with solar flares as an under-considered wildcard given we have no data on millennium-scale events.AMA | February 2022